Page 9 of 10
RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 5:09 am
by larryfulkerson
I busted a hole in the Soviet line and now I'm driving a Panzer division through the
gap. I'll add another division as soon as I find one available. Those are hard to
come by because I'm so outnumbered on the battlefield.
I've got engineers and recon people standing on the front lines because there's
nobody else nearby that can do the task at hand.
The mud season starts in T32 as I recall so that's right around the corner. I
expect the supply system to collapse to occur right around there and I'm hoping
that there's a section or two of the front lines where the advance can continue.
And for the Soviet Winter Offensive I'm thinking of shortening the lines and pulling
back into better defensive terrain and getting ready. No attacking in the month of
November to save up the supply that's going to be needed for the onslaught.
And there's the problem that there's no reserves anywhere. That's worrysome.
If I had a reserve I'd committ it somewhere or other, the need is there already.
I'm hoping I can take down Sevastopol in time just so I can play with the Bulgarians too.
RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 10:31 am
by larryfulkerson
Here's the T31 front lines before I have moved anybody.

RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 12:32 pm
by larryfulkerson
I finally started the attacking at Sevastopol after resting for three turns. I gained
a couple of hexes and created a pocket that I'm going to kill and I'm thinking of maybe
trying a finger advance here instead of the "broad front" approach. I know I have to
kill all of them, I just want to make sure I get the port first.

RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 12:38 pm
by larryfulkerson
This is the Kiev area right now. I'm clearing out the Soviet remnants up against the
river. A human player would have moved them long ago but Elmer is giving the orders
and his objective is where the units are so they stayed. I expect to have this cleaned
up shortly. I need these troops out on the front line instead of mopping up.

RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 12:43 pm
by larryfulkerson
Here's a section of the front lines where the Soviets are particularly sparse and it's
easy to surround them and dispatch them. Progress is slowed by the low supply levels
but progress is being made.

RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 1:24 pm
by larryfulkerson
The 3rd Mot Div had it's recon element trapped behing enemy lines by getting too far
out front and then retreating the wrong way when attacked. So now it's my turn to move
it and it was already divided so I tried to move the pieces to where I could blow a
bridge at laast before it dies. And I got one finally. The others might possibly survive
another turn and I'll try it again. The more broken bridges the better.

RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 1:36 pm
by larryfulkerson
There's a supply point near Vyazma that I need to get pretty badly because it turns
into an Axis supply point when captured. The problem is that my dudes are fighting in
a low-supply area and don't recover very fast from one attack to the next. It's slow
going. The mud season starts next turn however and I expect the Axis supply net to
collapse right around there so it would be a plus to have it.

RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 1:50 pm
by larryfulkerson
Here's a shot of the Orel area right now and we're fighting over possession of the
only supply point in this AO I guess, judging from the ferosity of their attacks. I
need to hang onto it because the supply net is going to crash soon and THIS supply
point will be the reason I can stay and attack still during the mud season. Which
is going to start next turn.

RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 1:56 pm
by TPOO
ORIGINAL: larryfulkerson
I finally started the attacking at Sevastopol after resting for three turns. I gained
a couple of hexes and created a pocket that I'm going to kill and I'm thinking of maybe
trying a finger advance here instead of the "broad front" approach. I know I have to
kill all of them, I just want to make sure I get the port first.
However, per house rules you cannot stack minor's and you have most of the Rumanians in stacks.
RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 2:03 pm
by larryfulkerson
Here's a view of where most of the progress is being made. I've got units streaming
east for a long stretch of front line in this area. The supply level is low and they
have to "save up" for enough supply to move or attack. So the advance is slow. The
Soviets are pushing back when they get their chance. They attack so hard that sometimes
Soviet units evaporate. Most of the time their attacks give them more losses than I
get. That's only true for those places that are backed up by arty.

RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 2:08 pm
by larryfulkerson
ORIGINAL: TPOO
However, per house rules you cannot stack minor's and you have most of the Rumanians in stacks.
You mean to say that I can't build a stack of pure Rumanians? I didn't know that. I thought
the rule ment that I couldn't stack Axis minors of other nations together. I didn't know that
you couldn't build stacks with any of the minor nations units. Bummer. Should I restart now
that I know that?
Edit: Here's why I say that.

RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 2:21 pm
by larryfulkerson
Elmer finally mobilized his reserves and drove some heavy units at my lines from the
east and caught my units still in travel mode and they are out of position and they
can't support each other. I've got a problem here. I think maybe I might have to
pull to the west a bit and regroup, form a line.

RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 3:12 pm
by John B.
I read the house rule the same way as Larry. You can't make stacks of minors that include more than one minor power in the stack. That fits with lots of other east front games where Romanians and Hungarians can't cooperate. It would be a brand new rule to say that even units of the same minor country could not stack together.
RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 3:13 pm
by TPOO
ORIGINAL: larryfulkerson
ORIGINAL: TPOO
However, per house rules you cannot stack minor's and you have most of the Rumanians in stacks.
You mean to say that I can't build a stack of pure Rumanians? I didn't know that. I thought
the rule ment that I couldn't stack Axis minors of other nations together. I didn't know that
you couldn't build stacks with any of the minor nations units. Bummer. Should I restart now
that I know that?
Edit: Here's why I say that.
No you do not have to restart. This rule is in place to simulate the historical competency of these units and to balance game play against the AI. The Rumanians took 2 months to capture Odessa. This rule was actually in place in the original FITE.
RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 5:53 pm
by larryfulkerson
ORIGINAL: TPOO
ORIGINAL: larryfulkerson
ORIGINAL: TPOO
However, per house rules you cannot stack minor's and you have most of the Rumanians in stacks.
You mean to say that I can't build a stack of pure Rumanians? I didn't know that. I thought
the rule ment that I couldn't stack Axis minors of other nations together. I didn't know that
you couldn't build stacks with any of the minor nations units. Bummer. Should I restart now
that I know that?
No you do not have to restart. This rule is in place to simulate the historical competency of these units and to balance game play against the AI. The Rumanians took 2 months to capture Odessa. This rule was actually in place in the original FITE.
You know about it more than I do Rick dude so I'll start playing it that way. Somebody might want to edit the
Scenario Briefing to reflect this change.
RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 6:11 pm
by larryfulkerson
This change has rocked my world so hard that I feel like I need to do a restart.
Besides this game "feels" wrong. Too many times I've let my recon units get
themselves destroyed by driving them too far afield so that they main body
couldn't get to them to save them in time. They get surrounded and destroyed.
I need to change my gameplay to stop doing that. I'll get some practice.
RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Sat Mar 17, 2018 11:04 am
by TPOO
I think the scenario briefing is quite clear on the rule but I will try and reword it if that brings more clarity. If you are going to start over I will have to send you the updated file as there has been a couple of tweaks. Thank you.
RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Sat Mar 17, 2018 11:36 am
by DD696
Hi -
I also took the wording to mean that Axis minor powers could not stack with units other than their own or German.
I've been playing this for quite some time - restarting as I learn the game. I would appreciate having the latest version sent to me also, if that would be possible.
Thanks for all you dedication to this scenario.
RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Sat Mar 17, 2018 1:03 pm
by 700851McCall
The wording is ambiguous. Not being allowed to stack a Rumanian with another Rumanian never occurred to me. I've sorted it out in my game now but I'm not restarting from turn 106

RE: D21 version 4.5
Posted: Sat Mar 17, 2018 1:33 pm
by larryfulkerson
ORIGINAL: 700851McCall
The wording is ambiguous. Not being allowed to stack a Rumanian with another Rumanian never occurred to me. I've sorted it out in my game now but I'm not restarting from turn 106
You're NOT going to restart? You'd make a lousy idealist. I feel like I'm working on
my PHd in
D21 stuff. Like a desertation or a masterpiece for a greaduate student. But
it's all for entertainment and I wouldn't do it if it weren't fun.