Page 39 of 47
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2016 7:30 am
by 1275psi
Blamey stands at the radio tent.
Men hate him. Many men hate him. But they follow him not for any genius in tactics
he might display ( his limitations he knows too well)
No, they hate his arrogance, is rudeness, his ruthless attitude to men who have deemed to
have failed.
But they follow him for his guts.
For his need , determination to fight.
Today, he knows, its all down to guts.
'" Sir, 3rd motor is reporting overwhelming numbers, a divisional size attack"
40 miles to my north........"The armour?"....40, or maybe more to my south
"advancing still sir"
And me in the middle.....who will surround who first???
Guts. This is the moment, who blinks first?
"Sir! message from Esperance!, the town has fallen!"
"Tell 3rd motor they will fight, and if need be, die in place. Tell the armour.....tell them
to put the pedal to the metal!"
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2016 8:40 am
by ny59giants
Kodiak - How are your infantry disruption levels? If you can keep them relatively low, you will be able to hold.
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2016 10:41 pm
by nicwb
No, they hate his arrogance, is rudeness, his ruthless attitude to men who have deemed to
have failed.
Got that one well picked. In RL Blamey was not particularly popular especially after the Koitaki speech to the troops in 1942.
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2016 11:19 pm
by 1275psi
To
Winston
Situation brief, Pacific theatre
India:
Stable situation along northern border of Burma
Our forces have checked all Japanese probes, and the first general probe south towards
Chittagong has commenced.
Air Campaign fluctuates, however overall we retain sufficient control of the air, with
little interference to our ground troops.
Forces are now concentrating in Calcutta area, any Japanese offensive against Western India or
Colombo now considered remote.
Support deployment of 2nd Division to Australia.
Politically this must give us some leverage with Australia, the concept of re borrowing
1st corp in 43 now very viable.
No offensive can be contemplated in India theatre for this year
Australia
The landings at Carnovan have seen our armoured brigade, 1st Corp safely ashore, and
these troops advance south
Landings at Esperance successful, along with 24th American Division, 2 enemy tank
regiments, and 15th army HQ are in full retreat
The road between Esperance and Kalgoorlie has been cut by 2nd motor brigade
Situation east of Kalgoorlie is tense, 4 Japanese divisions verses 3 weakening Australian.
However Japanese troop movements WEST are now observed. The Left undercut attack of our
Armour may unhinge enemy defences.
The Australian 4th division, and Americal continue to slowly move towards the battle
Blamey is being supplied now from coast road.
It appears that SOUTH PAC, is releasing considerable forces, including much armour,
to reinforce this battle. A landing at Freemantle or Albany too could very well succeed.
SOUTH WEST PAC
Battle soon to be joined at Katherine, and PORT Moresby, Horn Island now turning towards offensive
operations
SOUTH PAC
The diversion attack at EFATE has failed.
However SUVA and now Noumea, are considered safe. Further diversion attacks are planned.
Central Pacific.
Remains quiet, with neither side having sufficient forces to do anything
NorthPAC
Allied troops reported on KODIAK to be in "very god shape"
We believe this island will hold, even if the enemy dominate the area with its carriers.
Every day that this battle continues, is another good day for us.
No more turns in in tray........
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2016 11:40 pm
by BBfanboy
ORIGINAL: nicwb
No, they hate his arrogance, is rudeness, his ruthless attitude to men who have deemed to
have failed.
Got that one well picked. In RL Blamey was not particularly popular especially after the Koitaki speech to the troops in 1942.
I think strong-willed people are always unpopular because they remind the rest of us of our weaknesses. Instead of admiration, we give them envy and spite.
But there is no reason a leader cannot be strong-willed and tactful. Ike stands out, MacArthur does not. I know little of Blamey save his grit and determination, but I think he was handed one of the hardest conundrums of any leader in the war. He had no time to be polite and develop relationships - you either got behind him or got out of the way.
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Tue Jun 14, 2016 2:20 am
by nicwb
Hi BBfanboy,
I don't particularly disagree with you.
However, Blamey did cross a line at Koitaki. He was addressing the troops who had just come out of the jungle after the Kokoda Campaign. They had just completed a fighting withdrawal across the New Guinea Highlands. Their actions had markedly contributed to preventing the Japanese taking Port Moresby and had been carried out in dense jungle by militia troops and at a time when the Japanese had been steamroller ini everything in their path.
