Page 2 of 3
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 2:31 pm
by Hortlund
*sigh* No one thinks Im funny
[:(]
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 2:40 pm
by tsimmonds
Sorry, we're all too busy laughing at our own jokes. Nice post, btw. LMAO. Really, I did.
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 2:47 pm
by Tomo
Dear mjjhnim.
Welcome a board.
I know your hard feelings about historical problem.
However this is just a game. Not real war. Relax [;)]
This game simulate during WWII period. Unfortunately Korea was occupied by Japan at that time.
I feel "Sea of Japan" is suitable for WitP( I don't know for other place), isn't it?
Let's enjoy WitP together[:)]
BTW, Which side are you playing this game? Of course as Allied player?
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 3:51 pm
by pompack
ORIGINAL: rogueusmc
I know we have a lake that some call 'Lake Dallas' and some call it 'Lake Louisville' it all depends on the side of the lake you live on....[:)]
Yes but some ignore the civic chauvinism and call it Garza-Little Elm Lake (especially the people who live in Little Elm, Texas)
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 3:54 pm
by ZOOMIE1980
ORIGINAL: mjjhnim
Hi, thankyou for the great game and many support on this board.
but I would like to address the need for some changes in the map.
The Sea of Japan is totally wrong, it should be EAST SEA. It was "east sea"
for hundreds of years...before Japan's muddling.
Japan is economic power house and never learned from the
history about their savage treatment of Koreans and Chinese and Allied POWs.
If they have the means, these pople will do the same things...
Now they want a sea of their own... so instead of EAST SEA, its now Sea of Japan.
Japan spends alot of money, influencing map making companies around the world.
But what is wrong is wrong. I hope MATRIX can make things right.
These map problems may mean nothing to you guys. But it sure means a lot to
millions of people in Korea. We been mudered and attacked by Japan for many
years, and now in this modern age, just because Japan is regaining their world
power status in economy,and military. We shall never accept Japan taking our
sea and land.
Please help us.
Take it to a political forum....
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 4:00 pm
by mdiehl
Isn't "Sea of Japan" in any case a name bestowed by the 'evil' UK ([&o] rule, Britannia) and Portugese?
Well, mjjhnim, I'm not sure for whom you are advocating. Your point is worth noting but people will call things what they will. I'm pretty sure that most Native Americans would not refer to the "Gulf of California" as that or the "Sea of Cortez." Most Americans call Arizona, New Mexico, and southern California the "southwest" but most Mexicans call it the "northwest." Some Mexicans call it "stolen" land despite the fact that the US purchased half the property fair and square, and conquered the other half in a war started by Mexico. Ironic that the Mexicans call it that when it was they, in turn, who "stole it" from the Queen of Spain, and Spain, in turn, stole it from the various Native Americans living there at the time.
So what can you do? Every tribe has a different name for geographic features great and small, but you can only use one name on a map.
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 4:02 pm
by ZOOMIE1980
ORIGINAL: mdiehl
Isn't "Sea of Japan" in any case a name bestowed by the 'evil' UK ([&o] rule, Britannia) and Portugese?
Well, mjjhnim, I'm not sure for whom you are advocating. Your point is worth noting but people will call things what they will. I'm pretty sure that most Native Americans would not refer to the "Gulf of California" as that or the "Sea of Cortez." Most Americans call Arizona, New Mexico, and southern California the "southwest" but most Mexicans call it the "northwest." Some Mexicans call it "stolen" land despite the fact that the US purchased half the property fair and square, and conquered the other half in a war started by Mexico. Ironic that the Mexicans call it that when it was they, in turn, who "stole it" from the Queen of Spain, and Spain, in turn, stole it from the various Native Americans living there at the time.
So what can you do? Every tribe has a different name for geographic features great and small, but you can only use one name on a map.
The winners write the history books and the maps....been that way from the dawn of human history....
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 4:03 pm
by UncleBuck
You are Crazy. I named that body of water. It shoudl rightly be called... BOB. I was going to name it Robert, but I thought it was too pretentious.
So I woudl liek you to stop lobbying to get the name changed to "East Sea" I am not mentioning it to Matrix because , well I don't care what they call it. But I do think that it shoudl be called BOB and not East Sea.
