Page 1 of 5

Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 12:43 pm
by viberpol
Stolen from Fletcher's AAR here tm.asp?m=1281902
ORIGINAL: Miller

No CAP over his carriers???
Has to be the earliest IJN surrender in WITP history........

Good question. Just exclude the players that quit :(

Recently I started a game when my Allied opponent surrendered on 8th of January '42.
We had the following clash near Noumea.

AFTER ACTION REPORTS FOR 01/07/42
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Night Time Surface Combat, near Noumea at 66,117

Japanese Ships
BB Hiei, Shell hits 1
BB Kirishima, Shell hits 2
BB Mutsu, Shell hits 1
CA Tone, Shell hits 10
CA Chikuma
DD Mutsuki
DD Kisaragi

Allied Ships
DD HMS Express, Shell hits 5, Torpedo hits 1, and is sunk
DD HMS Isis, Shell hits 80, Torpedo hits 2, and is sunk

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Night Time Surface Combat, near Noumea at 66,117


Allied aircraft
no flights


Allied aircraft losses
SOC-3 Seagull: 2 destroyed

Japanese Ships
BB Hiei, Shell hits 1
BB Kirishima, Shell hits 2
BB Mutsu, Shell hits 3
CA Tone
CA Chikuma, Shell hits 2
DD Mutsuki, Shell hits 1
DD Kisaragi

Allied Ships
CV USS Lexington
CA USS Chester, Shell hits 2
CA USS Chicago, Shell hits 12, and is sunk
CA USS Astoria, Shell hits 3
DD USS Shaw, Shell hits 1, on fire
DD USS Reid
DD USS Fanning
DD FNS Le Triomphant, Shell hits 1
DD FNS Le Fortune

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Night Time Surface Combat, near Noumea at 66,117

Japanese Ships
BB Hiei
BB Kirishima
BB Mutsu, Shell hits 2, Torpedo hits 1, on fire
CA Tone
CA Chikuma
DD Mutsuki, Shell hits 2
DD Kisaragi, Shell hits 2

Allied Ships
CA USS Indianapolis, Shell hits 6, on fire, heavy damage
CA USS Northampton, Shell hits 3
DD USS McCall, Shell hits 2
DD USS Benham, Shell hits 1
DD USS Ellet
DD USS Mahan, Shell hits 1
DD USS Drayton

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Night Time Surface Combat, near Noumea at 66,117


Allied aircraft
no flights


Allied aircraft losses
C.XI-W: 1 destroyed

Japanese Ships
BB Ise, Shell hits 10
BB Hyuga
BB Fuso
BB Yamashiro, Shell hits 4
DD Ikazuchi, Shell hits 4, on fire
DD Inazuma
DD Sawakaze
DD Yukaze
BC Fuji, Shell hits 1

Allied Ships
CV USS Enterprise
CA USS Pensacola, Shell hits 1
CA USS Salt Lake Cit, Shell hits 15, on fire, heavy damage
CL RNS Java, Shell hits 8, and is sunk
DD USS Bagley, Shell hits 1
DD USS Helm, Shell hits 12, Torpedo hits 1, and is sunk
DD USS Mugford
DD USS Ralph Talbot, Shell hits 1, on fire
DD USS Henley, Shell hits 4, on fire, heavy damage
DD USS Craven
DD USS Gridley, Shell hits 1, on fire

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Night Time Surface Combat, near Noumea at 66,117

Japanese Ships
BB Ise
BB Hyuga, Shell hits 1
BB Fuso
BB Yamashiro
DD Ikazuchi, on fire
DD Inazuma
DD Sawakaze, Shell hits 1
DD Yukaze
BC Fuji

Allied Ships
CA USS Indianapolis, on fire, heavy damage
CA USS Northampton, Shell hits 1
DD USS McCall, Shell hits 1, on fire
DD USS Benham, Shell hits 2
DD USS Ellet
DD USS Mahan, Shell hits 3, on fire
DD USS Drayton

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day Air attack on TF at 65,118

