RE: 1943!
Posted: Wed Dec 03, 2014 5:45 pm
Supplies are finally rising... 8/10K every day!...but from now on it will be a long way to stockpile enough for late war theatres... 2.7M now...far from being enough.
What's your Strategy?
https://forums.matrixgames.com:443/

So you decided to abandon SW OZ after all? What was the calculus behind this?ORIGINAL: GreyJoy
OZ: as soon as he discovered i abbandoned SW Oz, he started to move again towards Kalgoo. Good. Just in time. We're now reinforcing Exmouth with 800 AVs. Don't wanna let him cross the corner easily once he gets back t Perth.
ORIGINAL: Sangeli
So you decided to abandon SW OZ after all? What was the calculus behind this?ORIGINAL: GreyJoy
OZ: as soon as he discovered i abbandoned SW Oz, he started to move again towards Kalgoo. Good. Just in time. We're now reinforcing Exmouth with 800 AVs. Don't wanna let him cross the corner easily once he gets back t Perth.
Ya, that makes sense. I think your biggest problem was going after western OZ and India at the same time. You had enough to establish a good frontier in both regions to delay an Allied push in 43 but with those 3 IDs in Western OZ you lacked the army in India to decisively defeat the Allies there. Overall it's not a bad strategy in my mind but it's a conservative strategy and its success is contingent on Allied counter-moves falling on their head. Against an impatient player it likely could have yielded better results but your opponent was wise not to fall into that trap.ORIGINAL: GreyJoy
ORIGINAL: Sangeli
So you decided to abandon SW OZ after all? What was the calculus behind this?ORIGINAL: GreyJoy
OZ: as soon as he discovered i abbandoned SW Oz, he started to move again towards Kalgoo. Good. Just in time. We're now reinforcing Exmouth with 800 AVs. Don't wanna let him cross the corner easily once he gets back t Perth.
The pop-up of waves of allied subs between Exmouth and Perth made up my mind. To seriously defend SW Oz i would need many more units than i have. At least 3 IDs. Not only for the first line, but also to protect the SLOCs between Port Hedland and Perth. And the KB would be needed permanently if he commits his carriers.
If i didn't have India theatre so active, that would be a valid strategy, but with my flanks exposed in India, i had to give priorities and i decided that defending the Bay of Bengal was much more important than Western Oz.
If i am not mistaken, as long as i hold Exmouth, a direct blow to Java and DEI would be pretty difficult for him. Not impossible, but difficult.
So the same strategic goal (defending the DEI) could be achieved without exposing my flank.
At the same time, shrinking my perimeter till Exmouth woul give me a much easier defensive position and could give the KB the Chance to effectively support the siege of Madras and the defence of Ceylon, at least untill this summer (43).
It's a pity, i know. The western Oz campaign didn't give me the hoped fruits...didn't destroy anything special (LCUs) there and didn't force him to committ a dangerous landing in 1942 (when i still had the upper hand). At leasti gained enough time to create a good line in northern Oz... but, once again, the cost in terms of supplies and fuel has been probably too high for what has effectively been achieved. Another good lesson learnt
ORIGINAL: crsutton
For the Japanese player it all comes down to timing as no position can be held forever. You seem to have a pretty good grip on that. Experience playing both sides helps in a matter like this.
ORIGINAL: witpqs
What are your fort levels at Madras?
Game engine is always calculation airstrike size base on detected ships number, types and size. You cannot expect full KB strike against a few cruisers.ORIGINAL: GreyJoy
ONLY!?!?!!?!?!? This should be the whole KB!!?!?!?
ORIGINAL: MrKane
Game engine is always calculation airstrike size base on detected ships number, types and size. You cannot expect full KB strike against a few cruisers.ORIGINAL: GreyJoy
ONLY!?!?!!?!?!? This should be the whole KB!!?!?!?
ORIGINAL: witpqs
What are your fort levels at Madras?
ORIGINAL: crsutton
Yes, I find fault with Obvert going for a massive siege in Madras. He knows you have one tank division bottled up there and with his superior mobile units should be driving down the open ground between Deli and Calcutta. It is a total waste to use these great units in siege fighting. No Japanese unit at this stage can fight them in open ground. In 1944 the Allies can engage in slugging matches but in early 43 they need to capitalize on their mobility.