Blamey basically and rather unforgivably accused them of cowardice in the face of the enemy.
Sorry PSI - not intending to hijack the thread!
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Tue Jun 14, 2016 8:43 am
by 1275psi
June 27th
Its a week since the miscarriage.
We won't even pretend to understand the darkness of the week Margaret has undergone.
A week........a long, long week.
She barely remembers some of it, most of it.
Matron.......well Matron has, regretfully, seen this before.
She attends with all that is needed, with love, with patience. Time, time will be needed.
It might have helped, it might not have.
Its Midday, and somehow.....somehow she finds herself in town.
There are uniforms everywhere, trucks, and from the field, the steady roar of the now ever
present B17's.
There is also dust, noise, a barking dog, and a poster.
Wanted
Nurses
For deployment
A surprised old man, drooping moustache, in even older uniform
A few lies
4 hours later, she finds herself on a DC3, destination Port Moresby.
Will train
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Tue Jun 14, 2016 8:50 am
by 1275psi
The messenger hands the signal to Blamey
"regret to report 3rd motor brigade has been destroyed"
"Destroyed, or surrendered?"
"Destroyed sir"
Blamey merely grunts....."Át least Rowe knows his duty"
He turns back to the map, as if so many men lost truly means so little, other than that
they have delayed the bloody 16th division from going anywhere.
"Our Armour?"
The messenger smiles. "Firmly on the rail line sir, firmly up the Japs arse"
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Tue Jun 14, 2016 9:07 am
by 1275psi
27th June
Kodiak
Its raining. Belting down, again. Cold, bitterly cold rain that gets under the collar,
runs down your neck, freezes your privates.
Your feet are numb, your fingers struggle to work.
The metal of the gun is even colder, at least it does not freeze to your fingers, yet.
That usually happens later in the night though.
About you, men shiver. You shiver.
But the cave/ pillbox you are in, protects you from the gale outside.
The bloody nips down there in the beach head will be feeling every breath of it.
Good.
The gun is cold, ammo is being saved today against the troops, bigger game is afoot.
"There the %$#^&ers are"
Out of the grey curtain of the rain, shadows, grey shadows on the water.
Jap ships.
The darkness is almost complete.
Almost.
About you only poor Peter, glasses fogged to hell can't see em.
"range, 5000!"
You are but one gun. But of 2 marine defence units, of several coastal battery units.
Of quite a few other artillery units.
"Give em hell"
2 cruisers, multiple destroyers. The will try to reply.
And just give themselves away.
3 destroyers won't be back in a long time. Both cruisers vanish, burning.
The gun falls silent, steaming
Sweating, you collapse.
The wind howls, the rain pelts down, freezing. If the Japs want to reinforce that way, they are
going to need a heck of a lot more ships.
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Tue Jun 14, 2016 9:12 am
by 1275psi
At dawn the Japs send another 160 kates, they finish of 4 hulks around the bay.
The defences remain untouched.
In the solomons, a lone CVE, maybe Hiyo and her friends attacks Louisville near
Milne bay.
A destroyer is damaged.
B17's strike Madang, 18strong.
Nells strike Port Moresby......well, the Japs sent them to that.
None return.
But a bad day on the Burma front
32 Hurricanes lost for 25 Oscars and zeros combined downed.
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Tue Jun 14, 2016 9:24 am
by 1275psi
"Prime Minister?"
Frank looks about the room. Yes, all her stuff is gone. Strange, how only 3 months ago
the thought of divorce , of separation at least, could have been so daunting.
In the shadow of the war, of so much stress, such a little thing now."
"Yes?"
"Än interesting tid bit sir, The Japanese Prime Minister made a speech today"
"Öh yes?"
"A line sir, to quote......we will hold every inch we have taken....now for the great
test, to stand at this high point, and let the enemy dash himself to pieces upon us"
Frank thinks........
"Do you think they are admitting that the high tide level has been reached sir?"
"Sounds a bit like it, doesn't it?"
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Wed Jun 15, 2016 8:24 am
by 1275psi
Have to step out of story for the moment
Have read Johns comments about too many games.
last night I welcomed him back, commented on how I actually like playing defence
as japan, and asked, can he make it to may 45
his answer:
definitely not.
