Page 3 of 5

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2020 3:00 am
by Seminole
Turn 13
September 11, 1941

AGN continues to work the left and right wings of the Luga River Line.

Image

STAVKA isn't content with simply absorbing the offensive at this point. Both Fronts are ordered to make attacks and push back the German line of advance. All the attacks succeed, forcing back 3rd Mot Div but more ground is gained in the south, pushing back some infantry regiments trying to hold the swamps south of Novgorod.

Image

Leningrad defenses are arranged in depth to force a grind forward by AGN.

Image

South of Lake Ilmen Reserve Front is pushed back west of the Valdaii Hills. Trying everything we can to keep the enemy off this terrain before the winter takes place. I don't want them to have automatic rough defense bonuses during the Winter Offensive.
East of the Volga river, where it bends north around Rzhev, the Wehrmacht blasts an armored salient 60 miles deep and 30 miles wide.
STAVKA orders the disbandment of the Moskva-Volga Canal fortified zones. Guards rifle divisions will be committed to maintaining the northern flank of the Kremlin Line (fortified zones flanking Moscow) until December.

Image

It's clear that Rzhev must be evacuated as their flank has been turned and they will surely be captured next turn if left in place.
STAVKA orders a series of successful counterattacks along the broad salient facing Moscow:

Image

Germans continue to slowly press against the screen in the Bryansk sector.

Image

STAVKA orders Bryansk Front to not remain idle, and they organize successful counterattacks to regain space south of Kaluga on the axis toward Tula.

Image

AGS liquidates the Poltava pocket and creates a new pocket around forces at Kharkov. The effort to help what would become 3rd Guards Rifle Division has cost us a lot more units. Lesson I already knew re-taught the hard way.

Image

A heavy attack against 13th PD was too weak to break this pocket and make more delay, but we can merge some units inside and put up a defense longer than one week.

Image

Axis Allied armies of AGS continue pushing toward Stalino.

Image

Southern Army organizes a cavalry response to chase Axis Allies, but they then fall back to create a screen instead of a solid line.

Image

Lastly, the Germans continue their push toward Crimea with a single attack.

Image

Overall strategic map at the end of turn 13:

Image

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2020 9:13 am
by BrianG
question

i see forts in all the south ports:

Your thinking is?

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2020 11:07 am
by Seminole
ORIGINAL: BrianG

question

i see forts in all the south ports:

Your thinking is?

http://www.matrixgames.com/forums/fb.asp?m=4896755


RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2020 6:49 pm
by vvs007
thanks again for your interesting game, always looking forward to every update :)

it is interesting to learn more general statistics, pool numbers, etc., how is the air war going, when Stalin's falcons are ready to destroy the Goering chicks? :)

good game!

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Mon Nov 09, 2020 12:57 am
by Seminole
Update on factory moves:

A little panicked on the Moscow moves, which cost us some MiG-3 production, but otherwise going well and staying ahead of the curve.

Image

Soviet losses:

Image

Axis losses:

Image

Two things I'm trying to do in this game that I've generally ignored. Active SU management and active air war. In the past I've generally ignored SUs aside from making sappers, and left the air war to automatic ground support and interdiction.
The Red Air Force was redeployed on turn 5 (July 17, 1941) and aside from ground support has been used to bomb mechanized formations once or twice per turn.
The Luftwaffe is still fighting, their losses above.
I have the event logs and stats files, so I should be able to pull other info if you're interested in something in particular, let me know. Not sure what all I might want to be keeping an eye on with this supply model and my SU plans anyway.

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 5:55 pm
by Seminole
Turn 14

AGN emphasizes attacking from their left wing, but broad attacks south of Lake Ilmen are pushing back Reserve Front.

