Page 8 of 8

RE: Opinions Wanted/Advice Needed

Posted: Tue Apr 17, 2007 7:26 am
by marky
[8|]

uhhh yeah,,,

could u be more of an arrogant self absorbed schmuck?[:)]

RE: Opinions Wanted/Advice Needed

Posted: Tue Apr 17, 2007 1:55 pm
by princep01
Marky, just one person's view, but I believe you owe Divebomber an apogolgy.

This is most cruel as I was enjoying "watching" this game unfold.  I was curious where your Fabian strategy would take the game.  I certainly did not anticipate this end.

Also, as an aside, the invasion of India and N. Australia were certainly seriously considered by the Japanese.  They chose a different approach, but especially the invasion of India was a distinct strategic possibility as expressed well in the book....Empires in the Balance: Japanese Strategic Options in WW2 (the title is probably slightly off, and I forget the authors name (circa 1978).  The author argues that probably the very best strategic chance Japan had was to turn west, subjugate China and then invade India.

RE: Opinions Wanted/Advice Needed

Posted: Tue Apr 17, 2007 3:38 pm
by DuckofTindalos
ORIGINAL: princep01

Marky, just one person's view, but I believe you owe Divebomber an apogolgy.

That would first require comprehension of the gravity of his error... Which is not likely...

And it's not "just one person's view", by the way...

RE: Opinions Wanted/Advice Needed

Posted: Tue Apr 17, 2007 3:56 pm
by princep01
Divebomber, I really enjoyed your AAR and looked forward to reading about the interesting game you and Marky had embarked on.  Thank you for the time and effort you put into the write-ups.  It really helped this relatively new player appreciate the game all the more.  Thanks again.

Terminus, I have opined enough about Marky's behavior. I think I shall simply leave it at that.

However, should Marky read this, I enjoyed watching your defense unfold. As I previously commented, I thought your strategy a bit extreme. But, it fun to watch it unfold.

RE: Opinions Wanted/Advice Needed

Posted: Tue Apr 17, 2007 4:32 pm
by AU Tiger_MatrixForum
"I have a cunning plan milord"

Dive,
A lot of folks were following your AAR judging my the number of hits. I imagine a lot of it was because of your writing style as well as Marky's curious "defense". Our game is at a similar date, so why don't you start an AAR based on ours, and I will start one from my pov, trying to mimic the style.

The strategic situation is very different in China, but not so much in Burma. Also, I have massive reinforcements heading for Alaska and Canada now [;)].

It is just a thought, let me know what you think. And I promise not to post too often in your AAR. [8D]

RE: Opinions Wanted/Advice Needed

Posted: Tue Apr 17, 2007 5:45 pm
by aztez
ORIGINAL: Dive Bomber1

Marky -

You realize, of course, that by entering my AAR, which was clearly marked right in the title "Marky Keep Out" you have ended the game, since I can no longer trust you.

I am very disappointed that you did this because I was enjoying the game.

To everyone who was following this AAR - thank you very much for your interest and your comments.


The first line pretty much sums this up on why this needs to be stopped.

Good luck into your next PBEM.

RE: Opinions Wanted/Advice Needed

Posted: Tue Apr 17, 2007 9:13 pm
by Dive Bomber1
ORIGINAL: princep01

Divebomber, I really enjoyed your AAR and looked forward to reading about the interesting game you and Marky had embarked on.  Thank you for the time and effort you put into the write-ups.  It really helped this relatively new player appreciate the game all the more.  Thanks again.

Terminus, I have opined enough about Marky's behavior. I think I shall simply leave it at that.

However, should Marky read this, I enjoyed watching your defense unfold. As I previously commented, I thought your strategy a bit extreme. But, it fun to watch it unfold.

Thanks for your comments and support. Since AuTiger has asked me to write an AAR to match his I will. It ought to be quite a bit different because 'Tiger has stood up to me and caused me all kinds of headaches. [X(]

RE: Opinions Wanted/Advice Needed

Posted: Tue Apr 17, 2007 9:14 pm
by Dive Bomber1
ORIGINAL: AU Tiger

"I have a cunning plan milord"

Dive,
A lot of folks were following your AAR judging my the number of hits. I imagine a lot of it was because of your writing style as well as Marky's curious "defense". Our game is at a similar date, so why don't you start an AAR based on ours, and I will start one from my pov, trying to mimic the style.

The strategic situation is very different in China, but not so much in Burma. Also, I have massive reinforcements heading for Alaska and Canada now [;)].

It is just a thought, let me know what you think. And I promise not to post too often in your AAR. [8D]

Okay, I'll start tomorrow after I've had a chance to play your next reply.

Thanks -

RE: Opinions Wanted/Advice Needed

Posted: Tue Apr 17, 2007 9:36 pm
by AU Tiger_MatrixForum
No doubt you have seen the number of posting on my AAR, I have just walked about the map with screenshots and a brief explanation for each theater.

I will knock out my turn now.

Getting ready to do a new AAR

Posted: Tue Apr 17, 2007 9:46 pm
by Dive Bomber1
ORIGINAL: AU Tiger

No doubt you have seen the number of posting on my AAR, I have just walked about the map with screenshots and a brief explanation for each theater.

I will knock out my turn now.

That's great! I'll leave it to you to do the screen shots - it won't be long before you won't have to do too many... [;)] [:D]


RE: Getting ready to do a new AAR

Posted: Tue Apr 17, 2007 10:21 pm
by AU Tiger_MatrixForum
That's right. Screenshot after screenshot of the Home Islands as my forces advance.
[:-]