RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Tue Nov 28, 2006 10:53 pm
You got it
Matrix Games Forums
What's your Strategy?
https://forums.matrixgames.com:443/
Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Page 9 of 125
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Tue Nov 28, 2006 11:09 pm
Another soul trapped by the fiendish WIF-gods! [X(]
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Wed Nov 29, 2006 12:36 am
Actually, my soul was sold about 20 yrs ago -- this is merely the resurrection! [:D]
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Wed Nov 29, 2006 11:19 pm
List on page 2 updated! The rumanians and the brits are being worked on from now on! [:D]
1 week til I am back in buisness with the germans again!
1 week til I am back in buisness with the germans again!
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Sat Dec 02, 2006 2:09 pm
Hi all.
I am trying to write up the Royal navy. And in my attemt i have come across a funny thing. The carrier HMS Africa is a ship of two classes. Audacious and Malta classes, both has a ship called HMS Africa.
Since the classes has VERY different stats i think this is important. The counter one is the Malta class.
Hope some one can help me.
Andi, aka Graf Zeppelin
I am trying to write up the Royal navy. And in my attemt i have come across a funny thing. The carrier HMS Africa is a ship of two classes. Audacious and Malta classes, both has a ship called HMS Africa.
Since the classes has VERY different stats i think this is important. The counter one is the Malta class.
Hope some one can help me.
Andi, aka Graf Zeppelin
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Sat Dec 02, 2006 2:41 pm
I too think that the HMS Africa that WiF has in its countermix is from the Malta Class. The Audacious Class are class 4 CVs, and the Malta Class are class 5 CVs, and HMS Africa is a Class 5 CV.ORIGINAL: Graf Zeppelin
Hi all.
I am trying to write up the Royal navy. And in my attemt i have come across a funny thing. The carrier HMS Africa is a ship of two classes. Audacious and Malta classes, both has a ship called HMS Africa.
Since the classes has VERY different stats i think this is important. The counter one is the Malta class.
Hope some one can help me.
Andi, aka Graf Zeppelin
You can find information here :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_Africa
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Audacious_ ... ft_carrier
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malta_clas ... ft_carrier
What would you need beyond this ?
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Sat Dec 02, 2006 4:56 pm
If somebody is keen on doing write-ups of Russian units and with regard to the ongoing discussion about Barbarossa versus Med, historical versus what-if strategies, there's a book review about Eastern front (book and reviw in English) at:
http://www.wargamer.com/reviews/slaught ... ookreview/
regards
http://www.wargamer.com/reviews/slaught ... ookreview/
regards
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Sun Dec 03, 2006 7:50 am
[/quote]
I too think that the HMS Africa that WiF has in its countermix is from the Malta Class. The Audacious Class are class 4 CVs, and the Malta Class are class 5 CVs, and HMS Africa is a Class 5 CV.
You can find information here :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_Africa
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Audacious_ ... ft_carrier
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malta_clas ... ft_carrier
What would you need beyond this ?
[/quote]
I also think the one in the countersheet is a Malta class, but sould there be 2?
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Sun Dec 03, 2006 9:40 am
I don't understand your question : "Should there be 2 ?".I also think the one in the countersheet is a Malta class, but sould there be 2?
Two what ?
Two Africa Carriers ? No WiF FE only has the Malta Class Africa Carrier, so there is only this one.
Two Malta Class Carriers ? Well there are many Malta Class Carriers in WiF FE, that's ok as it is (Gibraltar, Malta, Africa, New Zealand).
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Sun Dec 03, 2006 1:02 pm
yes but there is 4 of the Audacious and 4 of the Malta classes in real life, but only 3 Audacious and 4 Malta in the game...
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Sun Dec 03, 2006 1:05 pm
In WiF FE as it is now, there is no Africa CV of the Audacious Class.ORIGINAL: Graf Zeppelin
yes but there is 4 of the Audacious and 4 of the Malta classes in real life, but only 3 Audacious and 4 Malta in the game...
MWiF reflects the WiF FE order of battle, so it is normal that there is no CV Africa of the Audacious Class.
