ORIGINAL: Bliztk
In the aircraft comparation table could a new field called "True Gun Value" be added.
TGV should be gun value multiplied by the accuracy of the gun / 100
Because sometimes planes armed with 57mm gun or 40mm guns appear to be more effective than the planes armed with lower cal guns, which is untrue
Bliztk - where did you get this formula ? I know something better is probably needed than out generic "gunValue", but there are a number of different formula's floating around; including witpStaff's
OPGV: Contains the “Offensive Penetrating Gun Value” which trys to represent the ability of the
plane class to shoot forward. The formula used to calculate it is:
SQRT(effect*accuracy*LOG(range))*(1+penetration)*number_of_forward_guns/2
This shows that the penetration capability of a gun plays an important role (thus the name)
in contrast to WitP's numbers which IIRC only take effect and number into account.
Here is your calculated field:
I-16-III TGV= 4.32
I-15-III TGV= 4.32
H81-A3 TGV= 4.54
Hawk 75M TGV= 2.8
P-40E Warhawk TGV= 5.22
P-40N Warhawk TGV= 5.22
P-43A-1 Lancer TGV= 3.48
P-66 Vanguard TGV= 4.54
P-51D Mustang TGV= 5.22
Corsair II TGV= 5.22
Corsair IV TGV= 5.22
Corsair V TGV= 5.22
Hellcat I TGV= 5.22
Hellcat F.II TGV= 5.22
Seafire IIC TGV= 4.8
Seafire L.III TGV= 4.8
Seafire F.XV TGV= 4.8
Sea Hurricane Ib TGV= 5.44
Martlet II TGV= 3.48
Martlet IV TGV= 5.22
Wildcat V TGV= 3.48
Wildcat VI TGV= 3.48
Blenheim IF TGV= 4.08
Buffalo I TGV= 3.48
Hurricane I Trop TGV= 5.44
Hurricane IIa Trop TGV= 5.44
Hurricane IIb Trop TGV= 8.16
Hurricane IIc Trop TGV= 4.16
Mohawk IV TGV= 4.08
Mustang IV TGV= 5.22
Spitfire Vc Trop TGV= 4.8
Spitfire VIII TGV= 4.8
Spitfire F.XIV TGV= 4.8
Spitfire FR.XIVe TGV= 3.82
Tempest F.2 TGV= 4.16
Thunderbolt I TGV= 6.96
Thunderbolt II TGV= 6.96
B-339D TGV= 3.14
CW-21B Demon TGV= 2.8
75A-7 Hawk TGV= 2.8
Hurricane IIb Trop TGV= 8.16
P-40E Warhawk TGV= 5.22
B-339-23 TGV= 3.48
Kittyhawk IA TGV= 5.22
Kittyhawk III TGV= 5.22
Kittyhawk IV TGV= 5.22
P-51D Mustang TGV= 5.22
P-39D Airacobra TGV= 4.74
Spitfire Vc Trop TGV= 4.8
Spitfire VIII TGV= 4.8
Hurricane XIIb TGV= 8.16
Kittyhawk I TGV= 5.22
Kittyhawk III TGV= 5.22
Kittyhawk IV TGV= 5.22
F4U-1D Corsair TGV= 5.22
Kittyhawk IA TGV= 5.22
Kittyhawk III TGV= 5.22
Kittyhawk IV TGV= 5.22
P-51D Mustang TGV= 5.22
A-36 Mustang TGV= 5.22
F-6C Mustang TGV= 3.48
F-6D Mustang TGV= 5.22
P-26A TGV= 1.57
P-35A TGV= 3.14
P-36A Mohawk TGV= 1.57
P-38E Lightning TGV= 4.52
P-38F Lightning TGV= 4.52
P-38G Lightning TGV= 4.52
