Page 76 of 103
RE: Swordfish II
Posted: Mon Aug 10, 2009 11:55 pm
by jcjordan
Not sure if it's been mentioned but No.36 RAF w/ Vildebeests won't upgrade to anything else for whatever reason even w/ pdu on. My unit is set to upgrade to Vildebeests & when I click on it to change it to something else there's nothing on the list but Vildebeests so it'll never upgrade to anything due to a/c db settings. The other Vildebeest Sqdn being Aussie shows other OZ planes but not this Brit one.
Also in the a/c db, why are the Allied bomber type checked hvy, med, lt, attack, etc but none of the IJ bombers are? [&:]
RE: Admiral's Edition Air War Thread
Posted: Tue Aug 11, 2009 1:02 am
by Kull
ORIGINAL: Jim D Burns
Not sure if this has been pointed out yet or not. Take a look at the bomb loads, I think it's supposed to carry 100lb bombs for normal range missions.
Jim
That's hilarious. Assuming those really ARE 20 lb bombs, I can't escape this visual image of the guy in back, leaning over the edge of the airframe, hand-dropping them!
RE: Admiral's Edition Air War Thread
Posted: Tue Aug 11, 2009 3:34 am
by jww60
This is certainly not a major issue:
Is the P-36A Mohawk supposed to be listed as a Float Fighter?
The "Amphibian" box is checked for it in slot 328 in the Aircraft database in all the official scenarios except Guadalcanal.
Jeff
RE: AE Air Issues and Air OOB Issues
Posted: Tue Aug 11, 2009 8:50 am
by Speedysteve
ORIGINAL: timtom
If it's an R&D a/c it should be greater than zero - I think - but it's one for Andrew again. Any particular R&D factory you've got in mind?
Hey up,
All of these have 0 replace rate and 0 production rate and are rd planes set for the future in Grand Campaign 2:
Hurricane 1 Trop
" 11a "
DC-2
F2A-2P Buffalo
R-12
B339-23
G-2
P-39D 42/08
Boomerang C-12
F-10 Mitchell
PV-1N Ventura
P70A-1 Havoc
F4U2
Swordfish II
PB2Y-5 Coronado
PV-2 Harpoon
Boomerang C-19
B25J 11 Mitchell
PBY-6A
P-61C Black Widow
Am I missing something here or are factories due to upgrade to these guys when they are produceable?
RE: Admiral's Edition Air War Thread
Posted: Tue Aug 11, 2009 12:52 pm
by Terminus
ORIGINAL: jww60
This is certainly not a major issue:
Is the P-36A Mohawk supposed to be listed as a Float Fighter?
The "Amphibian" box is checked for it in slot 328 in the Aircraft database in all the official scenarios except Guadalcanal.
Jeff
It's already been fixed in the first patch.
RE: Admiral's Edition Air War Thread
Posted: Tue Aug 11, 2009 1:22 pm
by jww60
ORIGINAL: Terminus
ORIGINAL: jww60
This is certainly not a major issue:
Is the P-36A Mohawk supposed to be listed as a Float Fighter?
The "Amphibian" box is checked for it in slot 328 in the Aircraft database in all the official scenarios except Guadalcanal.
Jeff
It's already been fixed in the first patch.
Thank you
RE: Swordfish II
Posted: Tue Aug 11, 2009 3:56 pm
by bsq
ORIGINAL: jcjordan
Not sure if it's been mentioned but No.36 RAF w/ Vildebeests won't upgrade to anything else for whatever reason even w/ pdu on. My unit is set to upgrade to Vildebeests & when I click on it to change it to something else there's nothing on the list but Vildebeests so it'll never upgrade to anything due to a/c db settings. The other Vildebeest Sqdn being Aussie shows other OZ planes but not this Brit one.
Also in the a/c db, why are the Allied bomber type checked hvy, med, lt, attack, etc but none of the IJ bombers are? [&:]
Because they suffered almost the same fate as 100 Sqn similarly equipped.
From their history:
Heavy losses resulted in the aircraft of No 36 and No 100 Squadrons being pooled and eventually withdrawn to Java and Sumatra where last two were lost on 7 March, effectively ending the career of No 36 Squadron, which ceased to exist on the 8th (March 1941).
