Page 8 of 8

Re: End of the Japanese Empire, Dmitry (Allies) vs LoneRunner (Axis)

Posted: Wed Jul 27, 2022 10:38 am
by EarlyDoors
Wow, can’t believe you resigned

Looked like Allied NM would have gone into a death spiral to me

The losses they were taking were horrendous

Great AAR . Well played both

Re: End of the Japanese Empire, Dmitry (Allies) vs LoneRunner (Axis)

Posted: Wed Jul 27, 2022 10:13 pm
by LoneRunner
EarlyDoors wrote: Wed Jul 27, 2022 10:38 am Wow, can’t believe you resigned

Looked like Allied NM would have gone into a death spiral to me

The losses they were taking were horrendous

Great AAR . Well played both
Thanks EarlyDoors. I've been second-guessing my decision since conceding, heh. It's easy to get depressed when playing the Axis in 44/45.

I agree, Allied national morale was key to my chances to pull out a victory. Here's UK/USA national morale at game end:

UK Morale beg Nov 44 1.png
UK Morale beg Nov 44 1.png (507.75 KiB) Viewed 3759 times
US Morale beg Nov 44 1.png
US Morale beg Nov 44 1.png (510.18 KiB) Viewed 3759 times

Neither was falling as fast as I hoped. But both were, like you said, starting the death spiral. USA was below 75%. As a result unit morale for all USA units was multiplied by .90 every turn. UK wasn't far behind.

German morale was maintaining pretty well. Probably because of all the destroyed low supply Chinese units and sunk battleships:

German Morale beg Nov 44 1.png
German Morale beg Nov 44 1.png (496.89 KiB) Viewed 3759 times

Re: End of the Japanese Empire, Dmitry (Allies) vs LoneRunner (Axis)

Posted: Fri Nov 20, 2026 6:33 am
by wevilc
What a fantastic game & AAR. So instructive and it seemed in the balance until LR resigned. I had never seen (or conceived of) the Japan first strategy. I can think of some counters, most of which are mentioned in the thread already. For someone below average as a player, LR's detailed explanation of the mechanics of warfare in WAW was most interesting & helpful. I even got to see the point of paratroops. Mine usually sit behind the lines wondering what to do.

As LR said, it's a fantastic game with so many decisions to make, strategic, tactical and organisational. You almost need a general staff to play it! And you find out later, sometimes too late, whether a deeply laid plan was a good idea or not, often depending on ill-luck or the genius of the opponent in anticipating it.

I thoroughly enjoyed it & congratulate Dmitry on an epic win and LoneRunner on telling us a great story (while teaching about the game).

Re: End of the Japanese Empire, Dmitry (Allies) vs LoneRunner (Axis)

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 4:12 pm
by LoneRunner
wevilc wrote: Fri Nov 20, 2026 6:33 am What a fantastic game & AAR. So instructive and it seemed in the balance until LR resigned. I had never seen (or conceived of) the Japan first strategy. I can think of some counters, most of which are mentioned in the thread already. For someone below average as a player, LR's detailed explanation of the mechanics of warfare in WAW was most interesting & helpful. I even got to see the point of paratroops. Mine usually sit behind the lines wondering what to do.

As LR said, it's a fantastic game with so many decisions to make, strategic, tactical and organisational. You almost need a general staff to play it! And you find out later, sometimes too late, whether a deeply laid plan was a good idea or not, often depending on ill-luck or the genius of the opponent in anticipating it.

I thoroughly enjoyed it & congratulate Dmitry on an epic win and LoneRunner on telling us a great story (while teaching about the game).
Thank you for your kind comments Wevilc. Yes, Dmitry is an excellent WAW player. I really enjoyed his creative strategy with the Allies. I'm still kicking myself for quitting too early, haha. EarlyDoors was right. The USA had incurred heavy losses and had entered the morale death spiral. And my soon to be developed dreaded level 5 elite tanks would have kicked Allied butt. I think a lot of us quit WAW games too early. It's hard not to throw in the towel when Russia gets crushed or Japan is invaded.

I noticed that you are viewing a lot of the old AARs. Good show. That's exactly how I learned to play WAW.

Re: End of the Japanese Empire, Dmitry (Allies) vs LoneRunner (Axis)

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 11:30 pm
by wevilc
LoneRunner wrote: Sat Nov 21, 2026 4:12 pm
wevilc wrote: Fri Nov 20, 2026 6:33 am What a fantastic game & AAR. So instructive and it seemed in the balance until LR resigned. I had never seen (or conceived of) the Japan first strategy. I can think of some counters, most of which are mentioned in the thread already. For someone below average as a player, LR's detailed explanation of the mechanics of warfare in WAW was most interesting & helpful. I even got to see the point of paratroops. Mine usually sit behind the lines wondering what to do.

As LR said, it's a fantastic game with so many decisions to make, strategic, tactical and organisational. You almost need a general staff to play it! And you find out later, sometimes too late, whether a deeply laid plan was a good idea or not, often depending on ill-luck or the genius of the opponent in anticipating it.

I thoroughly enjoyed it & congratulate Dmitry on an epic win and LoneRunner on telling us a great story (while teaching about the game).
Thank you for your kind comments Wevilc. Yes, Dmitry is an excellent WAW player. I really enjoyed his creative strategy with the Allies. I'm still kicking myself for quitting too early, haha. EarlyDoors was right. The USA had incurred heavy losses and had entered the morale death spiral. And my soon to be developed dreaded level 5 elite tanks would have kicked Allied butt. I think a lot of us quit WAW games too early. It's hard not to throw in the towel when Russia gets crushed or Japan is invaded.

I noticed that you are viewing a lot of the old AARs. Good show. That's exactly how I learned to play WAW.
I confess I was a bit surprised by the resignation but then it's tough to defend Germany from 5 directions at once and anyway, I'm no judge. Yes, I'm lapping up the AARs learning and laughing all the time.