RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Tue Mar 24, 2015 8:05 pm
New unit type that could be available for all Nations,Observation Balloons? ( At the present time this is just a test addition for the game)[:D]
Matrix Games Forums
What's your Strategy?
https://forums.matrixgames.com:443/
COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Page 2 of 7
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Tue Mar 24, 2015 8:09 pm
Observation Balloons have a sighting range off 5
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Tue Mar 24, 2015 8:22 pm
Russian Observation Balloon in the production screen.Also note Destroyers are a buildable option in game now,but as stated earlier,at the present time these are just trial runs for possible inclusion to the game.[;)]
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Tue Mar 24, 2015 8:35 pm
Kirk
Can you give a purchase price? How long to deploy once purchased? Upkeep cost in PP? Loss of strength, would that cause a minus MP? It looks to have movement range of 10 hexes, can it move over water hexes? Can it be disbanded? Does it detect submarines? Can it defend a hex (It appears to do so)? Does supply affect it's function in any way?
Bob
Can you give a purchase price? How long to deploy once purchased? Upkeep cost in PP? Loss of strength, would that cause a minus MP? It looks to have movement range of 10 hexes, can it move over water hexes? Can it be disbanded? Does it detect submarines? Can it defend a hex (It appears to do so)? Does supply affect it's function in any way?
Bob
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Tue Mar 24, 2015 8:37 pm
Observation Balloon stats = Cost 5 Production points, 1 Manpower, 1 Upkeep & only 2 Turns to build.
These units have only one purpose in game, and that is for visual detection of your enemies unit positions.
They can spot all unit types,on Land,Air & Sea,but they can't attack anything![;)]
Movement range is just 1 hex.But they can be transported by Rail & Sea.
These units have only one purpose in game, and that is for visual detection of your enemies unit positions.
They can spot all unit types,on Land,Air & Sea,but they can't attack anything![;)]
Movement range is just 1 hex.But they can be transported by Rail & Sea.
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Tue Mar 24, 2015 8:56 pm
If the balloon has 5 hex LOS, cannot the any enemy unit see the balloon at the same distance?
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Wed Mar 25, 2015 6:49 am
No other Units can't see beyond their own Line of Sight distance.
LAND UNITS
Garrison Line of Sight = 1
Infantry Line of Sight = 1
Armour Line of Sight = 1
Artillery Line of Sight = 1
Rail Gun Line of Sight = 1
Armoured Train Line of Sight = 1
Armoured CAR Line of Sight = 3
Cavalry Line of Sight = 2
AIRCRAFT
Fighter Line of Sight = 3
Bomber Line of Sight = 3
Zeppelin Line of Sight = 4
Balloon Line of Sight = 5
On the battlefield world war 1, Observation Balloon's played a very important roll, in that they could see what your enemy was upto, hence the need to use Fighter Aircraft to fly Balloon busting missions![;)]
The crucial role of observation balloons.
An observation balloon was both a vulnerable and a valuable target: the balloon was moored in a stationary position and was lifted by flammable hydrogen gas, whose use was necessitated by the scarcity of helium reserves among European powers. The observer, suspended in the wicker basket beneath, typically had a wireless transmitter, binoculars and/or a long-range camera. His job was to observe actions on the front-line and behind it, to spot enemy troop movements or unusual activity of any sort, and to call down artillery fire onto any worthwhile targets. Balloon observers were consequently targets of great importance to both sides, especially before any sort of infantry action or offensive, so individual pilots, flights or whole squadrons were frequently ordered to attack balloons, either in an attempt to destroy them or at least disrupt their observation activities.[1] Pilots on both sides tried to attack from a height that could enable them to fire without getting too close to the hydrogen and pull away fast. They were also cautioned not to go below 1000 feet in order to avoid machine gun and AA fire.
Due to their importance, balloons were usually given heavy defenses in the form of machine gun positions on the ground, anti-aircraft artillery, and standing fighter patrols stationed overhead. Other defenses included surrounding the main balloon with barrage balloons; stringing cables in the air in the vicinity of the balloons; putting machine guns in gondolas for observers to use; and flying balloons booby-trapped with explosives that could be remotely detonated from the ground. These measures made balloons very dangerous targets to approach.
LAND UNITS
Garrison Line of Sight = 1
Infantry Line of Sight = 1
Armour Line of Sight = 1
Artillery Line of Sight = 1
Rail Gun Line of Sight = 1
Armoured Train Line of Sight = 1
Armoured CAR Line of Sight = 3
Cavalry Line of Sight = 2
AIRCRAFT
Fighter Line of Sight = 3
Bomber Line of Sight = 3
Zeppelin Line of Sight = 4
Balloon Line of Sight = 5
On the battlefield world war 1, Observation Balloon's played a very important roll, in that they could see what your enemy was upto, hence the need to use Fighter Aircraft to fly Balloon busting missions![;)]
The crucial role of observation balloons.