Japanese aircraft
A5M4 Claude x 10
A6M2 Zero x 98

Allied aircraft
F2A-2 Buffalo x 9
F4F-3 Wildcat x 12
SBD Dauntless x 55
TBD Devastator x 21

Japanese aircraft losses
A5M4 Claude: 2 destroyed
A6M2 Zero: 8 destroyed, 3 damaged

Allied aircraft losses
F2A-2 Buffalo: 9 destroyed
F4F-3 Wildcat: 12 destroyed
SBD Dauntless: 43 destroyed
TBD Devastator: 17 destroyed

Japanese Ships
CV Kaga
CV Akagi

Aircraft Attacking:
3 x SBD Dauntless bombing at 2000 feet
2 x TBD Devastator launching torpedoes at 200 feet

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day Air attack on TF at 66,118

Japanese aircraft
A5M4 Claude x 3
A6M2 Zero x 32
D3A2 Val x 24
B5N2 Kate x 20

Allied aircraft
F2A-2 Buffalo x 5
F4F-3 Wildcat x 7

Japanese aircraft losses
A6M2 Zero: 1 destroyed, 1 damaged
D3A2 Val: 14 damaged
B5N2 Kate: 2 destroyed, 10 damaged

Allied aircraft losses
F2A-2 Buffalo: 1 destroyed, 1 damaged
F4F-3 Wildcat: 3 destroyed, 1 damaged

Allied Ships
CV USS Lexington, Bomb hits 9, Torpedo hits 4, on fire, heavy damage

Aircraft Attacking:
6 x D3A2 Val bombing at 2000 feet
3 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
9 x D3A2 Val bombing at 2000 feet
9 x D3A2 Val bombing at 2000 feet
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
3 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day Air attack on TF at 66,118

Japanese aircraft
B5N2 Kate x 28

Allied aircraft
F2A-2 Buffalo x 2
F4F-3 Wildcat x 4

Japanese aircraft losses
B5N2 Kate: 1 destroyed, 14 damaged


Allied Ships
CV USS Lexington, Torpedo hits 2, on fire, heavy damage

Aircraft Attacking:
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
3 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day Air attack on TF at 66,118

Japanese aircraft
A5M4 Claude x 2
A6M2 Zero x 9
D3A2 Val x 32
B5N2 Kate x 45

Allied aircraft
F4F-3 Wildcat x 2

Japanese aircraft losses
D3A2 Val: 2 damaged
B5N2 Kate: 4 destroyed, 16 damaged


Allied Ships
CV USS Enterprise, Bomb hits 17, Torpedo hits 8, on fire, heavy damage
DD USS Craven

Aircraft Attacking:
2 x D3A2 Val bombing at 2000 feet
3 x D3A2 Val bombing at 2000 feet
1 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
3 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
2 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
9 x D3A2 Val bombing at 2000 feet
9 x D3A2 Val bombing at 2000 feet
9 x D3A2 Val bombing at 2000 feet
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
3 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet
4 x B5N2 Kate launching torpedoes at 200 feet

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sub attack near Noumea at 66,117

Japanese Ships
SS RO-64

Allied Ships
CA USS Indianapolis, Torpedo hits 1, on fire, heavy damage
DD USS Ellet
CA USS Northampton
DD USS Mahan, on fire
DD USS Benham
DD USS McCall
DD USS Drayton

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day Time Surface Combat, near Noumea at 66,117


Allied aircraft
no flights


Allied aircraft losses
SOC-3 Seagull: 4 destroyed

Japanese Ships
BB Ise, Shell hits 1
BB Hyuga, Shell hits 2
BB Fuso, Shell hits 2
BB Yamashiro, Shell hits 4
DD Inazuma
DD Sawakaze, Shell hits 3, on fire
DD Yukaze, Shell hits 2
BC Fuji, Shell hits 1

Allied Ships
CA USS Indianapolis, Shell hits 9, and is sunk
CA USS Northampton, Shell hits 23, and is sunk
DD USS McCall, Shell hits 21, and is sunk
DD USS Benham, Shell hits 5, and is sunk
DD USS Ellet, Shell hits 19, and is sunk
DD USS Mahan, Shell hits 11, Torpedo hits 1, and is sunk
DD USS Drayton, Shell hits 11, and is sunk

edit/ marvelous pounding ;)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Coastal Guns at Noumea, 66,117, firing at TF 118
TF 118 troops unloading over beach at Noumea, 66,117