RE: Swordfish II
Posted: Tue Aug 11, 2009 11:06 pm
by jcjordan
ORIGINAL: bsq
ORIGINAL: jcjordan
Not sure if it's been mentioned but No.36 RAF w/ Vildebeests won't upgrade to anything else for whatever reason even w/ pdu on. My unit is set to upgrade to Vildebeests & when I click on it to change it to something else there's nothing on the list but Vildebeests so it'll never upgrade to anything due to a/c db settings. The other Vildebeest Sqdn being Aussie shows other OZ planes but not this Brit one.
Also in the a/c db, why are the Allied bomber type checked hvy, med, lt, attack, etc but none of the IJ bombers are? [&:]
Because they suffered almost the same fate as 100 Sqn similarly equipped.
From their history:
Heavy losses resulted in the aircraft of No 36 and No 100 Squadrons being pooled and eventually withdrawn to Java and Sumatra where last two were lost on 7 March, effectively ending the career of No 36 Squadron, which ceased to exist on the 8th (March 1941).
Yes that may be history but w/ pdu on I should be able to change it to something else if I wanted to if the unit is still in play before it's w/d date [&:] And it does come back later on in the game w/ Wellingtons.
Another question along these lines for the Devs/Airteam guys, say I was to lose an air unit before it's w/d date & it was attached to a restricted command be it by base overrun or sunk on ship, does it come back if it has a d/b entry to? Like No.36 RAF is at start & a restricted command & I lose it in Malaya but in the db it has a 2nd entry to come back later on in the war but in the db that isn't X'd as an active unit (many things like this in air group db for units that w/d but come back later in war)
RE: Swordfish II
Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 5:03 am
by Sardaukar
Computer seems to have tendency to change CAP to 100 % LRCAP without mentioning it anywhere, for example, protecting nearby TF under attack. It would be OK, if it would revert then back to original orders. But no, it stays 100% LRCAP and you have no way to know this unless you happen to check your air units during next turn. This leads to massive ops losses and pilot fatigue within couple of turns.
RE: Swordfish II
Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 6:36 am
by herwin
The following problem might be worth looking at:
message thread on follow and meet commands
RE: AE Air Issues and Air OOB Issues
Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 7:58 am
by Speedysteve
ORIGINAL: Speedy
ORIGINAL: timtom
If it's an R&D a/c it should be greater than zero - I think - but it's one for Andrew again. Any particular R&D factory you've got in mind?
Hey up,
All of these have 0 replace rate and 0 production rate and are rd planes set for the future in Grand Campaign 2:
Hurricane 1 Trop
" 11a "
DC-2
F2A-2P Buffalo
R-12
B339-23
G-2
P-39D 42/08
Boomerang C-12
F-10 Mitchell
PV-1N Ventura
P70A-1 Havoc
F4U2
Swordfish II
PB2Y-5 Coronado
PV-2 Harpoon
Boomerang C-19
B25J 11 Mitchell
PBY-6A
P-61C Black Widow
Am I missing something here or are factories due to upgrade to these guys when they are produceable?
Bump
RE: AE Air Issues and Air OOB Issues
Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 12:00 pm
by fcam1387
I've noticed that some Claude and Nate squadrons have no upgrade path to the Zero and Nate, respectively. This is an issue when playing the AI where you have to de-select PDUs. Is this intentional?
RE: Swordfish II
Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 7:03 pm
by timtom
ORIGINAL: mikemike
Shouldn't the Kawasaki Ha-60 engine be the Kawasaki Ha-40?
Engines represents an amalgam of different types, hence we use the joint Army/Navy system of designation whenever possible - in this case "Ha-60" for the engine formely known as Ha-40.
ORIGINAL: jcjordan
ORIGINAL: bsq
ORIGINAL: jcjordan
Not sure if it's been mentioned but No.36 RAF w/ Vildebeests won't upgrade to anything else for whatever reason even w/ pdu on. My unit is set to upgrade to Vildebeests & when I click on it to change it to something else there's nothing on the list but Vildebeests so it'll never upgrade to anything due to a/c db settings. The other Vildebeest Sqdn being Aussie shows other OZ planes but not this Brit one.
Also in the a/c db, why are the Allied bomber type checked hvy, med, lt, attack, etc but none of the IJ bombers are? [&:]
Because they suffered almost the same fate as 100 Sqn similarly equipped.
From their history:
Heavy losses resulted in the aircraft of No 36 and No 100 Squadrons being pooled and eventually withdrawn to Java and Sumatra where last two were lost on 7 March, effectively ending the career of No 36 Squadron, which ceased to exist on the 8th (March 1941).
Yes that may be history but w/ pdu on I should be able to change it to something else if I wanted to if the unit is still in play before it's w/d date [&:] And it does come back later on in the game w/ Wellingtons.
