Page 1 of 1
AI and Tutorial
Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2007 2:30 pm
by leftydad
Can you play against the AI in this game? If so, is the AI okay? And does the game come with a useful tutorial to help the beginning player?
3 questions. Thanks for the help. [&o]
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2007 2:32 pm
by Erik Rutins
Hi Leftydad,
Yes, yes and yes. [:)]
Regards,
- Erik
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2007 4:52 am
by Alan_Bernardo
I must say, unless I missed something, the tutorial in AT is very poor. It is very short, ends as if the player were in the middle of something, and only shows how to create and transfer units and set a unit's HQ.
The ending of the tutorial scenario in the manual is almost laughable: "You have completed this scenario. The last thing we will now teach you is how to exit this scenario."
I was expecting something better with the tutorial.
Alan
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:37 am
by freeboy
the game is very easy to learn and also lots of help herre to get going and then learn the nuts and bolts.. ask away, someone surely will help!
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:44 am
by kam99
I have to agree with Alan. I expected more help fom tutorials. After playing the tutorial supplied, what would you recommend as the next steps for learning the game system?
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2007 7:09 am
by Westheim
The best way to learn the game mechanis would be to have played the original People's Tactics for years. [8D]
Otherwise, a game against the AI on a fairly small random map might help. The standard AI is actually very weak for veteran PT players, but just right for beginners, I think.
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2007 7:24 am
by freeboy
read the manual and start any game, learn in no particular order,
A. how to build a shell, and transfer componenet parts into it
B how to assign these shell units to a hq.
C. how to attack, unlike other gamesthis game does not have you give your units attack orders, rather you select the hex to attack, and there are a lot of attack types, land to land , artilery barage, air attack etc. Then assign which unit groups, and there are rules for how to help your attacks succeed, find these and note in the attack screan the % bonus you are recieving.
D. stick some inf type in a shell, then do the same and add trucks, see how many truck or half tracks it takes to increase the move rates the FOLLOWING turn these two nearly identical shell units are formed.
E Learn how to acces the entire build screan showing every city, note some scenarios have no or few, take up Russia 41 and open up and play as an example. do not worry about anything but learning.
F. Now try to make supply and all the other types of groups, see how they cost differing amount of production?
They each can go to different Hq, practive moving units builds to a few differnet HQ...
Learn to use Engeneers,sp?. I alway buiild with them early in the Russia 41 as the red army guys are going to fall back toward Karkov, and Lenn they blow bridges, b=uild roads and are generally very usefull, but I turn them off after gettting enough.. staying on top of what you need at the moment is critical and there is no lag in the builds, not accurate but a nice help.
Supply is a tricky one too, too much and it sits around gathering dust, too little and you are in trouble!
G. Now on to research.
Find and spend some research on some basic unit component like submachine gun troop advances. these take place immediately for factories building them, BUT your troops in the field still have the old guns etc. SO what to do?
Open them up mousing to the unit, shell, and you will see the subcomponent parts, Submachine gun x number or rifle x number etc. if you upgraded say a Submachine gun type from level one to two, mouse over and click on the unit, if it is in a supplied state, whatever that means, I assume near a HQ that has extra supply, you can drag a slider left to right to "convert" old to new.. I do think you take a experience hit to do this.
H. reassigne a unit from one hq to another, not the most important thing, but needed.
I. transfer troops between two non hq units, I did not know you could do this.
J. Open up a scen using naval units and practics loaing and unloading troops on cargo ships, remeber they are dead meat if a sub gets them, I like to put a DD with them. practice sea and air to sea attacks.
K Note, when you are looking at the page, there are some numbers on the lower right, learn what these mean... it is easy to miss, but also self explanitory... loss tollerence interdiction of supplies for air etc.
These steps should have you beating up the AI in no time, and soon you will be knocking on the door of the testers to have them "help you" in pbem.
Remember there are lots of folks to help, the above is not official, I am not a moderator, just an enthusiast![:D][:D]
Finally ASK ?'s!`
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2007 8:03 am
by JudgeDredd
For information, the developer recommeneds playing the AI on AI+ or AI++...his own words from another thread in this forum
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2007 8:51 am
by Awac835
Yeah, in the official scenario i can now almost repedetly beat the normal AI. Only if i make a mistake and let it cut of my supply roads and production from one of the citys will i lose. I ofc try and do the same to the AI.
AI+ and AI++ should be the way to go.
But then again i actualy dont mind it with a easy normal AI becouse it keeps me going, especialy on the larger scenarios as they will surely be more of a challenge becouse they also present more of a strategic challenge as well as a tactical one.
