Page 2 of 2

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2007 9:43 pm
by Titanwarrior89
I would say he has the right if it was not agreed upon before hand.  The reason I say this is because this is a "very, very long game" and the allied player will have a very hard time, gaining any headway against a good japanese player.     After this type of loss to the allied player............
 
1. The jap player can move any and every where for a long time(game and real time).
 
2.  It will take months of Real time to get back to anything near par with the japanese.
 
3.   All major landing will be a one sided crap shoot for a long time(for the allied play-real time).
 
4.   If it was a much shorter game - then I would say no.  But being a very long in real time for the allied player to watch, convoy after convoy go to the deep six with out air support is very hard to take over a period of 4,5,6 months or more(depending on turns sent per day).
 
I was in this position once against a decent japanese player.  I stopped after sep 42(i think)(i lost my carriers months before-real months).[:)]

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2007 11:15 pm
by bigjoe96912
The allied needs to stick it out regardless, isn't that what you are expecting of the Jap player in the later war years, to stand by and watch the inevitable crushing of the Jap. Who doen't want to see the B-29's dropping nukes on Tokyo. So what now he has to watch Nukes attacking Midway because the Japs keep him cornered until mid 1944, isn't that the Japs Big hope afterall, to make the allies launch airstikes against him from Hawaii. Everyone wants the Japs to stick it out till the end shouldn't the allies too. After all eventually the allies will win the war. If you are concerned play 2 games, one as the allies and one as teh Japs, I like doing it cause I am whipping and being whipped at the same time.

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2007 11:16 pm
by Andy Mac
Ok my 2 cents worth losing all 6 allied carriers before mid 42 is NOT a disaster (27 CVE's in 43 alone I think the US gets in PDU thats a lot of Birdfarms turn your remaining Fleet and light carriers into fighter platforms put the 4 F4U equipped USN sqns on board and lots of Hellcats and suddenly even a 6 CVL's plus Essex is enough to cover the fleet add to that CVE Wildcats a few with Hellcats and load em up with TBM's KB is toast.

They all respawn as essex class and it forces the allies to be defensive but its not the end of the world

Losing those same 6 carriers in late 42 is a much more difficult position to recover from.

The allied counteroffensive really begins after Hellcats arrive in mid 43 for many reasons Ubercap deathstars etc its not really worth taking massive risks at end 42 because if you lose a carrier it respawns in mid 44 whereas carriers lost in ealry 42 are back in time for the 43 'positioning' offensive.

Its not an easy position to recover from and it means getting creative no deep strikes etc but its far from over.

Japanese can very easily over reach.

Places like Suva, Line Islands and PH become fortresses and must be defended.

Canton etc are almost impossible to defend.

When 44 rolls around if the Japanese player commits to much to defend forward bypass.

Given a choice I would FAR rather lose 6 CV's in March 42 than December 42 or even 3 in December 42

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2007 11:20 pm
by Andy Mac
Also protect the RN Carriers each one gets Seafires and then Corsairs AND the Barracuda as a range 6 Torpedo Bomber can be nasty

You probably need to move the Eastern Fleet to support the USN for a while to keep KB honest.

Victorious, Formidable, Illustrious and Indomitable supported by 1 US Fleet Carrier with strong BB led escorts are a handfull for KB Seafires are a great interceptor and able to go toe to toe with A6M2's so far from lost except on points which no one cares about anyway

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2007 11:29 pm
by niceguy2005
Going back to the original question: as you say, it's your opponents right to surrender. However, that's not why most of us play this game, especially PBEM.

The good news probably is that this happened early on. It would be even worse for you to get into 43 or 44 and have him bail.

IMHO it is quite possible to fight on without 3 CV; it does make the counter-attack harder, but not impossible. In RL the US started its counter-attack on GC without really using much carrier power. In theory the entire Solomons campaign could be fought with only LBA.


RE: Early Allied CV loss

Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2007 11:57 pm
by moses
The bane of WITP is players who play with reckles abandon and then quit when their over-aggressive plans backfire.