Image

STAVKA orders NW Front to redeploy 8th Army to back up 30th Army by taking positions along the Pola River.
This necessitates pulling back from the growing salient in the center. We don't want to undo our success here with a few lucky rolls by the German generals.
STAVKA shifts rifle brigades into the frontline fortifications. With the rear lines largely devoted to reserve the Germans may lose a fight or two if they're not overpowering in taking these hexes.
I want next turn to make another consolidation and redeploy some of the most experienced units to reinforce the Moscow defenses.

Image

AGC pushes their NE salient east while the infantry push through the abandoned positions that defended Rzhev.
German attacks falter, and the Germans are stopped 30 miles south of Kalinin in their advance.

Image

STAVKA orders several counter attacks, highlighted below are two on either side of the Kalinin salient.

Image

East of Vyazma the broad advance renews against Kaluga, the enemy only 10 miles from the city.
Bryansk falls this turn.

Image

Kharkov Pocket is holding out.

Image

Farther south the Germans and their allies push toward Stalino. Russian cavalry raid the Rumanians holding the right wing of the advance and free some units from a ZOC lock.
A new screen is set up and we prepare to fall back even further. I don't have unit density down here anymore with the Poltava and Kharkov pockets and the railing of units to Moscow.

Image

Strategic overview at the end of the turn 14

Image

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Mon Nov 30, 2020 11:22 pm
by Seminole
Turn 15

Forgot to move factories!

Was hemming and hawing about whether or not to start evacuating Voronezh and decided to do it later, and then forgot to do it...

Germans continue to grind along the front, finding going particularly tough for AGN these days with Vasilevsky and Zhukov scoring some victories:

Image

Image

AGC also makes slow progress on a broad front. The Luftwaffe sends supplies to the panzers threatening Moscow's northern flank. The Guards rifle divisions are brought in to help defend this flank.
We don't want to allow Moscow to be encircled before the rains. If we can protect it a few more weeks it should be safe for the winter.

Image

The line is incredibly thin between Bryansk and Southwestern Fronts. Without a panzer threat in the area we're still trying to slow the German advance with a screen of infantry.

Image

Kharkov holds out for another week, but we've suffered another small pocket. This one was frustrating because somehow we overlooked 19th Army HQ and they were left on the line to be captured with their SUs. Dumb.

Image

The Germans and their allies are closing in on the Stalino factory complex. Time to fall back again, we just don't have the formation density down here to defend, and attempting to make a stand will just lead to more pockets.

Image

AGS has succeeded in pushing the Red Army into the Crimean peninsula.

Image

After a successful counter attack in the Leningrad sector the line is straightened to free up some additional units to transfer to Moscow's defense. Soft factor is showing supplies.

Image

In the Moscow sector STAVKA orders counterattacks near Kalinin and Kaluga.

Image

OoB:

Image

Losses:

Image

Overall strategic map at the end of turn 15:

Image

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Tue Dec 08, 2020 7:28 pm
by CapAndGown
Where is the German rail head in the Stalino/Kharkov area?

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Tue Dec 08, 2020 8:33 pm
by Seminole
I didn't keep track of it.
I didn't really look at rail again until the blizzard offensive time, and running through the end of turn screenshots I don't see any FBDs picked up by recon. I was usually only scouting close to the lines anyway to pick up mech formations off the line.

Waiting on turn 27 now, probably will wait another turn or two to resume posting so I can discuss prep for the Winter Offensive and maintain opsec.

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Wed Dec 09, 2020 11:01 am
by vvs007
The Red Air Force was redeployed on turn 5 (July 17, 1941) and aside from ground support has been used to bomb mechanized formations once or twice per turn.

interesting strategy ... and what are the results? ... as I understand it, on the plus side, the Germans need to divide fighters into intercepting such bombings and covering their bombers that help in ground battles? and on the negative side - the Soviet ground forces are left without air support, and this could change the results of some battles, and also the low effectiveness of the bombing of German tank columns themselves (a few damaged elements just?)

good game!