Its only end of June. And I think its dawning on him that 'fun times'running
around smashing things is coming to a end
So I am a bit worried. I do hope he continues...........
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Wed Jun 15, 2016 8:37 am
by 1275psi
28 June
Jack awakens with a start.
"Do you hear that?"
"Uh?"......disorientation.....its dark, and the trench, as usual still stinks of
sweat, excrement, oil, blood.
"Do you hear that?"
Jack is instantly awake, and up, crouching, peering cautiously into the dark towards the Japanese lines.
An attack???
The desert lies quiet under the moon
"Hear what, you bloody idiot"
"That's the point........you can't hear anything"
From
General Blamey
to
Australian command
My armoured brigades now stand firmly on rail line 80 miles due east Kalgoorlie
Enemy divisions opposite my army, retiring WEST.
Have ordered my armour to stab at Kalgoorlie, and to seize, if possible his supply dumps.
Advance Australia fair.
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Wed Jun 15, 2016 8:39 am
by Long pig
I hope he lasts for a while as I am really enjoying this AAR. Well done to you again sir for your description of combat in the air and the ground and not least at sea 👍
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Wed Jun 15, 2016 8:39 am
by 1275psi
From
Port Moresby
to
SW Pac command
Para drop Salamaua successful
Wau appears un occupied
Will seize it tomorrow.
end
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Wed Jun 15, 2016 8:51 am
by 1275psi
Cruisers Dortcheshire, Hobart, Achilles, the N class destroyers steam steadily south from
Carnovan.
There was fuel a plenty there, held in a score of transports holds.
Ammunition, there was none to be had.
Thus, a return to Adelaide.
Some bright spark, thinks John, has decided to totally empty the ammo against Perth.
But, as the sun rises, its apparent something has changed.
Geraldon field has grown large enough to take, field Vals.
Too many of the buggars
Again, the hard hat.
Again, the craning head, twisting shoulders, peering into the sun, the screaming fans, the rushing
waters, the crack of the guns.
The diving eagles, the whistles, the crumps, the crumps of the misses, the towering water spouts
Shrapnel hisses across Napiers bridge, hisses, whizzes, bangs, clatters.
A cry of pain behind John, a man, a friend, a companion collapsing
More crumps, then, horribly, the bangs, thumps, as bombs strike home.
All three cruisers are struck, struck hard.
Carnovan offers little, it will have to do. Shocked, humiliated, the task force turns
to the North.
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Wed Jun 15, 2016 8:58 am
by 1275psi
The Japanese have wildly flung his Tank units all over the aussie desert.
2, or 3 we have now smashed.
Another, the 8th tank regiment, is discovered today.
Its on the coast road, a long, long way from anywhere.
Yesterday, 4th division bumped into it, a unit of some sort.
Today, today 4 more cruisers ( oh, yes, we have just about EVERYTHING in these waters now)
pound it.
30 tanks destroyed.
4th division is going to squash it like a bug.
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Wed Jun 15, 2016 9:01 am
by 1275psi
Enemy CVL task group near Milne bay launches a very long range strike at Port Moresby
3 AK lost
a DD hit
PM Bristles with LBA.
I don't think he will come much closer
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Wed Jun 15, 2016 11:26 am
by Andav
I really hope he continues so we can continue to enjoy this AAR. It really is fantastic.
Is it 1942 or 1943? Either way, at this point, saying there is no way you will make it to May 45 would be very disappointing to me.
Wa
RE: Letters from a Prime Minister
Posted: Wed Jun 15, 2016 11:33 am
by Canoerebel
ORIGINAL: 1275psi
Have to step out of story for the moment
Have read Johns comments about too many games.
last night I welcomed him back, commented on how I actually like playing defence
as japan, and asked, can he make it to may 45
his answer:
definitely not.
Its only end of June. And I think its dawning on him that 'fun times'running
around smashing things is coming to a end
So I am a bit worried. I do hope he continues...........
Herbie, years ago I played John in a WitP match that last into late 1944. At that point we mutually called it quits (on the erroneous assumption that the "game was over," not realizing that Japan can still fight hard). But John went deep into that game.
I think John will fight far into your game unless he loses his full navy. He's a navy guy, and if he loses a high percentage of his ships I would guess that he might raise the white flag. Exactly when he would reach that point is anybody's guess, but usually it wouldn't be earlier than well into 1944.