RE: MWiF Global War Hot-Seat (AAR)
Posted: Tue Jan 24, 2012 5:05 pm
About USSR builds: rebuild the 5-1 GAR this turn, than start building the MIL (empty the pool). The GAR is a good unit and just as cheap as the MIL. I wouldn't scrap any INF at this moment, since you probably need all your build points to empty the MIL pool. You can wait and see what happens next turn with regards to losses (I expect them to be high, but hey: perhaps you get lucky and the summer turn ends soon).
To bad you didn't try to kill that German MECH in Persia. If it had been ground struck, the worst thing which might happen was that your CAV was going to get killed in exchange of that MECH, since a face down unit means a +1 on the roll. A 1 on the assault table wasn't going to kill Zhukov at all...
In Persia: there is a serious lack of Axis FTR's. I would suggest trying to put USSR FTR's into that area ASAP, since they can put up a nice fight if the Stuka's are going to ground strike. On the whole, the Persian area looks like the only area at this moment where German Ground strikes are possible (apart from places like Riga and Odessa). That's good and bad, good, since this means the USSR will be able to stay organised at the other frontlines, bad, because of the position Zhukov is in at the moment. Now, if you get the initiative as the Allies: choose to go first, so you can strengthen the lines and perhaps get some FTRs towards Persia and move Zhukov towards the wood hex. With Stuka's around, I don't like his position at all at the moment. Remember: you should defend the Caucasus until the last man is dead and Zhukov should be the last one to die, not the first... The other fronts, you might retreat from, but not the Persian mountains.
On reïnforcements: I suggest putting at least another 3 units into this area. The fronts in the Ukraine and around Vitebsk should do with cheap units, the Persian mountains however, need to get at least units who have a combat factor of 5 or higher.
The CW should, I'm afraid, continue to build INF type units to strengthen places like India for this turn. By the way: how did the Japanese manage to grab 7 oil points? Weren't you using the NEI and Burma oil for reorganisation or was this oil which simply wasn't used for reorganisation, due to the fact that the CW didn't need that oil for reorganisation and couldn't transport to the factories? I always try to use oil which is as close to the enemy as possible for reorganisation. I don't want to give the Japanese my precious stocks. I rather use Canada to build up my oil reserves. Just my two cents on this...
Can you give us an update on where the USA has got it's TRS and AMPH's at the moment? If I were the USA, my first thing in the war would be to have two TRS sitting in Pago Pago with INF units there and two in San Diego with INF type units. Than, as my first naval move: those INF in the USA are transferred into Pago Pago and the INF there go to New Zealand and/or Australia (depends on how many CW units are there). This move usually means Australia and New Zealand will be save from Japanese invasions for the rest of the game.
By the way: I like your reasoning for moving tension by choosing those options. However: the only thing I would have done was to embargo the Japanese first. He's getting far to many oil and I don't like that at all.
To bad you didn't try to kill that German MECH in Persia. If it had been ground struck, the worst thing which might happen was that your CAV was going to get killed in exchange of that MECH, since a face down unit means a +1 on the roll. A 1 on the assault table wasn't going to kill Zhukov at all...
In Persia: there is a serious lack of Axis FTR's. I would suggest trying to put USSR FTR's into that area ASAP, since they can put up a nice fight if the Stuka's are going to ground strike. On the whole, the Persian area looks like the only area at this moment where German Ground strikes are possible (apart from places like Riga and Odessa). That's good and bad, good, since this means the USSR will be able to stay organised at the other frontlines, bad, because of the position Zhukov is in at the moment. Now, if you get the initiative as the Allies: choose to go first, so you can strengthen the lines and perhaps get some FTRs towards Persia and move Zhukov towards the wood hex. With Stuka's around, I don't like his position at all at the moment. Remember: you should defend the Caucasus until the last man is dead and Zhukov should be the last one to die, not the first... The other fronts, you might retreat from, but not the Persian mountains.
On reïnforcements: I suggest putting at least another 3 units into this area. The fronts in the Ukraine and around Vitebsk should do with cheap units, the Persian mountains however, need to get at least units who have a combat factor of 5 or higher.
The CW should, I'm afraid, continue to build INF type units to strengthen places like India for this turn. By the way: how did the Japanese manage to grab 7 oil points? Weren't you using the NEI and Burma oil for reorganisation or was this oil which simply wasn't used for reorganisation, due to the fact that the CW didn't need that oil for reorganisation and couldn't transport to the factories? I always try to use oil which is as close to the enemy as possible for reorganisation. I don't want to give the Japanese my precious stocks. I rather use Canada to build up my oil reserves. Just my two cents on this...
Can you give us an update on where the USA has got it's TRS and AMPH's at the moment? If I were the USA, my first thing in the war would be to have two TRS sitting in Pago Pago with INF units there and two in San Diego with INF type units. Than, as my first naval move: those INF in the USA are transferred into Pago Pago and the INF there go to New Zealand and/or Australia (depends on how many CW units are there). This move usually means Australia and New Zealand will be save from Japanese invasions for the rest of the game.
By the way: I like your reasoning for moving tension by choosing those options. However: the only thing I would have done was to embargo the Japanese first. He's getting far to many oil and I don't like that at all.