Page 2 of 3
RE: New Small Map Scen - WIP
Posted: Mon Dec 16, 2013 7:56 am
by JeffroK
But many of us probably only do it for personal use, I found it a lot of work getting the AI to work properly. I had a "Invasion Australia" and WPO 1941 (Only 2 CV on each side) both without a propely working AI.
Louis Folly is interesting, as is any game where you have no idea of what the opposition is going to do. Having a few problems keeping the IJA out of Rangoon at the moment.
Cupla oddities, 14 Sqn RNZAF has Buffalos and is tied to a NZ upgrade line. 155 RAF has Mohawks, while reasonable I doubt they would be front line at this point.
RE: New Small Map Scen - WIP
Posted: Mon Dec 16, 2013 8:02 am
by kkoovvoo
Hi Andy,
thank you for creating small scenarios, i am returning to WITP after years. I will no longer have time for grand campaign.
I will for sure try all your small scens. Its great you create small scanearios with challenging AI - and we "part-time" players can also have fun.
RE: New Small Map Scen - WIP
Posted: Mon Dec 16, 2013 11:56 am
by berto
Given how much else I have to do (see my sig, especially the third item), WITP:AE is the only other game I allow myself time to play (other than the Campaign Series).
I consider WITP:AE to be the finest computer war game ever made. I have no time for the GCs. Small map scenarios make WITP:AE accessible for me.
All thanks to you and Symon. Keep 'em coming!
RE: New Small Map Scen - WIP
Posted: Mon Dec 16, 2013 2:27 pm
by Symon
Andy; the small scenario people don't engage much on the forum, but many of them are the most dedicated and knowledgeable players. Comments are far and few between, and many are by pm, but always on the money, succinct and helpful. They may be muted and under the radar, but they are there. They are the ones that make it all worth while.
If you are used to the baying of the hounds at the Grand GC Hunt, it might seem that your efforts are unappreciated, but they are appreciated ... believe me, they are. Ciao. J
RE: New Small Map Scen - WIP
Posted: Tue Dec 17, 2013 12:49 am
by derhexer
I'd make some scenarios, but I don't know how!
RE: New Small Map Scen - WIP
Posted: Tue Dec 17, 2013 9:09 am
by Andy Mac
Interestingly Mohawks were still in frontline service in 44 !!!
Buffalos are an error I will pick up.
Andy
RE: New Small Map Scen - WIP
Posted: Wed Dec 18, 2013 4:11 pm
by Andy Mac
My main issue is the scenario may be to big its supposedto be in 2 parts
1st 6 months - Folly taking Rangoon
2nd 6 monts - Mountbatten's Genius - holding Rangoon and making a grab for Malaya
RE: New Small Map Scen - WIP
Posted: Thu Dec 19, 2013 7:59 pm
by Andy Mac
Has anyone plyed it out yet ?
Want to get sme feedback before tacklin the allied AI
RE: New Small Map Scen - WIP
Posted: Thu Dec 19, 2013 11:46 pm
by PaxMondo
TRying to pull together time this weekend ...
RE: New Small Map Scen - WIP
Posted: Fri Dec 20, 2013 4:29 am
by berto
This scenario is not Babes-compatible, should only be used with a standard AE install, right?
RE: New Small Map Scen - WIP
Posted: Sat Dec 21, 2013 9:16 pm
by JeffroK
Gday Andy,
Still working through the game, up to late Feb 44.
Trying to avoid spoilers.
A bit of a grind on the ground, around Rangoon numbers are even, I got pushed out of Pegu 2 days before my forces arriving should have held it, but the IJA hasnt been strong enough to take Rangoon. (I'm not got to explain why so that others can work it out themselves[8D])
In the North I am just starting to move, the jungle is as much to blame as the IJA.
At sea, miniKB rules, at the moment, Beaufighters put 1 torp into a CVL/CVE, the IJN BB's keep visiting, again I got some torp claims, I should start getting my CVE armada soon so we'll see what happens next.