P-38H Lightning TGV= 4.52
P-38J Lightning TGV= 4.52
P-38L Lightning TGV= 4.52
P-39D Airacobra TGV= 4.74
P-39N1 Airacobra TGV= 4.74
P-400 Airacobra TGV= 5.58
P-40B Warhawk TGV= 4.54
P-40E Warhawk TGV= 5.22
P-40K Warhawk TGV= 5.22
P-40N1 Warhawk TGV= 3.48
P-40N5 Warhawk TGV= 5.22
P-40N26 Warhawk TGV= 5.22
P-43 Lancer TGV= 3.14
P-43A-1 Lancer TGV= 3.48
P-47D2 Thunderbolt TGV= 6.96
P-47D25 Thunderbolt TGV= 6.96
P-47N Thunderbolt TGV= 6.96
P-51A Mustang TGV= 3.48
P-51B Mustang TGV= 3.48
P-51D Mustang TGV= 5.22
P-51H Mustang TGV= 5.22
P-80A Shooting Star TGV= 5.22
P-82B Twin Mustang TGV= 5.22
I-15bis TGV= 4.32
I-153 TGV= 4.32
I-16m24 TGV= 4.32
La-5FN TGV= 1.92
La-7 TGV= 1.92
LaGG-3 TGV= 1.86
MiG-3 TGV= 3.06
Yak-7B TGV= 2.76
Yak-9 TGV= 2.04
Yak-9D TGV= 2.04
Yak-9U TGV= 2.76
F2A-2 Buffalo TGV= 3.48
F2A-3 Buffalo TGV= 3.48
F4F-3A Wildcat TGV= 3.48
F4F-3 Wildcat TGV= 3.48
F4F-3P Wildcat TGV= 3.48
F4F-4 Wildcat TGV= 5.22
FM-1 Wildcat TGV= 3.48
FM-2 Wildcat TGV= 3.48
F4U-1 Corsair TGV= 5.22
F4U-1A Corsair TGV= 5.22
F4U-1D Corsair TGV= 5.22
F4U-4 Corsair TGV= 5.22
F2G-1 Corsair TGV= 3.48
F6F-3 Hellcat TGV= 5.22
F6F-5 Hellcat TGV= 5.22
F8F-1 Bearcat TGV= 3.48
FR-1 Fireball TGV= 3.48
SNJ-3 Texan TGV= 1.4
A5M4 Claude TGV= 1.08
A6M2 Zero TGV= 2.84
A6M3 Zero TGV= 2.84
A6M3a Zero TGV= 2.92
A6M5 Zero TGV= 2.92
A6M5b Zero TGV= 3.25
A6M5c Zero TGV= 4.45
A6M8 Zero TGV= 3.58
A7M2 Sam TGV= 3.68
A7M3-J Sam TGV= 4.5
J2M2 Jack TGV= 2.84
J2M3 Jack TGV= 3.6
J2M5 Jack TGV= 3.6
J7W1 Shinden TGV= 3.0
J8M1 Shusei TGV= 1.5
N1K1-J George TGV= 4.68
N1K2-J George TGV= 3.68
N1K5-J George TGV= 5.42
Ki-27b Nate TGV= 1.08
Ki-43-Ia Oscar TGV= 1.08
Ki-43-Ib Oscar TGV= 1.41
Ki-43-Ic Oscar TGV= 1.74
Ki-43-IIa Oscar TGV= 1.74
Ki-43-IIb Oscar TGV= 1.74
Ki-43-IIIa Oscar TGV= 1.74
Ki-43-IV Oscar TGV= 2.24
Ki-44 Tojo TGV= 2.82
Ki-44-IIa Tojo TGV= 2.82
Ki-44-IIb Tojo TGV= 1.9
Ki-44-IIc Tojo TGV= 3.48
Ki-46-IIIb Dinah TGV= 0.58
Ki-61-Ia Tony TGV= 2.82
Ki-61-Ib Tony TGV= 3.48
Ki-61-Ic Tony TGV= 3.42
Ki-61-Id Tony TGV= 3.98
Ki-61-II KAI Tony TGV= 3.98
Ki-83 TGV= 3.54
Ki-84a Frank TGV= 3.98
Ki-84b Frank TGV= 4.48
Ki-84r Frank TGV= 3.98
Ki-93-Ia TGV= 3.37
Ki-94-II TGV= 3.54
Ki-100-I Tony TGV= 3.98
Ki-100-II Tony TGV= 3.98
Ki-102a Randy TGV= 2.36
Ki-201 Karyu TGV= 3.54
Ki-202 Shusei TGV= 1.3
Compare the Buffalo's to the Zero / Oscar V Warhawk/Aircobra... and others; it doesn't look right IMO. I still think something better might be hatched up (or can you justify it) & I don't want to put in something else that I'm unsure of.