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Mon Dec 04, 2006 3:12 pm
4 & 4?
No, as the first link shows, the name HMS Africa was reserved for an Audacious-class, got canceled, then assigned to a Malta-class, and got canceled again...
(Only 2 Malta's were even started.)
No, as the first link shows, the name HMS Africa was reserved for an Audacious-class, got canceled, then assigned to a Malta-class, and got canceled again...
(Only 2 Malta's were even started.)
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Thu Dec 28, 2006 3:05 am
I am finally seeing the light at the end of the tunnel, about a month later than I expected. All of december has been dedicated to my studies (had some old unfinished course that I just had to do to continue my studies). As of now I am putting the finishing touches to my second thesis this semester (the first one was approved [:)] ). It is due the 3rd of January and then I will get cracking with the fine write-ups that has been sent to me. I expect to be back in writing German write-ups by the end of that week. I hope everyone who has volonteered are as eager as me to write! I will post some screenies after I am done formatting.
There is always room for more hands if you (yes you
) are interested in helping out (on page 2 you have a list to help you pick your favorite country). Send me a PM and we can talk it through.
- Jesper
There is always room for more hands if you (yes you
) are interested in helping out (on page 2 you have a list to help you pick your favorite country). Send me a PM and we can talk it through.- Jesper
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Fri Jan 05, 2007 11:16 pm
OK one for your consideration:-
Italian Cavalry Corps "Mizza":
I've searched high and low for this and got nothing for my troubles. However the best advice I have is that there was a Cavalry regiment known as "Nizza" which was active in several theatres in WW2.
Seems likely that "Mizza" was a typo on the original counters or (surely not?) a mistake by Lord Harry... he had plenty of other things to think about after all, and he presumably is human- (or at least Australian, which is close enough )
In the scheme of things its not a biggie. However, knowing this, do I do the write up for "Mizza" and point out the error, or can/should the name of the unit be altered within the whole game?
I dont need an urgent reply, I've plenty of others to get on with and I fly off to France skiing for a week later on tonight; I thought I might just throw this one up and see where the bones lie when I get back.
Cheers Jimm
Italian Cavalry Corps "Mizza":
I've searched high and low for this and got nothing for my troubles. However the best advice I have is that there was a Cavalry regiment known as "Nizza" which was active in several theatres in WW2.
Seems likely that "Mizza" was a typo on the original counters or (surely not?) a mistake by Lord Harry... he had plenty of other things to think about after all, and he presumably is human- (or at least Australian, which is close enough
)In the scheme of things its not a biggie. However, knowing this, do I do the write up for "Mizza" and point out the error, or can/should the name of the unit be altered within the whole game?
I dont need an urgent reply, I've plenty of others to get on with and I fly off to France skiing for a week later on tonight; I thought I might just throw this one up and see where the bones lie when I get back.
Cheers Jimm
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Fri Jan 05, 2007 11:25 pm
If it is an error, I'll change the name of the unit.ORIGINAL: Jimm
OK one for your consideration:-
Italian Cavalry Corps "Mizza":
I've searched high and low for this and got nothing for my troubles. However the best advice I have is that there was a Cavalry regiment known as "Nizza" which was active in several theatres in WW2.
Seems likely that "Mizza" was a typo on the original counters or (surely not?) a mistake by Lord Harry... he had plenty of other things to think about after all, and he presumably is human- (or at least Australian, which is close enough
In the scheme of things its not a biggie. However, knowing this, do I do the write up for "Mizza" and point out the error, or can/should the name of the unit be altered within the whole game?
I dont need an urgent reply, I've plenty of others to get on with and I fly off to France skiing for a week later on tonight; I thought I might just throw this one up and see where the bones lie when I get back.
Cheers Jimm
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Fri Jan 05, 2007 11:36 pm
About Mizza / Nizza, the best would be to ask Harry.
About skiing in France, the best would be to bring your own snow too. No more snow here.
About skiing in France, the best would be to bring your own snow too. No more snow here.
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Sat Jan 06, 2007 12:02 am
ORIGINAL: Froonp
About Mizza / Nizza, the best would be to ask Harry.