In BiN i had to give myself extra reinforcments or die rolls to beat the normal AI. I never even tried the AI+/AI++
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2007 12:37 pm
by Erik Rutins
Did you try the training scenarios as well for an easier start?
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:20 pm
by TheHellPatrol
What he should have done is make it clear what/how to approach learning the game. The manual has a "tutorial" and the game has "training" scenarios, it is up to the player to figure it out. The tutorial is like a small sample random game whereas the trainers cover the different aspects of the game such as armor vs. infantry, air power, naval battles etc.
After all that and about 4 or 5 scenario restarts(oops forgot to transfer troops again, doh) i had it down pat.
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 7:09 am
by Adam Parker
I must agree that this game is much more complex than graphics and first appearances suggest.
It most certainly could use a more structured and intensive tut or a phased approach to learning.
After blasting my way around the Ardennes and then picking up the rules, I can say that on a scale of 1 (easy) to 10 (hard), I'd rate this game a 6.5 on par with World at War. It will take some learning to fathom.
And to the hard-working guys at Matrix, yeah I know time is limited but please fellas, look into proof reading your rules! Thanks btw for the print-ready manuals though.
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2007 1:21 am
by Veldor
The tutorial was very helpful and informative for what little it did cover but gave the most unfinished feeling I think I've ever had. It's almost as if some deadline was hit where an otherwise perfect tutorial thus far was ended abruptly with "And then you exit the game" when it should have carried on for pages and pages more. I'd have expected at least a dozen other basic topics to be included, but they were not. The training scenarios are worthless. I've no idea whatsoever what I'm suppose to be doing, much less what I'm suppose to be learning from them. And not having an AI in them makes even less sense and continues the unfinished feeling.
Perhaps this game is easy for those that have played People's Tactics or even TOAW for years but I've played neither.
Sorry, but it scores a 1/5 for me for ease of learning.
Fortuneately it appears to score very high in nearly every other area and is therefore worthwhile enough to hunker down with the manual for a good read-through circa 1970's. It's just disappointing that we haven't moved past a requirement such as that some 40 years later, given that every other genre of gaming has.
It would be a nice community improvement to me if someone would put together some tutorial scenarios, especially ones that covered basic tactics in the game.
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2007 1:26 am
by SMK-at-work
I got the game last night - the tutorial is basic but there are training scenarios too and it seesm strange that people don't notice those and use them!
I was able to play the game fairly roughly having done the tutorial and 1 training scenario (tanks vs infantry - I don't know how you can say it's useless...it tells you what to do with your tanks and how they can use manouvre to destroy the infantry - and then you do it pretty much the same as in the tutorial but with more units...wtf is the problem??

) - I then went straight to russia 1941 and learned heaps more by doing and having the manual open in the background to change to and look things up.
Seems pretty standard for any game to me - indeed better than many!
See also my blog at
http://www.gamesquad.com/forums/blogs/viewblog.php?userid=5647&entry=318
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2007 1:39 am
by TheHellPatrol
ORIGINAL: Veldor
The training scenarios are worthless. I've no idea whatsoever what I'm suppose to be doing, much less what I'm suppose to be learning from them. And not having an AI in them makes even less sense and continues the unfinished feeling.
There is an AI, again if there was better documentation re:tutorial & training missions it wouldn't go unnoticed. When you set up a training scenario you can pick either blue or red, then you click on the "human" next to the opponent you chose and it cycles thru human, AI, AI+ and AI++.
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2007 2:25 am
by Veldor
There is an AI, again if there was better documentation re:tutorial & training missions it wouldn't go unnoticed. When you set up a training scenario you can pick either blue or red, then you click on the "human" next to the opponent you chose and it cycles thru human, AI, AI+ and AI++.
Ah, silly me thinking a training scenario would be setup by default to actually train you on something. [:D]
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2007 2:45 am
by SMK-at-work
Yeah - that'd be why the initial notes in the training scenarios tell you what they're there to train you about...so you don't have any idea what they're for...[8|]
RE: AI and Tutorial
Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2007 3:37 am
by Veldor
ORIGINAL: SMK-at-work
Yeah - that'd be why the initial notes in the training scenarios tell you what they're there to train you about...so you don't have any idea what they're for...[8|]
Right. So I'll hand you a rifle and say "The purpose of this training excercise is to learn how to shoot a rifle". Now go shoot.
I suppose after you've shot it enough you've learned more than you knew in the first place. But I'd hardly call that training.