RE: The rant goes on... Pzjg Hortlund vs Castor Troy
Posted: Thu Jan 24, 2008 7:24 am
unfortunately this game is on hold [:(]. Hortlund seems to have a corrupt file, he says he can´t load the turn. Rtrapasso would be so kind to run the turn but I think Hortlund won´t give away his password, we will see...
you could ask now, why on earth aren´t you just redoing the last two turns. Well, I had never problems redoing a turn when some kind of bug hit the game and it was obvious during the replay. Though this corrupt file thing is different. I had this happen earlier against Japanese opponents. The file seems not to be working. Sent it to someone other, it worked. Now if it would be a turn where it´s probably pretty quiet or if there´s nothing expected to be happening, no problem. The last time this corrupt file thing came up, the Japanese player lost a couple of carriers with me as the Allied suffering one bomb hit on my carriers. So it was a very special turn, where the corrupt file popped up... you go two turns back and the carriers wouldn´t meet two days later... deliberately, or just because you can´t give exactly the same orders like before...
Now in our case, I ordered a huge airstrike from India which could destroy a monthly Japanese aircraft production. What´s even more interesting is the fact, that I spotted Kirishima off Darwin, as I wrote in my last post, she (or more BBs) are either going to bombard Darwin (where I have 2 BBs and 70 torp bombers) or the Japanese are just going East. So what if this is a turn that is working? The IJN comes in, damages my 2 BBs and gets damaged also. Then 70 torp bombers attack the Japanese at 3 or 4 hexes range because their max speed dropped below 5 hexes... 2 BBs and a CA sunk or something like that are sunk... to top it off, my airforce from India torches 100 enemy fighters... would be a perfect turn for the corrupt file to jump out of the box... that´s why I´m insisting to see this file run on another computer, but that seems impossible at the moment... [:(]
I´m not blaming any of my opponents but in all honesty, the Japanese player is the one that resolves the turn, sees the results first. If he doesn´t like them, what does he do? Normally send it back of course, saying ouch... but he could also say the file doesn´t work, let´s go back two days and you will never see his carriers, BBs, aircraft... show up two days later at the place where he lost them (or would lose them) in the corrupt file turn... everytime (well, everytime isn´t really correct, but often) I had this corrupt file thing, it was a turn where something "special" happened, never when it was a usual turn. I don´t call anyone a cheater, but if I would go back two turns in this situation and then nothing happens at this date, then the game would have a really bad smell for me for the rest of it´s duration... or until we have the next corrupt file... So to really clear up all doubts, the turn should be sent to rtrapasso, who would be so kind to run it and then we would see what´s really happening. If Hortlund isn´t willing to give away his password, then I fear this PBEM has ended... another one... [8|][:(]
Please release AE with a working AI... [&o]
you could ask now, why on earth aren´t you just redoing the last two turns. Well, I had never problems redoing a turn when some kind of bug hit the game and it was obvious during the replay. Though this corrupt file thing is different. I had this happen earlier against Japanese opponents. The file seems not to be working. Sent it to someone other, it worked. Now if it would be a turn where it´s probably pretty quiet or if there´s nothing expected to be happening, no problem. The last time this corrupt file thing came up, the Japanese player lost a couple of carriers with me as the Allied suffering one bomb hit on my carriers. So it was a very special turn, where the corrupt file popped up... you go two turns back and the carriers wouldn´t meet two days later... deliberately, or just because you can´t give exactly the same orders like before...
Now in our case, I ordered a huge airstrike from India which could destroy a monthly Japanese aircraft production. What´s even more interesting is the fact, that I spotted Kirishima off Darwin, as I wrote in my last post, she (or more BBs) are either going to bombard Darwin (where I have 2 BBs and 70 torp bombers) or the Japanese are just going East. So what if this is a turn that is working? The IJN comes in, damages my 2 BBs and gets damaged also. Then 70 torp bombers attack the Japanese at 3 or 4 hexes range because their max speed dropped below 5 hexes... 2 BBs and a CA sunk or something like that are sunk... to top it off, my airforce from India torches 100 enemy fighters... would be a perfect turn for the corrupt file to jump out of the box... that´s why I´m insisting to see this file run on another computer, but that seems impossible at the moment... [:(]
I´m not blaming any of my opponents but in all honesty, the Japanese player is the one that resolves the turn, sees the results first. If he doesn´t like them, what does he do? Normally send it back of course, saying ouch... but he could also say the file doesn´t work, let´s go back two days and you will never see his carriers, BBs, aircraft... show up two days later at the place where he lost them (or would lose them) in the corrupt file turn... everytime (well, everytime isn´t really correct, but often) I had this corrupt file thing, it was a turn where something "special" happened, never when it was a usual turn. I don´t call anyone a cheater, but if I would go back two turns in this situation and then nothing happens at this date, then the game would have a really bad smell for me for the rest of it´s duration... or until we have the next corrupt file... So to really clear up all doubts, the turn should be sent to rtrapasso, who would be so kind to run it and then we would see what´s really happening. If Hortlund isn´t willing to give away his password, then I fear this PBEM has ended... another one... [8|][:(]
Please release AE with a working AI... [&o]