I'm a tad puzzled by this one. The returning 36 Sqn redeploys to the MTO 5/43 (-ish) so is set to disband (taking a/c and pilots with it), however the first iteration is to withdraw (a/c and pilots to pool as default). Will have to take a closer look.
ORIGINAL: jcjordan
Another question along these lines for the Devs/Airteam guys, say I was to lose an air unit before it's w/d date & it was attached to a restricted command be it by base overrun or sunk on ship, does it come back if it has a d/b entry to? Like No.36 RAF is at start & a restricted command & I lose it in Malaya but in the db it has a 2nd entry to come back later on in the war but in the db that isn't X'd as an active unit (many things like this in air group db for units that w/d but come back later in war)
The 2nd entry should appear regardless just as long as the 1st entry is permanently out of play. Don't worry about them not being "X'd" (marked as active) in the DB.
ORIGINAL: Sardaukar
Computer seems to have tendency to change CAP to 100 % LRCAP without mentioning it anywhere, for example, protecting nearby TF under attack. It would be OK, if it would revert then back to original orders. But no, it stays 100% LRCAP and you have no way to know this unless you happen to check your air units during next turn. This leads to massive ops losses and pilot fatigue within couple of turns.
Known bug.
Wrong tree? [:)]
ORIGINAL: Speedy
ORIGINAL: Speedy
ORIGINAL: timtom
If it's an R&D a/c it should be greater than zero - I think - but it's one for Andrew again. Any particular R&D factory you've got in mind?
Hey up,
All of these have 0 replace rate and 0 production rate and are rd planes set for the future in Grand Campaign 2:
Hurricane 1 Trop
" 11a "
DC-2
F2A-2P Buffalo
R-12
B339-23
G-2
P-39D 42/08
Boomerang C-12
F-10 Mitchell
PV-1N Ventura
P70A-1 Havoc
F4U2
Swordfish II
PB2Y-5 Coronado
PV-2 Harpoon
Boomerang C-19
B25J 11 Mitchell
PBY-6A
P-61C Black Widow
Am I missing something here or are factories due to upgrade to these guys when they are produceable?
Bump
Jeez, some people...[:'(]
Anyway, some of them do and some don't. The last six on that list should come into production via upgrades of factories. The rest a limited issue and will arrive with units, sometimes in some numbers.
ORIGINAL: fcam1387
I've noticed that some Claude and Nate squadrons have no upgrade path to the Zero and [Oscar], respectively. This is an issue when playing the AI where you have to de-select PDUs. Is this intentional?
Propably, but difficult to say without knowing which units are being referred to [:)]
RE: Swordfish II
Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 9:29 pm
by jcjordan
ORIGINAL: timtom
ORIGINAL: mikemike
Shouldn't the Kawasaki Ha-60 engine be the Kawasaki Ha-40?
Engines represents an amalgam of different types, hence we use the joint Army/Navy system of designation whenever possible - in this case "Ha-60" for the engine formely known as Ha-40.
ORIGINAL: jcjordan
ORIGINAL: bsq
Because they suffered almost the same fate as 100 Sqn similarly equipped.
From their history:
Heavy losses resulted in the aircraft of No 36 and No 100 Squadrons being pooled and eventually withdrawn to Java and Sumatra where last two were lost on 7 March, effectively ending the career of No 36 Squadron, which ceased to exist on the 8th (March 1941).
Yes that may be history but w/ pdu on I should be able to change it to something else if I wanted to if the unit is still in play before it's w/d date [&:] And it does come back later on in the game w/ Wellingtons.
I'm a tad puzzled by this one. The returning 36 Sqn redeploys to the MTO 5/43 (-ish) so is set to disband (taking a/c and pilots with it), however the first iteration is to withdraw (a/c and pilots to pool as default). Will have to take a closer look.
ORIGINAL: jcjordan
Another question along these lines for the Devs/Airteam guys, say I was to lose an air unit before it's w/d date & it was attached to a restricted command be it by base overrun or sunk on ship, does it come back if it has a d/b entry to? Like No.36 RAF is at start & a restricted command & I lose it in Malaya but in the db it has a 2nd entry to come back later on in the war but in the db that isn't X'd as an active unit (many things like this in air group db for units that w/d but come back later in war)
The 2nd entry should appear regardless just as long as the 1st entry is permanently out of play. Don't worry about them not being "X'd" (marked as active) in the DB.