172 Coastal gun shots fired in defense.
Japanese Ships
PC Shonon Maru #11, Shell hits 12

Japanese ground losses:
925 casualties reported


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ground combat at Manila

Japanese Shock attack

Attacking force 73533 troops, 851 guns, 797 vehicles, Assault Value = 1486

Defending force 19320 troops, 189 guns, 35 vehicles, Assault Value = 679

Japanese max assault: 2808 - adjusted assault: 1560

Allied max defense: 678 - adjusted defense: 981

Japanese assault odds: 1 to 1 (fort level 2)

Japanese Assault reduces fortifications to 1


Japanese ground losses:
1730 casualties reported
Guns lost 43
Vehicles lost 4

Allied ground losses:
127 casualties reported
Guns lost 8

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ground combat at Mersing

Japanese Shock attack

Attacking force 16443 troops, 233 guns, 15 vehicles, Assault Value = 583

Defending force 5055 troops, 54 guns, 62 vehicles, Assault Value = 121

Japanese max assault: 1234 - adjusted assault: 755

Allied max defense: 73 - adjusted defense: 85

Japanese assault odds: 8 to 1 (fort level 3)

Japanese forces CAPTURE Mersing base !!!


Japanese ground losses:
280 casualties reported
Guns lost 11

Allied ground losses:
450 casualties reported
Guns lost 8
Vehicles lost 1


Defeated Allied Units Retreating!

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ground combat at Bataan

Japanese Bombardment attack

Attacking force 1328 troops, 44 guns, 40 vehicles, Assault Value = 938

Defending force 49249 troops, 739 guns, 410 vehicles, Assault Value = 1222



Allied ground losses:
11 casualties reported


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ground combat at Kuala Lumpur

Japanese Deliberate attack

Attacking force 48582 troops, 553 guns, 837 vehicles, Assault Value = 2233

Defending force 4853 troops, 10 guns, 155 vehicles, Assault Value = 10

Japanese max assault: 1142 - adjusted assault: 1688

Allied max defense: 8 - adjusted defense: 19

Japanese assault odds: 88 to 1 (fort level 3)

Japanese forces CAPTURE Kuala Lumpur base !!!


Japanese ground losses:
46 casualties reported
Guns lost 3

Allied ground losses:
663 casualties reported
Guns lost 3
Vehicles lost 19

Defeated Allied Units Retreating!

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ground combat at Koumac

Allied Bombardment attack

Attacking force 2987 troops, 34 guns, 50 vehicles, Assault Value = 130

Defending force 1300 troops, 25 guns, 2 vehicles, Assault Value = 62


Japanese ground losses:
10 casualties reported
Guns lost 1

Allied ground losses:
3 casualties reported
Guns lost 1


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ground combat at Noumea

Allied Bombardment attack

Attacking force 4278 troops, 71 guns, 3 vehicles, Assault Value = 223

Defending force 8892 troops, 83 guns, 2 vehicles, Assault Value = 315


Japanese ground losses:
21 casualties reported
Guns lost 1


My opponent quit saying this is ahistorical to attack Noumea and Luganville as soon as in January '42.
It touched me :(
Sure, I say, it didn't happen IRL, but this is a game -- how many of you conquer Canton Is. or Luganville in first 3-5 weeks?
I would say -- many!
And this is normal as these places are crucial, but Japan has no enough power to get two of them in the early game.
And I do not find it gamey -- because it is not using the quirks and mechanics of the game for evil purposes.
Because this is a GAME!

It is more frustrating because it was a mod -- a mod is to be "MODification" of a game.
He lost 3 CVs (Sara sunk the day before), 3 BB's at PH and a couple of CAs during this clash..
But what to expect if you fight against powerful TFs composed of 3+5 BBs?
Would you expect you could win the KB if you lost a CV sunk the day before and CV ratio is like 8:2 (my 6CVs in KB + 2 as escort against 2 Allied CV's)?

