Page 1 of 1

Supply Query

Posted: Sun Jul 08, 2007 6:09 am
by lancer
Goodaye,

I'm enjoying reading your Barbarossa AAR. I'm intrigued by how the suppy system works. I've read the People Tactics manual and so I have a rough idea but a little more explanation would be appreciated.

Specifically how it works and how big an impact it makes on the game? Is it a major consideration in your decision making or just a bells and whistle aside?

Cheers,
Lancer

RE: Supply Query

Posted: Sun Jul 08, 2007 7:24 am
by seille
Supply system is very complex.
 
The supply produced in cities flows into the attached HQ´s. From there it flows to
the sub HQ´s and from there to the units.
Many factors can have a impact here !
HQ or unit is not in perfect supply range or out of range
-> HQ or unit get less or no supply
 
Supply was destroyed by Anti supply on their way (navy or air of the enemy)
-> You get less supply
 
If a unit don´t get enough supply and had no reserves it can´t recover the during the turn lost readiness.
Because of this it will start the next turn with less action points and less effective.
 
There are some ways to control the supply flow.
SubHQ can store reserves you can set (for coming winter, offensives, upgrading equipment and so on)
You can also set how much supply a unit get in%.
In case you have a lack of supply you can set priorities this way. A unit that 80% supply gets has still a good worth in combat,
but it´s not the best choice in own attacks.
 
Things like bombed production and destroyed bridges are another problem to supply.
Bridges can prevent supply from reaching it´s destination and bombed cities can reduce
the supply production.
It´s a very complex thing compared to PT, but i love it !
 
The HQ attached to the supply producing cities can store supply, so depending on the there stored amount you can
adjust the production a bit.
 
Did i forget things, Vic ?
 
 

RE: Supply Query

Posted: Sun Jul 08, 2007 12:10 pm
by lancer
Goodaye,

Thanks for the informative reply. You mentioned supply range. With all the linkages in the supply chain (City - HQ - subHQ - unit) are these a fixed range of hexes or does it vary depending on terrain and road / rail nets a-la-TAOW ?

Cheers,
Lancer

RE: Supply Query

Posted: Sun Jul 08, 2007 12:55 pm
by Vic
Supply range is depended on roads, bridges, rivers, landscapetypes and even dammage to harbours (for supply traced through sea hexes)

RE: Supply Query

Posted: Sun Jul 08, 2007 10:26 pm
by lancer
Goodaye,

O.K. Thanks for your fast reply.

I have one further question. In the AAR of Barbarrossa that you are doing (excellent), are the germans drawing the supply from their distant start line in Western Poland & East Prussia or are they using captured cities as a supply source? How does the games supply mechanic's model this situation which was, I understand, quite a dilemma for the Germans at the time?

Cheers,
Lancer

RE: Supply Query

Posted: Mon Jul 09, 2007 1:22 am
by tweber
Germany is drawing supply from Rumania and Poland along the roads.  They are vulnerable to being cut.  I have already diverted units to keep the lines open and am making a push between the Moscow and Stalingrad fronts to protect my flanks. 

RE: Supply Query

Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2007 6:19 am
by lancer
Goodaye,

O.K, thanks. Does the supply attenuate over that large distance? Eg. if you start out with 100 supply units in Poland do you receive 100 units at Army Group North provided the road link is intact and there is no air or naval interdiction?

Cheers,
Lancer

RE: Supply Query

Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2007 9:34 am
by goodwoodrw
are they map overlays to show u supply routes stockpiles and broken lines of sup?

RE: Supply Query

Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2007 11:19 am
by tweber
Yes.  Vic has the overlay turned on in the first picture of his turn 7.

RE: Supply Query

Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2007 2:35 pm
by TPM
ORIGINAL: seille

Supply system is very complex.

The supply produced in cities flows into the attached HQ´s. From there it flows to
the sub HQ´s and from there to the units.
Many factors can have a impact here !
HQ or unit is not in perfect supply range or out of range
-> HQ or unit get less or no supply

Supply was destroyed by Anti supply on their way (navy or air of the enemy)
-> You get less supply

If a unit don´t get enough supply and had no reserves it can´t recover the during the turn lost readiness.
Because of this it will start the next turn with less action points and less effective.

There are some ways to control the supply flow.
SubHQ can store reserves you can set (for coming winter, offensives, upgrading equipment and so on)
You can also set how much supply a unit get in%.
In case you have a lack of supply you can set priorities this way. A unit that 80% supply gets has still a good worth in combat,
but it´s not the best choice in own attacks.

Things like bombed production and destroyed bridges are another problem to supply.
Bridges can prevent supply from reaching it´s destination and bombed cities can reduce
the supply production.
It´s a very complex thing compared to PT, but i love it !

The HQ attached to the supply producing cities can store supply, so depending on the there stored amount you can
adjust the production a bit.

Did i forget things, Vic ?


You say the supply system is complex, but does it make sense to the player? Can we figure it out? I have to this day never really figured out the supply system in TOAW and so it's really something I have at the back of my mind. With PT, I had a pretty good grip on the supply system and many of my decisions were based on knowing exactly what would happen if I lost supply, or cut the enemy's supply. Yes, we all know having no supply is bad, but in PT I knew how many turns a unit could last, I could see how much supply was left, I knew if I brought my THQ closer to the unit I could improve the situation, etc. Is the supply system in AT easily grasped?

RE: Supply Query

Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2007 3:08 pm
by seille
I can follow the AT supply system very good and i think all former PT players will be able to follow it.
It is NOT that much away from ! At least in the basics. But the routing is better and you get more
informations on the supply flow.
I do not know TOAW III. After playing AT for such a long time know i see no reason to play other similar
wargames or even to look at.
 
For the supply. I think i described well in my post above. Vic added some more things. You can see easily how
the supply works. It is a very logical thing in my eyes [:)]
 
supply arrival:
 
A unit in bad range get less or nothing if out of range (can happen when in bad terrain and not connected via road)
Depending on the stored supply the unit has it will sooner or later lose the readiness and become this way worthless.
 
If a city can´t deliver production to the attached HQ it stores the production (troops and supply) and will deliver as soon as possible. 
Can´t see any points in that system that are not logical or easy to follow.
 
But AT is overall a complex game and a new player will need some time to understand the game mechanics.
Some guy´s learn faster than others [:D]. I was a player that needed some time to learn..... 
This time you have to invest but after that AT is the pure fun. No idea why i write that...reading the AAR
should be enough [;)]
I play my turns now since about 15 month´s every day and it is still fun !

RE: Supply Query

Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2007 4:29 pm
by tweber
Couple comments on supply:
 
1.  It is pretty fundamental to the game system.  Attacking or cutting off an opponents supply lines is often more effective then attacking troops.  In the current AAR as the German player, I have approach key objectives with the view of isolating the Soviets while maintaining my supply lines.  In this sense, AT is similar to PT.
 
2.  AT has features that make managing supply easier:
a. There is a report that shows how much supply each HQ and unit needs.  You can then produce and direct your supply appropriately. 
b. There is an overlay that shows supply reachibility from HQ.  You can see if the HQ will be able to get supply from it's source and then pass it on to it's units.
c. Finally, each unit shows how much supply it has and how much reserve it can carry.  Most land units can store 2 turns of supply.  This is helpful in determining whether a unit up front can risk an explotation or should focus on re-establishing supply. 

RE: Supply Query

Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2007 5:19 pm
by Ande
is it possible to supply an entire army with a single little dirtroad located in the middle of nowhere or is there a limit?