Page 3 of 5
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 11:37 pm
by denisonh
Good point Sonny. It takes a man of character to "take a licking and keep on ticking".
Funny thing as ALlies pre May 42 is that CV on CV battles favor the Japs in WitP very heavily, so unless you have a numeric advantage, it is best to "pick on the fringes" and hit him where his CVs are not.
Not abiding that, a CV battle is a huge gamble. And one of the primary rules of gambling is do not gamble what you cannot afford to lose (or otherwise put "don't gamble with scared money").
Allied players who roll the dice and lose have to wait to prosecute their offfensive and hope they can avoid auto victory. (That, BTW, is my estimation of what I have to achieve as the Allies in 1942)
Simply put, prepare for the consequences of your actions, accept your responsibility for it, and deal with it.
ORIGINAL: Sonny II
ORIGINAL: Mike Scholl
ORIGINAL: Sonny II
Take it as a victory and look for your next opponent.
Giving up when you consider the game lost is smarter than the Japanese were IRL after '44. Who needs the misery of a hopeless game? Use the time you would have "wasted" on a game where you are not having fun and get into a game more to your liking.
So as soon as you've had all your "fun" as the Japanese, you should just quit? Sounds a lot like the reverse of the coin that
viberpol is complaining about.
Its a game. If you don't enjoy playing it then quit.
However, if you continue to quit when you have a disappointing turn you will soon run out of PBEM opponents.
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 12:24 am
by moses
I will make three points:
Point 1: You should negotiate/discuss views with your prospective opponent in great detail prior to the start. You intend to be inolved with this person for two to three years. Spend at least three or four long posts making sure you agree on what you want from the game. I know it's hard because when the urge hits you just want to start a game. But you have to do it.
Point 2: If you want an historical start play the historical start or scenario 16. Anything else is crap. If you allow Japan to taylor its first move without massive compensation you're either a putz or you just want a lunacy game. If that's what you want then fine. Otherwise wait for an opponent who wants a real game.
Point 3: Whenever a massive loss occurs allow you're opponent some days to recover. Don't press, and if pressed just be non-commital and allow you're opponent time to recover. If he is adament not to continue then oh well. But often I have needed 3 or 4 days to deal with a massive setback.
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 1:40 am
by Sonny II
ORIGINAL: moses
....................
Point 3: Whenever a massive loss occurs allow you're opponent some days to recover. Don't press, and if pressed just be non-commital and allow you're opponent time to recover. If he is adament not to continue then oh well. But often I have needed 3 or 4 days to deal with a massive setback.
On the rare occasions that I have pulled off a massively devastating turn (or more likely it was my opponents blunder and not my great talents) I offer my opponent the chance to quit the game without prejudice as to being a future adversary.
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 2:01 am
by Feinder
New blood always brings up the old news. At least it's sales for Matrix, and certainly entertaining.
-F-
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 2:19 am
by denisonh
SO True F.
I went through the whole CV loss trauma thing in my UV days (call it my UV vaccination against CV loss trauma)
ORIGINAL: Feinder
New blood always brings up the old news. At least it's sales for Matrix, and certainly entertaining.
-F-
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 6:04 am
by Mike Scholl
ORIGINAL: Sonny II
Its a game. If you don't enjoy playing it then quit.
However, if you continue to quit when you have a disappointing turn you will soon run out of PBEM opponents.
That was my point. Just as the Allied player
owes it to his opponant to contionue even if he is getting his head handed to him in the early going, so the Japanese player
owes it to his opponant to maintain the struggle even if he feels the issue has been decided in the end game. It should be up to the player doing well to suggest an early ending by mutual consent in a PBEM game. Otherwise each should consider that he has made a commitment to continue to the end of the game.
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 7:54 am
by Przemcio231
ORIGINAL: ctangus
IMO the allied player here simply couldn't stomach the losses.
Well in my game ageinst Wild_Willie i lost nearly all of my US CV's early in the War and were left with Enterprise only i think. All i sunk was Akagi but i keeped playing on... and with my game ageainst another guy from Poland i lost US CV's and said that i had enough not becouse of those CV's but only becouse my opponent just bypassed Burma and Landed in India i had units defending all of bases from Diamond Harbor to Madras but he just used small fragments of Para units and took bases far bechind wich were undefended as i did not have enough units to hold them (i did not send many units from India to Burma)so i decided to take Lunga with 2nd Marines + some Aussie Brigade and support as i knew KB will be covering India. In the Aftermatch he was advancing in India as from his base he was providing Cover with Zeros and send the KB south to Salomons, sunk my fleet and Recaptured Lunga with 2 or 3 Divisions. This games alows totaly Ahistorical outcome's i can't imagine Japane's landing deep bechind enemy lines and then taking away their Carriers to take part in another operation.
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 8:03 am
by herwin
ORIGINAL: denisonh
SO True F.
I went through the whole CV loss trauma thing in my UV days (call it my UV vaccination against CV loss trauma)
ORIGINAL: Feinder
New blood always brings up the old news. At least it's sales for Matrix, and certainly entertaining.
-F-
I think I went through it playing against the AI, but it also helped to have some applicable RL experience. On the other hand, that applicable experience did lead to frustration when it became clear that the game wasn't RL but rather somewhere in a game designer's fantasy world.
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 9:36 am
by herwin
ORIGINAL: Przemcio231
ORIGINAL: ctangus
IMO the allied player here simply couldn't stomach the losses.