BTW: this is a good example of catching ATF in surface combat at night.

My long post is to show you my frustration and to warn..
I hate quitters.. If I hear "this is ahistorical" I usually say -- go and read some books if you want IRL.
And cherish your opponent -- a good opponent is a crock of a gold at the end of the rainbow ;)

Enjoy your play!

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 12:52 pm
by Knavey
Sounds like you guys never negotiated the type of game you wanted to play before you started.  Some players look for something along the more historical line of play, others prefer a lunacy style which it seems you prefer.  Which play style do you prefer is probably the first question that should be asked of any opponent before setting down the house rules.

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 12:57 pm
by Feinder
This is why it's important to have a dialog with your opponent before the game begins.  To match experience levels and exepecations.
 
While it is regrettable that your opponent has retired, it was probably his first PBEM, coming off the AI.  In WitP, among many other discrepencies, the pace of things is much faster than history.  It -IS- frustrating to expect a historical game your first time at bat (which is exactly what the AI provides), only to find that many things in PBEM are "very different" to say the least.
 
You'd be better serverd to offer your opponent a restart.  It's not like you've revealed some clever new strategy (as you said, which Japanese opponenet DOESN'T try to take Canton/Noumea etc).  Next time, your opponent will consider it a possability, and will make more informed judgments over what his realistic capabilitys are (within the framework of WitP, just toss historical reality out the window, or you will get killed).
 
-F-

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 1:13 pm
by viberpol
Frankly speaking it WAS NOT his first game.
We played before, but as it was a mod, the first game happened to be flawed by editor's mistakes. He also played different PBEM's (and still plays it I think).

So: he knew my style of play.
And: he knows the difference between Ai vs PBEM.

What is more, we negotiated all the house rules before.
The rules concerning this situation were: "opposed landings only within normal range of available 2e bombers or a CV TF with at least two squadrons of bombers/torpedo bombers, affecting both sides"

So: we set the house rule and the landing was is accordance to it.
Even though.. :(

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 1:53 pm
by Ron Saueracker
Ever wonder that perhaps the fact that your BBs, due to the brutally abstract movement and air phases, managed to "outrange" the aircraft of the opposing CV TFs and engage before airstrikes may have added to player frustration? Same with minor tactical range/endurance differences, coupled with the air model, basically render the shorter range Allied naval carrier aircraft mere shipboard targets if the Japnese end up at extended range, in the sweet spot just beyond Allied max range? This happens quite alot, with the Allied CVs basically fending off incoming hordes and not launching...something that never happenned and would never happen IRL.

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 2:11 pm
by viberpol
Well, I do not think so..

The surface engagement with Air TFs happened at night.
This is because he made a tremendous mistake.

The day before we had CV vs CV engagement.
The results were quite "normal" & to be expected.
He lost USS Saratoga, I had my escorting CV's damaged:

AFTER ACTION REPORTS FOR 01/06/42 /notice: earlier/
-----------------------------------------
Day Air attack on TF at 63,119

Japanese aircraft
A5M4 Claude x 13
A6M2 Zero x 134

Allied aircraft
F4F-3 Wildcat x 19
SBD Dauntless x 34
TBD Devastator x 15

Japanese aircraft losses
A5M4 Claude: 3 destroyed
A6M2 Zero: 5 destroyed

Allied aircraft losses
F4F-3 Wildcat: 19 destroyed
SBD Dauntless: 24 destroyed
TBD Devastator: 15 destroyed

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day Air attack on TF at 63,119

Japanese aircraft
A6M2 Zero x 81

Allied aircraft
D.520 x 15
A-24 Dauntless x 14
B-25C Mitchell x 4
P-38F Lightning x 30

Japanese aircraft losses
A6M2 Zero: 13 destroyed, 2 damaged

Allied aircraft losses
D.520: 5 destroyed, 1 damaged
A-24 Dauntless: 4 destroyed, 6 damaged
B-25C Mitchell: 1 destroyed
P-38F Lightning: 9 destroyed, 11 damaged