An observation balloon was both a vulnerable and a valuable target: the balloon was moored in a stationary position and was lifted by flammable hydrogen gas, whose use was necessitated by the scarcity of helium reserves among European powers. The observer, suspended in the wicker basket beneath, typically had a wireless transmitter, binoculars and/or a long-range camera. His job was to observe actions on the front-line and behind it, to spot enemy troop movements or unusual activity of any sort, and to call down artillery fire onto any worthwhile targets. Balloon observers were consequently targets of great importance to both sides, especially before any sort of infantry action or offensive, so individual pilots, flights or whole squadrons were frequently ordered to attack balloons, either in an attempt to destroy them or at least disrupt their observation activities.[1] Pilots on both sides tried to attack from a height that could enable them to fire without getting too close to the hydrogen and pull away fast. They were also cautioned not to go below 1000 feet in order to avoid machine gun and AA fire.
Due to their importance, balloons were usually given heavy defenses in the form of machine gun positions on the ground, anti-aircraft artillery, and standing fighter patrols stationed overhead. Other defenses included surrounding the main balloon with barrage balloons; stringing cables in the air in the vicinity of the balloons; putting machine guns in gondolas for observers to use; and flying balloons booby-trapped with explosives that could be remotely detonated from the ground. These measures made balloons very dangerous targets to approach.
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Wed Mar 25, 2015 8:18 pm
If I had it my way: I'd definitely stick with the destroyers, I'm a bit "iffy" on observation balloons, I see some merit to having them, but also see hex wise, they could get in the way
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Wed Mar 25, 2015 8:44 pm
ORIGINAL: operating
If I had it my way: I'd definitely stick with the destroyers, I'm a bit "iffy" on observation balloons, I see some merit to having them, but also see hex wise, they could get in the way
I think you are right, after a good few hours testing, I think the Observation Balloons are not going to be included in game.[;)]
But on a brighter note Belgium now have a general in game Gerard Leman.[:)]
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Wed Mar 25, 2015 9:27 pm
I have now removed all trace off Observation Balloons from the scripts in game, it was a worth while experiment, which in the end did not hit the spot.[;)]
But Belgium now has a second General Victor Deguise to use,this completes the new Generals for Belgium,I think 2 is enough.[:)]
But Belgium now has a second General Victor Deguise to use,this completes the new Generals for Belgium,I think 2 is enough.[:)]
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Wed Mar 25, 2015 10:52 pm
I like the concept of observation balloons. Perhaps they could still be included not as standalone units, but as an ability abstracted into the infantry divisions. Maybe the result of a research upgrade, they could act as a temporary LOS bonus for an infantry unit, that could in turn be countered by enemy fighters?
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Wed Mar 25, 2015 11:09 pm
Question: ( I have not used 1.62 yet) Has LOS been lowered in the new patch for many units as indicated in the chart below (ie. armored car from 4 to a 3 LOS)?
ORIGINAL: kirk23
No other Units can't see beyond their own Line of Sight distance.
LAND UNITS
Garrison Line of Sight = 1
Infantry Line of Sight = 1
Armour Line of Sight = 1
Artillery Line of Sight = 1
Rail Gun Line of Sight = 1
Armoured Train Line of Sight = 1
Armoured CAR Line of Sight = 3
Cavalry Line of Sight = 2
AIRCRAFT
Fighter Line of Sight = 3
Bomber Line of Sight = 3
Zeppelin Line of Sight = 4
Balloon Line of Sight = 5
On the battlefield world war 1, Observation Balloon's played a very important roll, in that they could see what your enemy was upto, hence the need to use Fighter Aircraft to fly Balloon busting missions![;)]
The crucial role of observation balloons.
An observation balloon was both a vulnerable and a valuable target: the balloon was moored in a stationary position and was lifted by flammable hydrogen gas, whose use was necessitated by the scarcity of helium reserves among European powers. The observer, suspended in the wicker basket beneath, typically had a wireless transmitter, binoculars and/or a long-range camera. His job was to observe actions on the front-line and behind it, to spot enemy troop movements or unusual activity of any sort, and to call down artillery fire onto any worthwhile targets. Balloon observers were consequently targets of great importance to both sides, especially before any sort of infantry action or offensive, so individual pilots, flights or whole squadrons were frequently ordered to attack balloons, either in an attempt to destroy them or at least disrupt their observation activities.[1] Pilots on both sides tried to attack from a height that could enable them to fire without getting too close to the hydrogen and pull away fast. They were also cautioned not to go below 1000 feet in order to avoid machine gun and AA fire.