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Wed Dec 09, 2020 12:42 pm
by Seminole
ORIGINAL: GDHF
The Red Air Force was redeployed on turn 5 (July 17, 1941) and aside from ground support has been used to bomb mechanized formations once or twice per turn.

interesting strategy ... and what are the results? ... as I understand it, on the plus side, the Germans need to divide fighters into intercepting such bombings and covering their bombers that help in ground battles? and on the negative side - the Soviet ground forces are left without air support, and this could change the results of some battles, and also the low effectiveness of the bombing of German tank columns themselves (a few damaged elements just?)

good game!

Well, I’m getting some Guards airbases, which never happened before because I didn’t regularly attack units, just relied on ground support.

It will definitely get you kills, but one of the things I noticed is that several air attacks in an area will drain enemy unit supplies.
I’m guessing the AAA routines are shifting supplies to ammo.

Another observation, in another game I’m on turn 5, and the Luftwaffe doesn’t seem to be able to fight well in intercept. I’ll post the combat shots in another thread to not clutter this one, but it seemed ‘off’’.

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Wed Dec 09, 2020 2:12 pm
by Shupov
How did you save the great full map screen shot? Which screen capture utility did you use?

Thanks in advance!

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Wed Dec 09, 2020 4:54 pm
by Seminole
I just Print Screen to copy the image, and save it a folder with Irfanview.
I think Win10 has a gaming screen shot key, just haven't bothered to look into it because sometimes I crop what I save in Irfanview and custom name the file for creating the AAR later.

I use Paint.net to stich them together.
For the large map ones I start zoomed each time on a particular lake in Finland, back up the view, and then save the three images by scrolling to the same points each time.

I like Paint.net because of the layer features, and it's free.



Anyone have a preferred gif host anymore? Seems most sites translate them into video formats upon upload (at least beyond a certain size), and I haven't found one that plays nice with this board.


RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Sat Dec 12, 2020 4:56 am
by Hanny
ORIGINAL: CapAndGown

The Germans have airbases right up with the panzers. What is that all about? Won't they be out of supply? How does that effect German air operations? I've seen that in several AARs and I don't understand it. Franky, I'm not sure I understand the air game at all.

Could be that he is leap frogging air bases, by stacking to max on T1, giving him empty air basses to push forward, which he may or may not then transfer into, or just use as staging bases closer to the front but empty of assets.

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2020 7:23 am
by Hanny
ORIGINAL: Seminole

Anyone have a preferred gif host anymore? Seems most sites translate them into video formats upon upload (at least beyond a certain size), and I haven't found one that plays nice with this board.

You could go another way and use OBS to record your turn, with comments, ( edit OBS for the portions you want to comment further on) and re post on you tube.

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2020 11:47 am
by Seminole
You could go another way and use OBS to record your turn, with comments, ( edit OBS for the portions you want to comment further on) and re post on you tube.

I'm afraid I'm a terribly slow player, and with frequent interruptions from a 4 and 7 year old it's even worse.
I've had success in the past saving screenshots, clipping them, and creating a gif, but the video editing would be way more involved.
It just seems that picture hosts have moved on from larger gifs, and these boards don't like to do inline video (unless there is something else I don't know).

e.g.

Image

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2020 12:43 pm
by Seminole
Turn 16

Slow German grind in AGN sector continues, but Leningrad is safe. We've so far preserved Leningrad and tied up 4th Panzer Group for the entire summer offensive. Still trying to thin this area as much as possible by sliding forces south of Lake Ilmen

Image

Cavalry brought in around Vyshny Volochek to help reclaim some of the terrain. Enemy is thin here on the northern flank of the Moscow salient, breaking down to regiments to try and cover the line, and the Red Army takes advantage.

Image

Half a dozen successful counter attacks overall in the Moscow area, pushing back several infantry divisions and the 18th Panzer. Trying to keep pushing back around Kaluga as well.