Japanese Ships
CS Chiyoda, Shell hits 16
CVE Taiyo, Shell hits 8
CVE Hosho, Shell hits 8
CVL Zuiho, Bomb hits 3, on fire

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day Air attack on TF at 64,121

Japanese aircraft
A5M4 Claude x 4
A6M2 Zero x 30
D3A2 Val x 107
B5N2 Kate x 152

Allied aircraft
F4F-3 Wildcat x 8

Japanese aircraft losses
A6M2 Zero: 2 destroyed
D3A2 Val: 2 destroyed, 6 damaged
B5N2 Kate: 6 destroyed, 19 damaged

Allied aircraft losses
F4F-3 Wildcat: 3 destroyed, 2 damaged

Allied Ships
CV USS Saratoga, Bomb hits 19, Torpedo hits 5, on fire, heavy damage
DD USS Ellet
CA USS Northampton
CA USS Indianapolis
CA USS Portland, Bomb hits 1, Torpedo hits 1
----------------------------------------------------

The evening phase brought nothing extra to the scene as my KB was ignored because of bad weather and with 2 CVs he hit my landing tranports instead.

But here he gave VERY VERY bad orders.
He withdrew all TFs to Noumea INSTEAD of trying to break the engagement with KB and blunt the KB airpower by LBA...
Did he expect he would be safe there??
That wasn't too clever.

No wonder I ordered my supporting heavy BBs to end the turn at Noumea..
They used all ammunition to hit the screening CA'a (no hit at single CV during night combat).

My BBs just probed the allied CAs at night, bombarded Noumea (I didn't attach this because it was of low importance), stayed there, have not been attacked by low morale air, and crushed the CAs in the daylight.
In the meantime the running away CVs were attacked by reacting KB (in range: we attacked each other at the range of 2 hexes) and.. here the game is over..

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 2:33 pm
by pauk

well, i do not understand your opponent... he would have carriers sunk back as Essexs in the middle 43, right?

Anyway, he noticed you and resign (admit he is defeated), so i can not see a big problem here. My advice to you is when you looking for a opponent demand game without quiting, but that leads us to another question - are you ready to play a game if you loose KB in, lets say middle '42?

So the bottom line he is defeated and you may cheer[;)]

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 2:37 pm
by USSAmerica
Before starting any PBEM, I think discussion needs to take place, not only for what house rules to use, but also the style of game.  I've just started my first PBEM, and the discussions were simple, "It's a game, not a history book.  For house rules, less is more.  Let's have fun."  I don't think either of us will intentionally exploit outrageous bugs in the game, but if it does happen, I'll just have to consider it part of the game.  My opponent is in full agreement with me on this approach to the game, and we are going to have fun.  [:)]
 
Talk things over with your opponent, set the expectations, then you can both enjoy the carnage.[8D]

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 2:37 pm
by viberpol
ORIGINAL: Ron Saueracker
if the Japnese end up at extended range, in the sweet spot just beyond Allied max range? This happens quite alot, with the Allied CVs basically fending off incoming hordes and not launching...something that never happenned and would never happen IRL.

Ron, what are you talking about???

It "never happened"?
I just give you a single example: 19th June '44.
Ozawa managed to stay hidden and out of range while hitting the Allied TG 58 with several waves.
Apart from the fact this was a slaughter, it did happen IRL.

The longer range IS real.



RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 4:41 pm
by ctangus
ORIGINAL: viberpol

If I hear "this is ahistorical" I usually say -- go and read some books if you want IRL.

