Page 2 of 2
RE: Wiki for NewDawn features?
Posted: Sat Nov 04, 2017 1:46 pm
by sIg3b
Hmmmph; one thing I really like to have is precise rulus as in a boardgame. I never want to be reduced to guessing if reinforcements can reach a given hex, or if my Strategic Transport resources are sufficient.
RE: Wiki for NewDawn features?
Posted: Sat Nov 04, 2017 7:40 pm
by ernieschwitz
Some people call lack of control realism, however I do feel your pain.

RE: Wiki for NewDawn features?
Posted: Sun Nov 05, 2017 2:57 pm
by sIg3b
Lack of control is ok, where intentional and defined, like Command&Control rules; I just don´t like a lack of control that creeps in through bugs or a vague manual.
That said, I am very impressed with the positives of 2.25; incremental AI improvements over the years really add up to something! Fighting one AI is still easy, but at least it does now fight back and even tries to form a coherent line. And 2 Allied AIs have become challenging.
With TOEs and all the incremental improvements, I find ATG 2.25 about 8x as good as the original AT.
RE: Wiki for NewDawn features?
Posted: Mon Nov 06, 2017 5:40 am
by Vic
One thing that is not clear to me at all is this: Suppose my Supreme HQ has only Trains, no Trucks -does it deliver only to HQs/units that sit directly on rails, or can the SFs move a couple hexes on their own volition AFTER leaving the trains?
No that should not be possible.
My ideal setup for the TOE feature with a large army would be something like
HIGH HQ => by train => LOWER HQ (on rail hex) => by truck => Units (out in the field)
Best wishes,
Vic
RE: Wiki for NewDawn features?
Posted: Mon Nov 06, 2017 6:16 pm
by sIg3b
ORIGINAL: Vic
One thing that is not clear to me at all is this: Suppose my Supreme HQ has only Trains, no Trucks -does it deliver only to HQs/units that sit directly on rails, or can the SFs move a couple hexes on their own volition AFTER leaving the trains?
No that should not be possible.
My ideal setup for the TOE feature with a large army would be something like
HIGH HQ => by train => LOWER HQ (on rail hex) => by truck => Units (out in the field)
Best wishes,
Vic
*Precisely* what I was doing in my 2nd game.
I must be a fast learner. [:D]

RE: Wiki for NewDawn features?
Posted: Tue Nov 07, 2017 2:21 am
by Ormand
Another little tip is that the reinforcements will go to your HQ at the beginning of your turn. They will be dispersed to your units at towards the end. But, if you are impatient, or want to make sure they go where you want, you can move them during your turn. For the most part, you should let the TOE system move things around for you even though it will take an extra turn because the movement costs for the TOE system are less, and you will move things more quickly. In addition, there doesn't seem to be the readiness loss that comes with transferring units from one HQ to another. Again, largely because it will take you a bit longer than doing it directly yourself.
You should also make sure your SHQ has some trucks as wlel, just in case you need to transfer to HQs that had to be moved off the rail.
Lastly, on a large map, you might need more than one layer of HQs, you might want to have trains in the second HQ as well.
RE: Wiki for NewDawn features?
Posted: Tue Nov 07, 2017 7:17 pm
by sIg3b
And I suppose if the reinforcements have to cross the ocean, it will take longer, and likely get more complicated?
RE: Wiki for NewDawn features?
Posted: Wed Nov 08, 2017 4:11 am
by Ormand
Yes, and no. First, you need enough transports, which might have to be assigned to the same HQ, like trains need to be) for the HQ to send them abroad. They can then be shipped to an HQ in a port. The reinforcements will then be dispersed as usual. In addition, the transfers can be intercepted by anti-supply. So, you could lose some. Basically, you need to to have enough cargoships, for transport, to send the requested reinforcements to an HQ in a distant port. But, beware, the enemy can intercept them.
RE: Wiki for NewDawn features?
Posted: Wed Nov 08, 2017 2:29 pm
by sIg3b
ORIGINAL: Ormand
Yes, and no. First, you need enough transports, which might have to be assigned to the same HQ, like trains need to be) for the HQ to send them abroad. They can then be shipped to an HQ in a port. The reinforcements will then be dispersed as usual. In addition, the transfers can be intercepted by anti-supply. So, you could lose some. Basically, you need to to have enough cargoships, for transport, to send the requested reinforcements to an HQ in a distant port. But, beware, the enemy can intercept them.
So I need:
1) Supreme HQ with Trains
2) Port HQ with Cargo Ships
3) Port HQ on the other side of the ocean with Trains
4) Forward HQ with Trucks
Reinforcements to reach the units will take a whopping 4 turns. That is, if I do everything right, have the required amount of transport everywhere and don´t get intercepted.
Well,ok. I suppose intercontinental invasions shouldn´t be too easy.
RE: Wiki for NewDawn features?
Posted: Wed Nov 08, 2017 9:12 pm
by Ormand
Yes, that's pretty much it.
It isn't as bad as it first looks. There are several positive benefits with the TOE system. For one, it costs less to reinforce units, and there isn't that terrible loss in readiness when transferring to a different HQ. In addition, when you do it manually, you have pretty much the same turn delay, since you transfer to an HQ, but then can't use movement (I believe) to send them to another unit after the transfer. Like I said before, the transfer to the final unit looks like it will happen that turn anyway. At the start of the turn, the SFTypes that get transferred to an HQ can move that turn, so you can send them to their respective units manually during your turn. They will use either own movement or the trucks in the destination HQ. It is a pretty good system that will save some time, but you should watch over it every now and then.
You can also skip the transfer to Port HQ with Cargo Ships by sending production to that HQ. I don't do this against the AI myself. I tend to send all production to the SHQ unless the city is isolated or on another continent. The reason being that this gives the AI a little help. It also represents what would be called a proper centralized system. Plus, the TOE, human players get a leg up on how it went before.
RE: Wiki for NewDawn features?
Posted: Fri Nov 10, 2017 1:19 pm
by sIg3b
Yes, I think on large maps you could also decentralize and increase efficiency at the expense of some micromanagement getting back in.