An allied player will launch an offensive operation in Jan 42 and if it suceeds will lord it over you. If it fails, as the odds say it will, he will quit.

Japanese players are worse. They launch crazy unsupported offensives. They attack until they have literally nothing left to fight with. Then when their carriers run out, they say that the game is over. Why fight now that obviously they can no longer win.

You have to find players who know that this game is not about winning or losing. It's just about playing. Doing the best that you can and then holding on against all odds.

I'm playing Jwilkerson now and you know there is no doubt that I will "win". I get so many forces as time goes by. But I sure hope he doesn't quit. And why should he? As Japan you know you will eventually lose. You're ego should not be invested in "winning" but instead in playing. Fighting on in desperation.

I lost virtually all my carriers as allied and kept playing. Why not? The game goes on. Win, Lose it doesn't matter. The war goes on and who gives a shit what anyone else thinks. You play just to see what happens and to see what you can make of things.

Really I just want to see what 1944 feels like!!!!! Play on, Kick ass, WITP rules!!!!!!


RE: Early Allied CV loss

Posted: Tue Aug 28, 2007 4:53 am
by 1275psi
I agree with Moses

Still, I think far to many Jap players are denying themselves a great experience by not playing on into 44.
You cannot win, but there are so many other challenges to keep you busy.
I feel great satisfaction getting in a lick or two -or disrupting his plans, or even the simple pleasure of getting troops from A to B , under the allied noses is fun.

Losing planes at ridicoulous rates is not fun, but your army can still fight -and if you still have a surface fleet - you are especially lucky.

Im into 4/44, and personally the game is just getting to the good bits!

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Posted: Tue Aug 28, 2007 5:03 am
by bradfordkay
I must be a chickensh*t admiral. I've never lost more than one or two carriers in the first few months of the war. They're too valuable as a "force in being" to waste them on wild adventures...

In the same vein, they've not contributed much to the enemy kill list, either...

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Posted: Tue Aug 28, 2007 7:37 am
by ilovestrategy
Game=Fun [:)]

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Posted: Tue Aug 28, 2007 7:52 am
by Alfred
Gentlemen,
 
I am flabergasted at reading so much slander.  Surely there are no players, exhibiting such selfish and childlike tantrums, as described by Moses.[:D]
 
Seriously, having never played PBEM I am not in a position to really comment but based on what is posted Moses has thrust his rapier straight to the heart.  What particularly intrigues me is how are such unsuitable PBEM players actually found and more to the point perserved with.  Wouldn't such unsatisfactory behaviour manifest itself within the first 3 months, as identified by Moses, and if so why would you continue the game?
 
Alfred

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Posted: Tue Aug 28, 2007 3:27 pm
by niceguy2005
ORIGINAL: moses
You have to find players who know that this game is not about winning or losing. It's just about playing. Doing the best that you can and then holding on against all odds.

I lost virtually all my carriers as allied and kept playing. Why not? The game goes on. Win, Lose it doesn't matter. The war goes on and who gives a shit what anyone else thinks. You play just to see what happens and to see what you can make of things.
Nice speech Moses...I'm sending this on to my defenders in the DEI, who are as we speak getting the snot kicked out of them in Threadwar...Palembang just fell and its still early Jan 42...

On a more serious note, I agree. What also makes something like losing most of your carriers interesting is that it simply has to alter the game. YOu are almost guranteed to fight different battles with different forces in different places (see Chaos theory). Which is part of the fun of playing the game. Whats the fun of continually fighting the same battles over and over again.

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Posted: Tue Aug 28, 2007 3:32 pm
by aztez
The game is definately for for playing. That is why I prefer to have experienced and longterm forum members as opponents. It will take ages to go through first few months let alone years.
 
WITP has it moments when you just would like delete the whole software but those storms slowly fade away.
 
Personally I had couple of times in my PBEM's when I was mentaly ready to quit. Luckily I did not and both games are now in 1945's.