Matrix Games Forums

War lover....the Bomber Pilot.[:)]

ORIGINAL: freeboy

war hourse.. too long too manipulative would be a very good 1 hour 45 minute movie..
SORRY I flunked this thread
war movies from WW2.. then deleat BH, and Master and commander ..
lets add First
Band then.. hands down for feel and acting..story
wow..
The thread is causing me to remember a lot of ww2 movies that just are not around..
Anyone see Steve Mqueen in The War Lover ?

Well a difficult question "best. 5" This question is asked in forums over and over again, and I bet if you analyzed posters answers, they would vary on each occasion.
My best five this week are
1. Private Ryan
2. A Bridge to Far
3. Battle of Britain
4. Zulu
5. Gallipoli

A special mention, certainly not the best war movie, but Where Eagles Dare is without doubt the movie I have watch most. This picture is not about Axis vs Allied, but Burton vs Eastwood.

What? No battle of the bulge? Look at that Allstar cast and tell me what could go wrong?

'The most intensely personal drama of men ever told'


mo reb

redcoat,

9. Ice Cold in Alex
10. Malta Story

I must investigate these further. [:D]

MoReb,

What? No battle of the bulge? Look at that Allstar cast and tell me what could go wrong?

Did you not examine my glorious list, sir? Why its easy to spot between choices 1 & 1! [:'(]

Battle of the Bulge can easily be the top spot on worst flick though. What were they thinking?

Anyone watch When Trumpets Fade?
It was a made for HBO flick that depicts the fighting in the Hurtgen Forest. Few goofy parts but one that covered the horrors of that battle in a slow burn kind of way. I liked it.

ORIGINAL: KG Erwin

These are my personal faves in my WWII film library ...

I still prefer the B&W classics: "A Walk in the Sun" and "The Red Badge of Courage".

They still hold an almost universal appeal as their scripts could apply to almost any war of any time.

SPEAKING OF THE BULGE, TIME FOR CLOSE COMBAT:THE RUSSIAN FRONT!
Panzerlied
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N4K09d2W3BY

I would have to agree hands down.[&o]
[quote]ORIGINAL: Missouri_Rebel

Battle of the Bulge can easily be the top spot on worst flick though. What were they thinking.

ORIGINAL: Missouri_Rebel

Battle of the Bulge can easily be the top spot on worst flick though. What were they thinking?

Anyone watch When Trumpets Fade?
It was a made for HBO flick that depicts the fighting in the Hurtgen Forest. Few goofy parts but one that covered the horrors of that battle in a slow burn kind of way. I liked it.

It's in my list above.

I am corrected. Been many years since I've seen it so it's probably time to put it in the DVD player again.

1. Stalingrad
2. Das Boot
3. Tora Tora Tora
4. Battle of Britain
5. Saving Private Ryan

Speaking of the Hurtgen, my old neighbor was a platoon leader in the 60th reg. of the 9th division. He never spoke of it until he had me over one day to look at some tile work in his basement bathroom and I saw a bunch of plaques(sp?) on the wall commemorating his service through the war. I reluctantly asked him a few questions and he asked me to come to the kitchen table to talk a bit about it. His wife stood behind him as  well as if she had never really heard him speak of it. Man I was naive and just a teen because the man told me some things and it was VERY hurtful to him to do so. After just a few questions I broke off the conversation. The thing that bothered him the most was seeing all the dead being pushed around on the beach still and the fear he had during the Hurtgen Forest battle. After the HF they fell back as reserves  because they were so mauled but were then caught up in the Battle of the Bulge. Here he was a bazooka man. I asked him what that was like and that is when his wife gave me a rather sad look so I said, 'Mr. Sampson, I appreciate your service and don't want to bring anymore feeling back up'. I think he was glad that I did not ask any more. Back then I was a silly boy who wanted to know about his experiences and couldn't fathom at the time the emotions I had dredged up. I never asked him about it again and he never brought it up to me. It pains me to think what I did to the man in pressing for information. A stupid silly boy.

Of course my Grandpappy served in the 1st Marines and fought his way across the Pacific. Those stories for another day.

1.Tali-Ihantala 1944(Finn)
2.Downfall/Der Untergang
3.Conspiracy(HBO film about Wannsee Conference)
4.For those we love(Japanese, Kamikaze unit)
5.Brest 1941(Russian)

Best Series
1.Band of Brothers
2.Piece of Cake
3.Enemy at the Door(BBC series of the Channel Islands during occupation)
4.Das Boot full length miniseries.

I recently realized that for all the time I have put in simulating World War II, I have never actually seen a film of a real attack going in during the World War II era. I have seen clips in documentiaruies such as San Pietro and Tarawa but never actually seen a World War II attack filmed live from a hill or command bunker. Has anyone ever seen, say a company level attack filmed from a hill go in and finish completely? Am I looking for a unicorn?

In no particular order:-

1. Downfall
2. Merry Christmas, Mr. Lawrence
3. Battle of Britain
4. Catch-22
5. Hell in the Pacific ( Lee Marvin's BEST Film IMHO )