Image

Image

With the autumn rains on the way, STAVKA begins to plan for a Winter Offensive.
Zhukov is tapped to draw up the details, but the overall theme will be a double pincer from the Kaluga and Vyshny Volochek areas to eliminate the Moscow salient.

Kursk and Orel are falling under threat, but both sides have little committed in this area.

Image

1st Panzer Group has split their mechanized forces, making threats toward Voronezh as well as Rostov.

Image

The Stalino complex is nearly encircled. Bobkin's 37th Army (STAVKA) of Russian cavalry help push back the Grossdeutschland Mot Rgt and isolate Das Reich Mot Div and another Mot Div.

Image

Remaining forces pull back to establish a new cavalry screen, but at least 3 rifle divisions won't be able to escape.
Newly minted Guards cavalry divisions are being shipped out to refit for the Winter Offensive.

Image

Trying to ship in reserves to keep Rostov safe from a snow offensive.
I don't expect much of a threat as he has split his panzer corps (I believe in a bid to gain as much territory as possible before blizzard to setup the '42 offensive).

Overall strategic picture at the end of turn 16:

Image

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2020 2:05 pm
by Seminole
Turn 17

Zhukov begins planning by reviewing the available forces.
16 Guards rifle divisions on the map (3rd Guards RD expected to be replaced 12/25/41), with a further 22 currently qualified for Guards status.
6 Guards cavalry divisions, with a further 3 qualified.
1 Guards Mtn Inf Div, 2 more qualified with 1 only 1 win away.

All of the Soviet cavalry will be split between the north and south pincer.
One Front will be assigned to each pincer, with four Armies and a cavalry corps HQ attached.

This week the German attacks closest to Leningrad fail, but along the line 4 more hexes are captured by the Wehrmacht.

Image
Image

Image

Defensive arrangement at Leningrad sector at the end of the turn:

Image

German attacks continue along the northern flank of the Moscow salient.

Image

The Red Army hits back, regaining some of the territory near Torzhok.

Image

On the southern side of the Moscow salient more forces are brought in west of Tula.

Image

Orel and Kursk find themselves on the front lines as the German infantry continue to push.

Image

We have no intention of losing these manpower centers before winter.

Image

The last of the Kharkov pocket is finally neutralized, and Panzer Group 1 makes a raid toward Voronezh.

Image

The rifle divisions trapped near Stalino are liquidated, and several more attacks by AGS toward Rostov are made.

Image

37th Army and the remainder of the cavalry in the south are put on rails and a new defensive screen is setup.

Image

Finally, at the gates of Crimea the Red Army holds a port on the Sea of Azov against Axis Allies:

Image

Losses:

Image
Image
Image

OoB:

Image

Overall strategic map at the end of turn 17:

Image

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2020 2:19 pm
by Seminole
Turn 18

Time for another re-org of the Red Air Force.
Upgrading ShaP to make sure they're using IL-2s and swapping in Hurricanes to the remaining air battalions. These will be assigned to OSNAZ air base to support the Li-2 air drops.

Zhukov's cavalry are beginning to coalesce in the staging areas.

Image

Overall strategic picture at the end of the turn:

Image

RE: Generalrisky (Axis) vs Seminole (Soviet) - Bitter End

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2020 3:20 pm
by Seminole
Turn 19

AGS makes two small attacks against infantry brigades, but are repulsed. Otherwise a very quiet week.

Recall all air units to reserve to make re-org simpler.
29th and 31st Army units re-assigned to shift Leningrad Front farther south.
Zhukov's 24th Army (NW Front) has it's units re-assigned to Leningrad Front and other NW Front armies so it can be relocated south at the end of the Valdaii Hills, the shoulder of the northern pincer.
NW Front continues to shift south, with 8th and 28th Armies assuming responsibility from Kalinin Front, freeing up 11th and 30th Armies to take over from 13th and 22nd Armies (Western Front) so that we can finally sort out the command delineation.


Overall strategic map at the end of turn 19:

Image