Page 2 of 2

Re: AAR War in Spain (España en Guerra)

Posted: Thu Dec 11, 2025 9:58 pm
by LordSpain
Image
Turn 20. I want to make a brief assessment and, with it, bring this AAR to a close, as its aim was to show the opening stages of the campaign. I love the game; there is a variety of options and situations that are truly worth highlighting.
So then, in this wrap-up, if we look at the naval side, we can see that in capital ships we have lost the ones shown in red, while the Republicans have suffered losses in those shown in green. Sinking 2 enemy destroyers, given the small number of ships, the low level of readiness, and the few weapons available to counter them, I take as a small success. Not so much on the merchant-war side, where we have only managed to sink a few ships.

Turno 20. Quiero hacer un pequeño balance y con esto, dar por finalizado este aar que pretendía mostrar los primeros compases de la campaña. El juego me encanta, hay una diversidad de opciones y de situaciones, dignas de resaltar. Pues bien, en este cierre, si nos vamos a la parte naval, vemos que en buques capitales hemos perdido los buques en color rojo, mientras que los republicanos han sufrido bajas en los de color verde. Hundir 2 destructores enemigos, dado el escaso número de buques, bajo nivel de preparación y las pocas armas para contrarrestarlos, lo tomo como un pequeño éxito. No tanto en la parte de la guerra mercante, donde solo hemos podido hundir unos pocos buques.

Image
Nothing to say about all the ships of the Nationalist side that have been sunk. We have really taken a good beating in these early turns. It must also be acknowledged that I have been very aggressive in an attempt to move troops from North Africa and the Canary Islands to the Iberian Peninsula.
The Nationalist side is not ready to carry out such a bold move at the outset, with zero air support and limited naval strength. Hence the fact that the airlift from Morocco to Seville (for example) is of vital importance (just as it was in reality).

Nada que decir de todos los buques hundidos del bando nacional. Realmente nos han dado una buena paliza en estos primeros turnos. También hay que reconocer que he sido muy agresivo en un intento de movilizar tropas desde el norte de África y las Islas Canarias hacia la península ibérica. El bando nacional no está listo para hacer un movimiento tan osado en los inicios, con cero apoyo aéreo y poca potencia naval. De ahí que el puente aéreo desde Marruecos a Sevilla (por ejemplo), sea de vital importancia (tal como ocurrió en la realidad).

Image
In the air war, there is little to comment on. The Nationalist side has virtually no aircraft to confront the Republican side in the early stages. Little by little, air units begin to arrive, both our own and those of our Italian and German allies.

En la parte aérea, poco que comentar. El bando nacional tiene nulos aparatos para hacer frente al bando republicano en los inicios. Poco a poco van llegando unidades aéreas tanto propias como de los aliados italianos y alemanes.

Image
As a final snapshot, I’m leaving you with statistical data from turn 0, the mid-game turns, and this last one. It shows how things have evolved in terms of number of bases, victory points, ships sunk, air losses, and so on. A summary of what has happened and what we’ve been reporting along the way.

Como imagen final, les dejo datos estadísticos del turno 0, mitad de turnos y este último. Queda reflejada la evolución en cuanto al número de bases, valor en puntos, buques hundidos, bajas aéreas, .... Un resumen de lo que ha pasado y que hemos ido contando.


I would like to thank the entire War in Spain 1936–1939 team for the opportunity they have given me to write this AAR and to take part in the game’s beta. I feel that a part of my country’s history, and my own family history, is being portrayed as faithfully as possible, which allows us to tell some incredible stories and gives us a chance to delve even deeper into the events that took place there.
Because in the end, while you play, you end up looking for information, watching videos, reading books and articles… it becomes a way of enriching our culture through games. So once again, many thanks for this opportunity, and see you on the battlefield!

Quiero agradecer a todo el equipo de trabajo de War in Spain 1936-1939 la oportunidad que me han brindado para realizar este aar y participar en la beta del juego. Siento que una parte de la historia de mi país y familiar está siendo reflejada de la forma más fiel posible, lo que nos permite narrar unas historias increíbles y nos da pie a profundizar más aún en los acontecimientos que allí ocurrieron. Porque al final, mientras juegas, vas buscando información, viendo vídeos, leyendo libros y artículos, ... es una oportunidad de aumentar y enriquecer nuestra cultura a través de los juegos. Así que nuevamente, mil gracias por esta oportunidad y ¡¡ nos vemos en el frente de batalla !!

Re: War in Spain 1936-39 AAR #2: War in Spain (España en Guerra)

Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2025 3:33 pm
by Q-Ball
Well done, this was really informative! Love the pictures and descriptions!