I am looking at having it's legal name changed from BOB to EEKY EEKY EEKY NI NI NI But I am not sure Monty Python woudl approve. [:D]
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 4:16 pm
by mdiehl
As an example of what happens when negotiations end in a draw... there is a lake in the state of Massachusetts that has retained its Nipmuck (Native American) name, which I can't spell, and translates to: "You fish on your side, we'll fish on our side, nobody fishes in the middle." [:D]
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 4:29 pm
by Charles2222
It seems a bit silly to me. Down here in Texas we have the Gulf of Mexico and nobody assumes it's Mexican territory. There's bits of it that are Mexico and bits of it that are US, while the rest is neutral I suppose. Seems that's how waters would be interpeted worldwide wouldn't it?
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 4:42 pm
by pad152
mjjhnim
What a bunch of PC crap![:-]
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 4:53 pm
by DrewMatrix
FRANCE supports my struggle against Spanish city names in North America
Yeah. As I understand it we are going to have to stop saying
"The State of Illinois" ("Illinoy")
And start calling it "L'Etat d'Illinois" ("d'Ilinwaa") which is, after all, it's real name.
Des Moines and Dubuque are also in trouble No one who currently living in either city can pronounce their city's name.
But all this will only be temporary. Until we go back to using the original North American Indian names for everyplace.
But France, at that point, will have to stop using French place names. Nor Gaullic nor Gallo-Roman. They are going to have to use the Beaker People's placenames.
I think the Italians will have to revert to Etruscan, but I am still researching that one.
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 5:22 pm
by tsimmonds
ORIGINAL: Charles_22
It seems a bit silly to me. Down here in Texas we have the Gulf of Mexico and nobody assumes it's Mexican territory. There's bits of it that are Mexico and bits of it that are US, while the rest is neutral I suppose. Seems that's how waters would be interpeted worldwide wouldn't it?
Now that you mention it, I suppose it's little short of miraculous that it isn't called the Gulf of Texas![;)]
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 5:27 pm
by guke
Besides, as every German speaker knows, the East Sea is the body of water which
the evil Anglo-Saxons erroneously call Baltic Sea.
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 5:30 pm
by vonmoltke
ORIGINAL: pompacl
ORIGINAL: rogueusmc
I know we have a lake that some call 'Lake Dallas' and some call it 'Lake Louisville' it all depends on the side of the lake you live on....[:)]
Yes but some ignore the civic chauvinism and call it Garza-Little Elm Lake (especially the people who live in Little Elm, Texas)
Bah, who cares about civic chauvanism.
Its Lake Lewisville anyway. [:D]
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 5:31 pm
by anarchyintheuk
ORIGINAL: rogueusmc
I know we have a lake that some call 'Lake Dallas' and some call it 'Lake Louisville' it all depends on the side of the lake you live on....[:)]
It's only used to dump bodies in anyway. [;)]
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 5:32 pm
by vonmoltke
ORIGINAL: anarchyintheuk
ORIGINAL: rogueusmc
I know we have a lake that some call 'Lake Dallas' and some call it 'Lake Louisville' it all depends on the side of the lake you live on....[:)]
It's only used to dump bodies in anyway. [;)]
Nah, that's Lake Ray Hubbard. [:'(]
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 6:14 pm
by byron13
Not really going to jump into this one, but "East Sea" seems about as biased as "Sea of Japan." After all, the sea is only east of Korea (being west of Japan), hence, it seems to me that this name clearly has a Korean origin.
Just looking around the internet, it seems to be a real issue. Found this on a website sponsored, apparently, by the Japanese government:
"In response to the enquiry by the Government of Japan, the United Nations Secretariat officially replied on 10 March 2004, that 'Sea of Japan' is the standard geographical term and as such is to be used in official documents of the United Nations. It is confirmed that the name 'Sea of Japan' is authorized by the United Nations which is the most comprehensive and neutral international organization with the participation of 191 member states including both Japan and the Republic of Korea (ROK), and the most proper forum to represent the collective will of the international community."
Notice that mjjhnim has disappeared.
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 6:21 pm
by tsimmonds
Notice that mjjhnim has disappeared.
He's probably asleep. It's 4:30am in Seoul.
RE: Sea of JAPAN ?
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2004 7:44 pm
by pompack
ORIGINAL: irrelevant
Notice that mjjhnim has disappeared.
He's probably asleep. It's 4:30am in Seoul.
ya, but the Texans hijacked the thread anyway[:)]