Page 2 of 2

RE: Optimum Surface Combat TF Composition

Posted: Sat May 11, 2019 10:56 am
by Lowpe
ORIGINAL: BBfanboy

ORIGINAL: AleRonin
I try to take advantage of this by having multiple combats during one night by using multiple small task forces. I have a feeling that damage, even slight damage but especially fire, increases the combat dl in subsequent combats.

Question about this sentence, but is every TF following each other? I mean like a chain.
TFs usually engage in order of their TF number, It is usually not good to have SCTFs set to follow one another because if the first one withdraws the others might not engage. Just set them all to patrol in or around the target hex with a react setting.
Note that engagement is not guaranteed - there is always a detection/engagement check before any combat happens but as Lowpe notes, initial combats are likely to raise the D/L enough for nearby TFs to find and engage the enemy.


The task forces usually have either a destination point or a patrol point, I almost never use follow ever under any circumstance. I do like reaction range for surface action groups.

RE: Optimum Surface Combat TF Composition

Posted: Sat May 11, 2019 11:00 am
by Lowpe
ORIGINAL: BBfanboy
Lowpe: 4th: I love threat tolerance set to low

Lowpe did you really mean this? Wouldn't that result in TFs being reluctant to engage?


Absolutely! Almost 100% of the time. How it seems to work in game, after extensive use, is that there seems to be no reluctance to engage although this might be due to the fact most Allied players use aggressive leaders. Each task force will usually only have one combat and then withdraw...

But my SAG tend to disengage early, so I get an initial torpedo launch and then if out gunned a retreat. There seems to be no effect against normal merchant convoys.

As Japan I try to maximize the torpedo attacks and slight skirmish instead of a punishing slugfest for a variety of reasons.

RE: Optimum Surface Combat TF Composition

Posted: Sat May 11, 2019 11:04 am
by AleRonin
Thanks guys for the explanations!
The task forces usually have either a destination point or a patrol point, I almost never use follow ever under any circumstance. I do like reaction range for surface action groups.

Another question arise...neither for Amphibious TF? How do you handle the SAG TF then?

RE: Optimum Surface Combat TF Composition

Posted: Sun May 12, 2019 3:35 am
by Alfred
ORIGINAL: Lowpe

... I have a feeling that damage, even slight damage but especially fire, increases the combat dl in subsequent combats.

For example skirmishing task force of 2 DD attacks, scores a few 12 cm hits to the superstructure starting a fire and retires --- any subsequent combats that enemy ship on fire is easier to hit while I am using ships that are undamaged. Of course I could be all wrong, but I like it.[:D] ...


You are not wrong.

A ship on fire isn't per se easier to hit. The fire itself will increase the DL, particularly if it is a night combat, of the ship itself and thus means it is a more prominent target to be selected by other friendly ships. The amount of damage sustained can lead to system damage which reduces it's speed and in that sense makes it easier to be hit.

Fire therefore impacts on the DL of the ship both in the current combat and provided the fire is still raging, on subsequent combats. Even when the fire has been extinguished, the effects of the fire may still disadvantage the ship in combat.

Alfred

RE: Optimum Surface Combat TF Composition

Posted: Mon May 13, 2019 11:34 am
by AleRonin
Lowpe, I have two questions for this sentence:

The task forces usually have either a destination point or a patrol point, I almost never use follow ever under any circumstance. I do like reaction range for surface action groups.

How do you handle the SAG in an Amphibious TF if you don't use follow?

Also, for a CV TF in escort, is the follow setting the right choice?

Thanks


RE: Optimum Surface Combat TF Composition

Posted: Mon May 13, 2019 12:29 pm
by Miller
Never mix types, therefore BB CA CL all in separate TFs and make sure their speeds are pretty much the same. Between 8-12 ships per TF, ideally 2 DDs for every larger ship (so 4 CA 8 DD) etc.

I've played IJN opponents who put 18 knot CLs and 16 knot PBs/Es in the same TF as 30+ knot CAs and DDs and they perform terribly as they are restricted to the top speed of the slowest ship in the combat phase and are much more likely to be hit.

RE: Optimum Surface Combat TF Composition

Posted: Mon May 13, 2019 12:34 pm
by Lowpe
ORIGINAL: AleRonin

Lowpe, I have two questions for this sentence:

The task forces usually have either a destination point or a patrol point, I almost never use follow ever under any circumstance. I do like reaction range for surface action groups.

How do you handle the SAG in an Amphibious TF if you don't use follow?

Also, for a CV TF in escort, is the follow setting the right choice?

Thanks

I count hexes and use remain on station for amphibious task forces. SAG that protect the amphibious TF are set to the same hex, but with patrol and I use a little bit of reaction range on them.



RE: Optimum Surface Combat TF Composition

Posted: Mon May 13, 2019 12:49 pm
by Chickenboy
ORIGINAL: Lowpe
I have a feeling that damage, even slight damage but especially fire, increases the combat dl in subsequent combats.

For example skirmishing task force of 2 DD attacks, scores a few 12 cm hits to the superstructure starting a fire and retires --- any subsequent combats that enemy ship on fire is easier to hit while I am using ships that are undamaged. Of course I could be all wrong, but I like it.[:D]

I get this 'feeling' too, but don't know if it's based on (game) reality. But it would make sense. In the battle of Savo island, IJN ships turned off their search lights after a while, as the Allied heavy cruisers were burning well enough to illuminate the battle area by themselves.

RE: Optimum Surface Combat TF Composition

Posted: Tue May 14, 2019 2:20 pm
by AleRonin
Thanks for your feedbacks, I will try to apply them in my current game [:)]

RE: Optimum Surface Combat TF Composition

Posted: Tue May 14, 2019 2:38 pm
by RangerJoe
By using a bunch of small surface task forces first to engage the enemy, the enemy SCTF uses up some ammo and in further combats it seems that the enemy does not fire as often as next fresh, fully ammo loaded SCTF that engages them. Plus the possibility of having enemy ships being torpedoed by a long lance or another torpedo at two to four thousands yards by surprise can ruin their whole night.

I think that the low aggression rating is so that the SCTF will disengage if outnumbered and/or facing enemy combat vessels. They tend to take a few quick shots and fire any torpedoes, then sail away. From what I have seen, the ships tend to concentrate on the enemy merchant vessels and not the escort vessels. If the task force has no combat vessels, then the low aggression SCTF stays and has a live fire exercise.

Edited for spelling. [:@] Sometimes my "X" key and others being depressed does not register.

RE: Optimum Surface Combat TF Composition

Posted: Wed May 15, 2019 1:29 pm
by AleRonin
Another question:
which leader is more important in a TF, TF leader or ship leader?
I would say both, maybe the former is more important.

Because if you create multiple small TFs (i.e. 1 BB+DDs, 1 CA+DDs, and so on) TF leaders above 70 as naval skill are not so much...

RE: Optimum Surface Combat TF Composition

Posted: Wed May 15, 2019 3:03 pm
by RangerJoe
Bad naval skills can lead to bumper ships.

Ships leaders first since if the task force disbands, then the points for the task force leader go away. If you need to send all of the ships into repair mode, then assign a PB or HDML, whatever you have, for the Task Force commander to use as a yacht to keep the task force still in existence with the leader. Then, add the ships that you want after repairs are complete. If it is an aircraft carrier task force and all of the carriers need body and fender work, do the same but when you want to put carriers back into it, then make it an escort task force, add the carrier and then remove any ships not eligible to be in a carrier task force. The task force should then revert to an aircraft carrier task force.