The Japanese never sank 9 allied BBs in real life, like you have in our game, so you shouldn't try to sink any more of my battleships. And you're only allowed to sink one more CV. Otherwise it would be ahistorical. [:D]

Looks to me like you simply out-played your other opponent - you are damn dangerous at surface combat. I'm with pauk - take it as a victory! [:)]

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 4:51 pm
by viberpol
ORIGINAL: pauk
So the bottom line he is defeated and you may cheer[;)]

That was my second thought... "Damn... What the f**??? Am I good or what?" [:D]
BTW: Chuck -- this is to celebrate such opponents as you are! [&o][&o]

Solid, cold-blooded, patient.. and most of all -- letting me to sink all these BBs with no hard feelings [:D]

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 5:13 pm
by Przemcio231
My opponent quit saying this is ahistorical to attack Noumea and Luganville as soon as in January '42.
It touched me :(
Sure, I say, it didn't happen IRL, but this is a game -- how many of you conquer Canton Is. or Luganville in first 3-5 weeks?
I would say -- many!
And this is normal as these places are crucial, but Japan has no enough power to get two of them in the early game.
And I do not find it gamey -- because it is not using the quirks and mechanics of the game for evil purposes.
Because this is a GAME!
 
 
Well if let's see your opponent lands in India in February and just overruns it... or the same for Australia or PH or let's say happyly loiters around Pearl Sinking everything in Port then something is wrong with him... and Becouse this is a game the other side to have to get some joy out of it. And what you Are saying about Lugganvile and Canton is some kind of BS... its easy to capture both in January as well as New Caledonia and Etafe with them. Just loiter around Pearl for some time till those Allied CV's run out of Fuel then sail to Canton to support the Invasion and after that just sail further south... no way Allies can Reinforce those places before middle of January and they will only be able to do it if the KB will be far away...

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 5:15 pm
by ctangus
Ah, real men don't need battleships. [:'(]

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 5:19 pm
by denisonh
Once again I think discussion with your opponent is key, so there is a baseline of understanding of what to expect.

On the other hand, an Allied player challenging the KB with 2 CVs on Jan 8 1942 around Noumea is a bit foolish IMO, not to mention leaving CVs in a hex too long and getting engaged by a surface TF is foolish as well.

ORIGINAL: Przemcio231
My opponent quit saying this is ahistorical to attack Noumea and Luganville as soon as in January '42.
It touched me :(
Sure, I say, it didn't happen IRL, but this is a game -- how many of you conquer Canton Is. or Luganville in first 3-5 weeks?
I would say -- many!
And this is normal as these places are crucial, but Japan has no enough power to get two of them in the early game.
And I do not find it gamey -- because it is not using the quirks and mechanics of the game for evil purposes.
Because this is a GAME!


Well if let's see your opponent lands in India in February and just overruns it... or the same for Australia or PH or let's say happyly loiters around Pearl Sinking everything in Port then something is wrong with him... and Becouse this is a game the other side to have to get some joy out of it. And what you Are saying about Lugganvile and Canton is some kind of BS... its easy to capture both in January as well as New Caledonia and Etafe with them. Just loiter around Pearl for some time till those Allied CV's run out of Fuel then sail to Canton to support the Invasion and after that just sail further south... no way Allies can Reinforce those places before middle of January and they will only be able to do it if the KB will be far away...

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 5:29 pm
by viberpol
ORIGINAL: Przemcio231
Just loiter around Pearl for some time till those Allied CV's run out of Fuel then sail to Canton to support the Invasion and after that just sail further south... no way Allies can Reinforce those places before middle of January and they will only be able to do it if the KB will be far away...

I am not keen on such unfair CV hunting as you mentioned.
The other rule of a thumb we used "no CV hunting soon after the PH attack".
And I think it's fair.

Przemek, KB cannot be everywhere.
If I invade Canton, then I have not enough power to get the Noumea.
(if it would be properly defended)
Ok with Luganville, you're right because it is mainly undefended.
And there is time and patience of Allies to get Canton back soon..

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 5:40 pm
by castor troy
ORIGINAL: viberpol

ORIGINAL: Przemcio231
Just loiter around Pearl for some time till those Allied CV's run out of Fuel then sail to Canton to support the Invasion and after that just sail further south... no way Allies can Reinforce those places before middle of January and they will only be able to do it if the KB will be far away...

I am not keen on such unfair CV hunting as you mentioned.
The other rule of a thumb we used "no CV hunting soon after the PH attack".
And I think it's fair.