The air is in balance, and thats depite getting 2:1 victories, too many RAF sqns are based back in Assam so I'm fighting out of Rangoon, Bassein & Prome, The Spit VIII is supreme, 1 have 1 Sqn each of P51A, P47D-2 & P38J which do well but numbers are low. One of my better Sqns has B25H, some silly Hayabusa's got in the way of the 12 x 50cal, confetti! (I'd like to think they used the head on tactic used against B24D and assumed the B25 only had 1 forward mg)
Its a good little scenario, plenty of options to consider and cover.
RE: New Small Map Scen - MOUNTBATTENS FOLLY
Posted: Sun Dec 22, 2013 3:52 pm
by berto
ORIGINAL: Andy Mac
v5 Posted with working AI for Japan and many many amendments
Starting to play this.
With each new update, and in particular as you upgrade the AI, any chance it will work with an ongoing game? Or will restarts always be required?
RE: New Small Map Scen - MOUNTBATTENS FOLLY
Posted: Mon Dec 23, 2013 6:46 am
by Andy Mac
The AI doesnt update but I am not planning on messing with the Jap AI until a few people have played it through
Most of my efforts will be on the allied AI for the time being
Jeff my main concern is should it be one scen or two ??
i.e. 1st 6 months rescue XV COrps
2nd 6 months OPeration Zipper
To win the allies need Rangoon and Singapore
That was the intent of the scenario
Japan only needs one of them to win
RE: New Small Map Scen - MOUNTBATTENS FOLLY
Posted: Mon Dec 23, 2013 5:02 pm
by JeffroK
I would prefer 2 stand alone scenarios.
ZIPPER/TIDERACE has always been an interesting "what if".
In MF, I have moved along to late April 44, 14th Army has finally crawled out of the jungles onto the Central Burma plains. I can now concentrate them against what should be undersupplied IJA formations, strangely the IJA seems to be continually supplied??
Allied airpower starts to be overwhelming. I have reasonable numbers of P38H & Spit VIII and a few Sqns of P47D-25, P51B, Corsair II & Hellcat I and lots of Hurricane IIC. japanese airpower seems to have been worn down, 2000 plus losses must have some effect.
My 4 CVE rule the Bay of Bengal, as long as I keep out of range [8D] and the Killer B's are taking shots at various targets across the map.
The scenario has been a lot of fun, though I think I've broken the back of it now, I'll see how it pans out.
RE: New Small Map Scen - MOUNTBATTENS FOLLY
Posted: Thu Dec 26, 2013 7:14 pm
by Andy Mac
Has the Beaufighter being an attack bomber made them more credible I always strruggled with them as FB's in game ??
With that level of losses you may not need to take Singapore to win which may require a tweaking of the victory conditions
Andy
RE: New Small Map Scen - MOUNTBATTENS FOLLY
Posted: Thu Dec 26, 2013 11:49 pm
by JeffroK
Didnt know I had to take Singapore!!!!!
Late June, Ive relieved Rangoon, taken Pegu & Sittang Bridge and am about to try Moulmein. I might slow there ans try a right hook.
I've been sending recce flights over Mergui, Tavoy, Phuket * Langkawi looking for an easy capture to set up airbases to support landings on the Malay Peninsula.
RE: New Small Map Scen - MOUNTBATTENS FOLLY
Posted: Thu Dec 26, 2013 11:58 pm
by JeffroK
I'm unsure about the Beaufighter, about 140 TFX losses but they have had unescorted strikes against IJA TF moving within CAP range, not a fair comparison.
RE: New Small Map Scen - MOUNTBATTENS FOLLY
Posted: Fri Dec 27, 2013 8:11 am
by Andy Mac
Well I wasnt giving you all those extra naval assets in 2nd half for nothing.....
To draw allies should need to hold Rangoon
To win hold Rangoon and take Singapore by end Dec 44
RE: New Small Map Scen - MOUNTBATTENS FOLLY
Posted: Mon Dec 30, 2013 9:07 pm
by Andy Mac
One of the things I am really noticing in this scenario is how much more realistic the sub war plays out without hundreds of LBA concentrating on ASW
Andy
RE: New Small Map Scen - MOUNTBATTENS FOLLY
Posted: Tue Dec 31, 2013 11:54 pm
by JeffroK
I also like the Brigade/Regiment scale, but, would also like to rebuild them to Divisions now that Burma has been cleared.