RE: Where JTCS went wrong
Posted: Sun Dec 25, 2011 12:37 am
go for it
ORIGINAL: Warhorse
OMG, here we go again.... And I play against the AI, BTW... This always coming from people that actually don't do anything constructive to perpetuate the game, just complain, try doing something.
Mike
ORIGINAL: osiris
HI
snipped for sanity's sake
Dont come on here and say people didnt try to move the game in the right direction--the game has NOT CHANGED 1 BIT since the it was purchased by MATRIX games...all we got was some window dressing
rene
ORIGINAL: osiris
I think this needs to be said as to why I have completely stopped playing this game its a culmination of old technology, a company that has little or no forward thinking and design changes that just went wrong
1: Patches-Upto patch 1.02 it was an excellent game and from there it went downhill
in patch 1.04-
Useless Gimmicks
we have battleships, civilians and all kinds of other useless gimmicks which do not enhance game play..If you want reality then why didnt you include a concentration game icon as well, We have supply depots that do nothing for game play, HQ units that dont work and so on-The most irritating gimmick is Individual snipers ( last time I checked this is a platoon game) why do we need individual snipers!!)
The developers folded to the a minority of players who wanted this crap while ignoring the majority of players
Useless OBs
we have OBs of useless countries which had useless armies- Romania (in fact we have an entire set of scenarios dedicated to that useless army that played such a minor role in the war). Hungarian, Finnish, Bulgarian, Yugoslavian and a few others useless armies that played such a minor role in war
close assualt system
This should either have been changed or NOT-Not some stupid comprimise that again made a minority happy and a majority very unhappy
The developers should have had got some back bone and made a decision
Crummy AI-
This has been a complaint about the game for ages-Unfortunately MATRIX missed the boat on this when they first aquired the game that is when changes should have been made to the game engine before the 1st patch came out
Why I want to play AI-ITS CONVENIENT!!!-
I dont want to wait for some stupid human being to send me a turn 1 week or more later that should take 3 minutes to do-Again Panzer corp solved this problem beautifully
Is playing humans better-Of course it is but its inconvenient!! and finally unlike Panzer Corp which solved the cheating problem JTCS series did not so again
Matrix missed the opportunity to upgrade the game engine
Not so visually stunning Graphics-
As the world of computers gets more and more advanced this game is being left in the dust visually-Again there was a chance for Matrix to do this upgrade and they missed the boat
This game is dying a terrible death because
A MATRIX games missed too many boat to really upgrade this game and
The developers/designers (out of there good heart or whatever the reason was) made the mistake of trying to make everyone happy (especially the minority of players who wanted useless crap in the game
So Im gonna wait for the John Tiller Software to come out with Panzer Battles-a platoon based game and then Im going to toss JTCS series out the window
I completely understand why people want patch 1.02 it represents the very best of JTCS...so give players the option of having it
PS I wont buy/get modern wars because its based on the same graphics and same game engine as JTCS hence the same problems
ORIGINAL: Warhorse
OMG, here we go again.... And I play against the AI, BTW... This always coming from people that actually don't do anything constructive to perpetuate the game, just complain, try doing something.
Mike
ORIGINAL: osiris
Rude by that you mean i disagreed with a bunch of people who have little or no tolerance or disagreement on this forum..
NOTHING NEW.anything the designers do or touch on this game is beyond discussion-they are always right..
Expressing ones opinion on this forum that disagrees with anything that the designers do is seen as high treason..well thats too damn bad...
In case you have not noticed I never said anything negative personally about the designers and others...all I did was question some of the choices they made you are free to disagree..
If you cant handle a criticism then you should go hide under a rock...its not safe out here in the real world people may disagree with what you say or with your ideas!
Nothing was addressed in patch 1.02..none of the major issues, AI, sound, graphics and so on
My point exactly--nobody uses them...how many scenarios have you played with civillians in it???
Please see the orginal TALONSOFT version before you sart talking nonsense
Your in the minority
I dont play with humans..
I do-- you should try it..its fun..might expand your knowledge of games
Play in 2 D..go play a board game..most people play in 3d hence why there are posts all over the forum for improving the graphics!
As I have mentioned they did the best they could..
thank you for mentioning the game is on life support because it never got off..!!!
We CANNOT promote the game if the company that owns it DOES NOT WANT TOO
ORIGINAL: osiris
Useless OBs
we have OBs of useless countries which had useless armies- Romania (in fact we have an entire set of scenarios dedicated to that useless army that played such a minor role in the war). Hungarian, Finnish, Bulgarian, Yugoslavian and a few others useless armies that played such a minor role in war
ORIGINAL: osiris
HI Hawk
I was not rude..disagreeing or voicing your opinon is not rude (however you are entitiled to your opinion).
ORIGINAL: osiris
a company that has little or no forward thinking and design changes that just went wrong
ORIGINAL: osiris
Useless Gimmicks
Useless OBs
ORIGINAL: osiris
I dont want to wait for some stupid human being to send me a turn
I am not tactful by nature (I find it to be boring and a waste of time trying to colour bad news with positive images/words)..
Its not a MATRIXs product..Matrix only owns the license..MATRIX did not create JTCS..its a TALONSOFT product produced by TALONSOFT..
Jason and his design team own more of JTSC then MATRIX does simply by demonstrating their commitment to it..
If MATRIX wants ownership of it and really make it theres then they should have addressed and still could fix the major issues in the game..
The graphics/sound suffice for some and for others not because there is a boredom with mediocrity.
Matrix has no interest in this game..
Operational Art of War got a total face lift and then some (that was this year 2011)..they had the money to spend on that on a product that caters to a far smaller audience..
I never said the design team did a poor job. I simply indicated that some of the choices were bad/questionable (an opinion!!)
other than that most of my criticism of who did a poor job is leveled directly at MATRIX
ORIGINAL: osiris
Jason and his design team own more of JTSC then MATRIX does simply by demonstrating their commitment to it..
Simple example of how MATRIX has mismanged this product..They missed the opportunity when Modern Wars was being created. They could have built an entirely new engine with new everything. Relase Modern wars and then release a complete makeover of JTCS
If everyone is so content why are there polls on this forum to revert back to 1.02???
Funny going through some of the other threads the same people who jumped on me in this thread are the same ones who jump on others who dont like people who critize/voiced an opinion that was negative of 1.04..dont you find that intersting?
Sorry the masses are not content and we will not shut up
Instead of having a constructive discussion on how to move MATRIX forward on this game we get this instead..growth requires criticism however unpleasent it may be