Przemek, KB cannot be everywhere.
If I invade Canton, then I have not enough power to get the Noumea.
(if it would be properly defended)
Ok with Luganville, you're right because it is mainly undefended.
And there is time and patience of Allies to get Canton back soon..


hmm, how do you think Noumea OR Canton would be properly defended two or three weeks after the war started? From Noumea to Johnston Island there are perhaps 250 av all together!

While it wasn´t really smart to attack KB I can also understand your opponent when finding it strange also. [8|] In the game you can bypass thousands of miles to invade some places deep in the southern Pacific. Take every island there and after two months you begin to attack the SRA. That´s not possible in real life but it´s the best way in the game... [8|]

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 6:11 pm
by herwin
Definitely ahistorical and not logistically supportable. The closest fleet base was Truk, and that was 2000 miles away. No land-based air cover. The invasion fleet would have taken several weeks to load and get there. Exactly zero chance of surprise. It wasn't until Rabaul was taken and some airbases established in the Solomons that Suva and Noumea were vulnerable to anything more than a random raid.

Of course, I'm speaking as a naval analyst, not a gamer.

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 6:13 pm
by viberpol
ORIGINAL: castor troy

hmm, how do you think Noumea OR Canton would be properly defended two or three weeks after the war started? From Noumea to Johnston Island there are perhaps 250 av all together!

While it wasn´t really smart to attack KB I can also understand your opponent when finding it strange also. [8|] In the game you can bypass thousands of miles to invade some places deep in the southern Pacific. Take every island there and after two months you begin to attack the SRA. That´s not possible in real life but it´s the best way in the game... [8|]

Castor, the funny thing is I did not conquer Noumea.
I don't think I would, eventually.

I had 4 JAP Divisions engaged at Manila, rest of my assault was on Malaya -- heading Singapore... as "proper" as it should be ;)
All INF reinforcements I got landed at Mersing to cut out the withdrawing Allies.
How on earth could I get AND HOLD Noumea attacked with a single (52nd.. I think.. with changed HQ from HIsland HQ) division and several Japanese marine NLFs?
AND this was mod! My opponent had several French units and IND divisions trasfered to Malaya, Lightnings adn Davointine D520 from the early game.. etc.
ORIGINAL: herwin

Definitely ahistorical and not logistically supportable. The closest fleet base was Truk, and that was 2000 miles away. No land-based air cover. The invasion fleet would have taken several weeks to load and get there. Exactly zero chance of surprise. It wasn't until Rabaul was taken and some airbases established in the Solomons that Suva and Noumea were vulnerable to anything more than a random raid.
Of course, I'm speaking as a naval analyst, not a gamer.


And herwin, I invaded Luganville and Etafe the week before -- having even the air CAP over my transports.
And it was a surprise -- how can I explain Lightnigs strafing my CV's?
He didn' expect KB to be there? Underestimate the power of my surface TFs and morale of my night trained crew? [:D] And last, but not least, gave the wrong orders.. [;)]

Ok, but this thread is not on assesing the strategy, but to point out how important is a solid opponent :)

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 6:15 pm
by herwin
ORIGINAL: viberpol

ORIGINAL: Przemcio231
Just loiter around Pearl for some time till those Allied CV's run out of Fuel then sail to Canton to support the Invasion and after that just sail further south... no way Allies can Reinforce those places before middle of January and they will only be able to do it if the KB will be far away...

I am not keen on such unfair CV hunting as you mentioned.
The other rule of a thumb we used "no CV hunting soon after the PH attack".
And I think it's fair.

Przemek, KB cannot be everywhere.
If I invade Canton, then I have not enough power to get the Noumea.
(if it would be properly defended)
Ok with Luganville, you're right because it is mainly undefended.
And there is time and patience of Allies to get Canton back soon..

In reality, the KB didn't have the fuel reserves to go carrier hunting after Pearl. In fact, Pearl was beyond the operational radius of the KB--read about how they pulled out all the stops to put the KB in strike range of Pearl. That was why Kimmel was surprised.

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 6:21 pm
by viberpol
ORIGINAL: ctangus

Ah, real men don't need battleships. [:'(]

Ah, real manno doesn't need B(ig)B(all)s? [:D][;)]