Due to their importance, balloons were usually given heavy defenses in the form of machine gun positions on the ground, anti-aircraft artillery, and standing fighter patrols stationed overhead. Other defenses included surrounding the main balloon with barrage balloons; stringing cables in the air in the vicinity of the balloons; putting machine guns in gondolas for observers to use; and flying balloons booby-trapped with explosives that could be remotely detonated from the ground. These measures made balloons very dangerous targets to approach.
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Thu Mar 26, 2015 5:50 am
ORIGINAL: operating
Question: ( I have not used 1.62 yet) Has LOS been lowered in the new patch for many units as indicated in the chart below (ie. armored car from 4 to a 3 LOS)?
ORIGINAL: kirk23
No other Units can't see beyond their own Line of Sight distance.
LAND UNITS
Garrison Line of Sight = 1
Infantry Line of Sight = 1
Armour Line of Sight = 1
Artillery Line of Sight = 1
Rail Gun Line of Sight = 1
Armoured Train Line of Sight = 1
Armoured CAR Line of Sight = 3
Cavalry Line of Sight = 2
AIRCRAFT
Fighter Line of Sight = 3
Bomber Line of Sight = 3
Zeppelin Line of Sight = 4
Balloon Line of Sight = 5
On the battlefield world war 1, Observation Balloon's played a very important roll, in that they could see what your enemy was upto, hence the need to use Fighter Aircraft to fly Balloon busting missions![;)]
The crucial role of observation balloons.
An observation balloon was both a vulnerable and a valuable target: the balloon was moored in a stationary position and was lifted by flammable hydrogen gas, whose use was necessitated by the scarcity of helium reserves among European powers. The observer, suspended in the wicker basket beneath, typically had a wireless transmitter, binoculars and/or a long-range camera. His job was to observe actions on the front-line and behind it, to spot enemy troop movements or unusual activity of any sort, and to call down artillery fire onto any worthwhile targets. Balloon observers were consequently targets of great importance to both sides, especially before any sort of infantry action or offensive, so individual pilots, flights or whole squadrons were frequently ordered to attack balloons, either in an attempt to destroy them or at least disrupt their observation activities.[1] Pilots on both sides tried to attack from a height that could enable them to fire without getting too close to the hydrogen and pull away fast. They were also cautioned not to go below 1000 feet in order to avoid machine gun and AA fire.
Due to their importance, balloons were usually given heavy defenses in the form of machine gun positions on the ground, anti-aircraft artillery, and standing fighter patrols stationed overhead. Other defenses included surrounding the main balloon with barrage balloons; stringing cables in the air in the vicinity of the balloons; putting machine guns in gondolas for observers to use; and flying balloons booby-trapped with explosives that could be remotely detonated from the ground. These measures made balloons very dangerous targets to approach.
Hi Bob, LOS has not been lowered in 1.6.2 for other land units, I was only testing various options, if Observation Balloons ever made it into the game.[;)]
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Thu Mar 26, 2015 6:00 am
ORIGINAL: Objekt730
I like the concept of observation balloons. Perhaps they could still be included not as standalone units, but as an ability abstracted into the infantry divisions. Maybe the result of a research upgrade, they could act as a temporary LOS bonus for an infantry unit, that could in turn be countered by enemy fighters?
I was thinking along the same lines,of abstracting Observation Balloons into the game as a possible research bonus to land units.[;)]
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Thu Mar 26, 2015 3:02 pm
German General Ludendorff.[;)]
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Thu Mar 26, 2015 3:34 pm
Would like to see Herr Ludendorff's stats..[:)]
ORIGINAL: kirk23
German General Ludendorff.[;)]
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Thu Mar 26, 2015 5:40 pm
General Ludendorff stats.[:)]
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Thu Mar 26, 2015 5:42 pm
General Albrecht[;)] ( In the last patch I hear that some crashes were due to Commander activation, If these new Generals are added officially to future patches, I guarantee no crashes will be caused by Commander activation issues)[:)]
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Thu Mar 26, 2015 5:51 pm
Can see why Herr Ludendorff will be very popular in the game!!!![;)]
ORIGINAL: kirk23
General Ludendorff stats.[:)]
RE: COMMANDER THE GREAT WAR AND ITS FUTURE.
Posted: Thu Mar 26, 2015 9:54 pm
German Admiral Von Ingenohl[:D]