Well in my game ageinst Wild_Willie i lost nearly all of my US CV's early in the War and were left with Enterprise only i think. All i sunk was Akagi but i keeped playing on... and with my game ageainst another guy from Poland i lost US CV's and said that i had enough not becouse of those CV's but only becouse my opponent just bypassed Burma and Landed in India i had units defending all of bases from Diamond Harbor to Madras but he just used small fragments of Para units and took bases far bechind wich were undefended as i did not have enough units to hold them (i did not send many units from India to Burma)so i decided to take Lunga with 2nd Marines + some Aussie Brigade and support as i knew KB will be covering India. In the Aftermatch he was advancing in India as from his base he was providing Cover with Zeros and send the KB south to Salomons, sunk my fleet and Recaptured Lunga with 2 or 3 Divisions. This games alows totaly Ahistorical outcome's i can't imagine Japane's landing deep bechind enemy lines and then taking away their Carriers to take part in another operation.
That's really, really gamey. In reality, WWII parachute drops produced a lot of casualties and about 99% temporary disruption. Given a few hours or a couple of days, the parachute unit would reform and find its supplies, but meanwhile it was vulnerable to practically everything with weapons and certainly did not have the ability of grabbing the local base facilities.
Figure that your local base force could deploy about a battalion of infantry in an emergency. Unless you hit it with at least a parachute regiment, it was quite capable of taking care of itself for a few days. To take an ungarrisoned airstrip or port you needed about a battalion of parachutists or a company of something more organised to gain and maintain control. The USMC hit Tulagi (with a 900-man base force) with a full regiment of marines. The Japanese used a full battalion to take Sabang (which was ungarrisoned).
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 1:23 pm
by Nikademus
I would only disagree slightly with point 2. I do believe (because i've done it many times) that it is possible and feasible for Japan player to have a taylored Turn 1 without having to compensate the Allied player, and one that doesn't "abuse" the system at all. I've had plenty of starts as Allies as well allowing a custom Turn 1 for Japan where i've issued no orders at all (it's a suprise attack after all)
In the end it all comes down to the type of game you want to play which should be discussed before Turn 1 ever starts. None of my opponents attempt landings at places like Midway or Johnston on Turn 1 because we've agreed that we want a historically flavored game.
Ultimately i find it no less abusive to mobilize the entire Allied machine on Turn 1 than it is to abuse the 'warp' movement of Japan's turn 1.
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 1:25 pm
by DuckofTindalos
Throws an axe at Nik's head, for no reason whatsoever...
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 1:40 pm
by Nikademus
its nice to be appreciated.
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 1:41 pm
by DuckofTindalos
Don't say I never did nothin' for ya...
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 1:42 pm
by goodboyladdie
You'd have thought that reaching 20,000 would have made him rest on his laurels for a bit...
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 1:44 pm
by Sonny II
ORIGINAL: goodboyladdie
You'd have thought that reaching 20,000 would have made him rest on his laurels for a bit...
Hey, there is 30000 for him to shoot for. The sooner he starts the quicker he gets there.[:D]
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 1:45 pm
by DuckofTindalos
-9980...
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 2:11 pm
by qgaliana
Everytime I see this argument, I still can't help feeling there is an immediate desire to yell 'gamey' whenever someone just makes a bad strategic decision. Usually centered around gambling the bulk of their fleet on one pitched battle and losing.
I still don't see why the japanese can't make an all out drive into the south pacific if they choose to commit resources to it - even in january. Shouldn't the onus be on the allied player to come up with a strategy to take advantage of the long lines of communication?
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 2:18 pm
by viberpol
ORIGINAL: Mike Scholl
That was my point. Just as the Allied player owes it to his opponant to contionue even if he is getting his head handed to him in the early going, so the Japanese player owes it to his opponant to maintain the struggle even if he feels the issue has been decided in the end game. It should be up to the player doing well to suggest an early ending by mutual consent in a PBEM game. Otherwise each should consider that he has made a commitment to continue to the end of the game.
You know Mike? Here you are absolutely right.
Somehow, it's a matter of uprightness/honesty.
And also, I begin to think that my next "opponent needed post" shall contain such a sentence:
"opponent needed, AAR necessary" [:D]
Opponents under the public scrutiny, are less prone to quitting [:D]
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 2:20 pm
by viberpol
ORIGINAL: qgaliana
Everytime I see this argument, I still can't help feeling there is an immediate desire to yell 'gamey' whenever someone just makes a bad strategic decision. Usually centered around gambling the bulk of their fleet on one pitched battle and losing.
I still don't see why the japanese can't make an all out drive into the south pacific if they choose to commit resources to it - even in january. Shouldn't the onus be on the allied player to come up with a strategy to take advantage of the long lines of communication?
Absolutely right!
Thanks for backing me up
There are pros and cons of every strategc decision of this kind.
RE: Cherish/value your opponent!
Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2007 2:21 pm
by viberpol
ORIGINAL: Mike Scholl
That was my point. Just as the Allied player owes it to his opponant to contionue even if he is getting his head handed to him in the early going, so the Japanese player owes it to his opponant to maintain the struggle even if he feels the issue has been decided in the end game. It should be up to the player doing well to suggest an early ending by mutual consent in a PBEM game. Otherwise each should consider that he has made a commitment to continue to the end of the game.
You know Mike? Here you are absolutely right.
Somehow, it's a matter of uprightness/honesty.
And also, I begin to think that my next "opponent needed post" shall contain such a sentence:
"opponent needed, AAR necessary" [:D]
Opponents under the public scrutiny, are less prone to quitting [:D]
/sorry, the message has somehow doubled, can I erase one?/