As a veteran WITP-AE player, I cringed when you took those damaged ships to sea.......Espana, Navarra, and Velasco all start with alot of damage (since they were in the middle of refits). I would probably play it more conservative and try and get the Sys and Eng damage down before heading south, but that's just me........though I understand as the Nationalists that's all you have early-on

IIRC, Espana had a turret out of action at war start, so repair of that might have to wait.

Re: War in Spain 1936-39 AAR #2: War in Spain (España en Guerra)

Posted: Thu Dec 18, 2025 9:05 am
by Dali101
Espana had only 4 functional main guns at the beginning of the war.
After about 3 months, another 2 guns were repaired and put into operation.

In 1938, it was possible (although only hypothetically, since she sank in 1937) to re-arm the original 8 main guns.

This is how it is modeled in the game.

Navarra (ex Reina Victoria) is a completely non-functional ship. Disarmed of the main armament and essentially retired as a floating ship.
She served as a training area for the artillery cadet school, which is why I left several small-caliber weapons on this ship.
This ship is facing an almost two-year general reconstruction (and to be honest, it is best to send her to Germany after emergency repairs so as not to block the limited capacity of the Spanish shipyards)

Re: War in Spain 1936-39 AAR #2: War in Spain (España en Guerra)

Posted: Thu Dec 18, 2025 9:08 am
by Dali101
I would also like to point out that some aircraft types (Bre 19, DH.89, Fokker VII, Ju 52 and others) can be converted in the game for a different purpose.
For example, the Bre 19 has two possible versions, as a recon or as a light bomber.
You can invoke this conversion by clicking on the image of the aircraft...
(most conversions are available from 8 months onwards, which is indicated by the blue color)

Re: War in Spain 1936-39 AAR #2: War in Spain (España en Guerra)

Posted: Thu Dec 18, 2025 2:25 pm
by jwilkerson
Excellent AAR - thanks so much LS !!! :)

Re: War in Spain 1936-39 AAR #2: War in Spain (España en Guerra)

Posted: Thu Dec 18, 2025 6:15 pm
by Q-Ball
Dali101 wrote: Thu Dec 18, 2025 9:05 am Espana had only 4 functional main guns at the beginning of the war.
After about 3 months, another 2 guns were repaired and put into operation.

In 1938, it was possible (although only hypothetically, since she sank in 1937) to re-arm the original 8 main guns.

This is how it is modeled in the game.
Might be display differences, but in WITP-AE, usually the SYS and ENG damage is separate from disabled weapons.....SYS Damage impacts all ship operations, and in WITP-AE would be repaired ideally before she put to sea, even if the 2 wing turrets are disabled (which would make her a Pre-Drednaught!). IIRC, Espana was in dry-dock and under repairs, so makes sense she was "damaged".

Probably Nationalists just have to live with having no Navy until the Cervera is ready

Re: War in Spain 1936-39 AAR #2: War in Spain (España en Guerra)

Posted: Sat Dec 20, 2025 11:58 am
by comte
Great AAR!

Ths looks like THE Spanish Civil War game!

Been waiting forever for someone to make a game like this.

Re: War in Spain 1936-39 AAR #2: War in Spain (España en Guerra)

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2025 12:12 pm
by lecrop
Amazing AAR, thank you LordSpain

Re: War in Spain 1936-39 AAR #2: War in Spain (España en Guerra)

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2025 5:45 pm
by jwilkerson
comte wrote: Sat Dec 20, 2025 11:58 am Been waiting forever for someone to make a game like this.
Me three !!!

We have 52 titles on our wish list. One down and 51 left to go !! :o

Re: War in Spain 1936-39 AAR #2: War in Spain (España en Guerra)

Posted: Thu Dec 25, 2025 6:02 pm
by SuluSea
:lol:
jwilkerson wrote: Mon Dec 22, 2025 5:45 pm
comte wrote: Sat Dec 20, 2025 11:58 am Been waiting forever for someone to make a game like this.
Me three !!!

We have 52 titles on our wish list. One down and 51 left to go !! :o

Re: War in Spain 1936-39 AAR #2: War in Spain (España en Guerra)

Posted: Thu Dec 25, 2025 6:03 pm
by SuluSea
Enjoyed the reading ,explanations and overall presentations Lord Spain! Very well done!

Re: War in Spain 1936-39 AAR #2: War in Spain (España en Guerra)

Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2026 12:19 am
by btd64
Great job LordSpain 👏 👍....GP