About skiing in France, the best would be to bring your own snow too. No more snow here.
I'm told its been snowing all week at Courchevel! I'll let you know though...
Anyone able to throw the Mizza/Nizza query at Harry (without the Aussie quip, mind you...)
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Sat Jan 06, 2007 1:09 am
ORIGINAL: Jimm
a mistake by Lord Harry... he had plenty of other things to think about after all, and he presumably is human
[X(][X(] Human?
Heretic!
----
Nizza would be more logical than Mizza for sure.
We let Steve and the other priests (who communicate with Harry) handle the communication and we continue on our merry little way towards completing the write-ups! [:)]
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Sun Jan 07, 2007 3:16 pm
Hi All,
It's quite by chance that I stumbled on this forum to discover with astonishment (and delight !) that there is a computer version of WiF in active development !!! This was quite a surprise since, outside of this forum (the ADG web site, the Matrix web site), it wasn't looking like much was going on.
So, I spent a few days going through a lot of the messages on this forum (I must say that the maps are stunning, as well as the air units counters !). Among other things, I can't wait to see how the "naval units display on the map" problem is going to be addressed (not that I have any doubt that it will be addressed properly) or how the different phases are actually played in the game (I have not see the CWiF game).
In the meantime, I was wondering how I could help and it looks like you are still looking for people to do the writeup on some land units. Not that I have any credentials in military history, though... My strongest credentials for that job is that I *really* want to help get this game out !
So, if you think that I can help with some small and easy countries (to start), let me know. French is my native language, so I could help with the French land units, but I am worried that this might be too tough of a cookie for me...
It's quite by chance that I stumbled on this forum to discover with astonishment (and delight !) that there is a computer version of WiF in active development !!! This was quite a surprise since, outside of this forum (the ADG web site, the Matrix web site), it wasn't looking like much was going on.
So, I spent a few days going through a lot of the messages on this forum (I must say that the maps are stunning, as well as the air units counters !). Among other things, I can't wait to see how the "naval units display on the map" problem is going to be addressed (not that I have any doubt that it will be addressed properly) or how the different phases are actually played in the game (I have not see the CWiF game).
In the meantime, I was wondering how I could help and it looks like you are still looking for people to do the writeup on some land units. Not that I have any credentials in military history, though... My strongest credentials for that job is that I *really* want to help get this game out !
So, if you think that I can help with some small and easy countries (to start), let me know. French is my native language, so I could help with the French land units, but I am worried that this might be too tough of a cookie for me...
RE: Unit Descriptions: Air, Naval, Land
Posted: Sun Jan 07, 2007 6:33 pm
Welcome and thanks for offering to help.ORIGINAL: pclem
Hi All,
It's quite by chance that I stumbled on this forum to discover with astonishment (and delight !) that there is a computer version of WiF in active development !!! This was quite a surprise since, outside of this forum (the ADG web site, the Matrix web site), it wasn't looking like much was going on.
So, I spent a few days going through a lot of the messages on this forum (I must say that the maps are stunning, as well as the air units counters !). Among other things, I can't wait to see how the "naval units display on the map" problem is going to be addressed (not that I have any doubt that it will be addressed properly) or how the different phases are actually played in the game (I have not see the CWiF game).
In the meantime, I was wondering how I could help and it looks like you are still looking for people to do the writeup on some land units. Not that I have any credentials in military history, though... My strongest credentials for that job is that I *really* want to help get this game out !
So, if you think that I can help with some small and easy countries (to start), let me know. French is my native language, so I could help with the French land units, but I am worried that this might be too tough of a cookie for me...
All help is appreciated. As far as I know, no one working on the unit writeups is a professional historian and almost all of them are learning a great deal as they do the writeups. Capitan is coordinating efforts for the land unit writeups so you should send him a PM (personal message) repeating what you just posted. Currently the French land units have no writeups, with the exceptions of the HQ/leaders and a lone Artillery unit built in the USA.
Writers have had more trouble with the land unit writeups than the air and naval ones, so I suggest reading through (lightly) the posts in this thread for a discussion and examples of how to research and what to look for. Good hunting!