Matrix Games Forums

How did France manage to siege a province they didnt start their movement in (Bosnia)? Sieges are supposed to happen before movement, not after.  My turn 20 shows Grand Armee I starting turn 20 in Illyria.  Is that FOW?  Were they actually in Bosnia already?  Very weird.

That is about the only unexpected thing to happen for me this turn.

Good catch, Mus. Grande Armee I did indeed start the turn in Illyria. According to the in-game appendix under movement sub phases, sieges should occur before movement.

Either: I once again am not comprehending the manual; it's a bug; the garrison was too small/opposing force too large for the garrison to be considered an "opposing" force; or a combination of any of these.

Seems like this situation may have happened before, although I'm not certain.

HiHi

You are right Bill, it happened at Marseilles, 1 Militia on 1.7 moral v's Russian army on " a hell of a lot higher moral [:)]", so probably your guess the garrison was too small/opposing force too large for the garrison to be considered an "opposing" force; has the right of it.

All the Best
Peter

HiHi

Russias T21 orders sent in.

All the Best
Peter

If it isnt a bug the possibility ought to be discussed in the manual or appendix. Thats all. Not a huge deal. I just hadnt ever seen that happen before.

One possibility that struck me was that "Force Marching" might in certain circumstances count as the beginning of a new movement? I dont know, I do wish certain areas of the rules were a bit more fleshed out though.

Swedish turn is almost in!

Sweden T21 is now in.

HiHi

Russias T22 orders sent in.

All the Best
Peter

I need a lawyer.  I want a binding decision on a course of action I will take from a "neutral" judge of our house rules before I send my turn in. [:D]
 
Whose decision will we accept?

I vote for me.  Turkey has least to gain from issues that far North.

Hey Im still in there at -900 Morale, lol.

You or your country ? [8D]

How about if Mus and Matto decide... and if they can't agree together, then... damn... .  I wish I could keep the question confidential.  Hmmmm...

Don't make to much fuss about that single house rule... Many things went ''wrong'' this game (ie everyone loosing 600 glory because of me!). I guess people will have a better feel of the game after this and we will restart once the patch is out!

LOL... yeah.  I will  just play.  And I will appoint Franck as the interpreter of any actions which occur as a result.  Is that okay with everyone?

On house rules, hopefully they will be less necessary next game, but if a disagreement arises this turn it will only provide fodder for discussion in establishing house rules for next game.  So since this game is so messed up in the Glory department I say the more problems arise probably the better

Sweden Turn 22 in.  Surprise!  LOL

This better be good with all the build up.
 
[:D]

Mus, for the Ottoman Empire, it will be but a ripple in a pond.  For Sweden, it will make headlines for two months. 

Hmm.  So how many victory points do all those powers have on you?