ORIGINAL: Sardaukar
Computer seems to have tendency to change CAP to 100 % LRCAP without mentioning it anywhere, for example, protecting nearby TF under attack. It would be OK, if it would revert then back to original orders. But no, it stays 100% LRCAP and you have no way to know this unless you happen to check your air units during next turn. This leads to massive ops losses and pilot fatigue within couple of turns.
Known bug.
Wrong tree? [:)]
ORIGINAL: Speedy
ORIGINAL: Speedy
Hey up,
All of these have 0 replace rate and 0 production rate and are rd planes set for the future in Grand Campaign 2:
Hurricane 1 Trop
" 11a "
DC-2
F2A-2P Buffalo
R-12
B339-23
G-2
P-39D 42/08
Boomerang C-12
F-10 Mitchell
PV-1N Ventura
P70A-1 Havoc
F4U2
Swordfish II
PB2Y-5 Coronado
PV-2 Harpoon
Boomerang C-19
B25J 11 Mitchell
PBY-6A
P-61C Black Widow
Am I missing something here or are factories due to upgrade to these guys when they are produceable?
Bump
Jeez, some people...[:'(]
Anyway, some of them do and some don't. The last six on that list should come into production via upgrades of factories. The rest a limited issue and will arrive with units, sometimes in some numbers.
ORIGINAL: fcam1387
I've noticed that some Claude and Nate squadrons have no upgrade path to the Zero and [Oscar], respectively. This is an issue when playing the AI where you have to de-select PDUs. Is this intentional?
Propably, but difficult to say without knowing which units are being referred to [:)]
Thanks TT
RE: Swordfish II
Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 11:45 pm
by Mynok
Sasebo Ku S-1 and Kawai Det are the Claudes that do not upgrade.
RE: Swordfish II
Posted: Thu Aug 13, 2009 2:27 am
by fcam1387
Yes, I've found the:
Yamada-Det S-2
Saesbo KU S-1
3rd Hicotai IMAF
RE: Admiral's Edition Air War Thread
Posted: Thu Aug 13, 2009 3:37 am
by Flying Tiger
ORIGINAL: Kull
ORIGINAL: Jim D Burns
Not sure if this has been pointed out yet or not. Take a look at the bomb loads, I think it's supposed to carry 100lb bombs for normal range missions.
Jim
That's hilarious. Assuming those really ARE 20 lb bombs, I can't escape this visual image of the guy in back, leaning over the edge of the airframe, hand-dropping them!
the Audax is listed as a twin! not sure where that extra engine is hidden though??
RE: Admiral's Edition Air War Thread
Posted: Thu Aug 13, 2009 8:06 am
by Fletcher
I have a light dude with recon/naval search experience in the JNAF units. I.e. Yamada Det T-1 with 6 C5M2 Babs has 6 aircrafts, and the best experience pilot has naval search experience with 43 and recon with 80. I am certainly disagree, they were naval pilots working for the navy. C5M2 Babs in the navy works for naval search vs. Ki-15 Babs (the same model for the Army) that works for ground recon. Comments will be wellcomed.
Thanks in advance.
Regards.
RE: Admiral's Edition Air War Thread
Posted: Thu Aug 13, 2009 9:21 am
by steveh11Matrix
I don't know if this has been raised yet, but in view of the manual saying to the effect that extended range is for emergencies only, shouldn't the default range setting for air groups be "normal" and not "extended" as it is at the moment?
Steve.
RE: Swordfish II
Posted: Thu Aug 13, 2009 9:26 am
by Speedysteve
ORIGINAL: timtom
ORIGINAL: Speedy
ORIGINAL: Speedy
Hey up,
All of these have 0 replace rate and 0 production rate and are rd planes set for the future in Grand Campaign 2:
Hurricane 1 Trop
" 11a "
DC-2
F2A-2P Buffalo
R-12
B339-23
G-2
P-39D 42/08
Boomerang C-12
F-10 Mitchell
PV-1N Ventura
P70A-1 Havoc
F4U2
Swordfish II
PB2Y-5 Coronado
PV-2 Harpoon
Boomerang C-19
B25J 11 Mitchell
PBY-6A
P-61C Black Widow
Am I missing something here or are factories due to upgrade to these guys when they are produceable?
Bump
Jeez, some people...[:'(]
Anyway, some of them do and some don't. The last six on that list should come into production via upgrades of factories. The rest a limited issue and will arrive with units, sometimes in some numbers.
Happy to help[:'(]