Page 1 of 1

Can you restrict what a city produces?

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 8:38 pm
by SMK-at-work
Just got the game last night and stayed up way too late playing russia 41[>:]

I'd like to tweak that scenario a bit (nothing like jumping in at het deep end!!) by putting in a few production restrictions. For example the Russians had only a handful of facilities that could produce medium tanks (Kharkov, Leningrad, Stalingrad & a couple in the Urals one of which was evacuated from Kharkov) - one at Leningrad & Kharkov were evacuated IIRC, & Stalingrad was blown to bits (the Tractor Factory).

Light tanks, OTOH, could be produced by plants that made trucks and cars. Most often these plants were in the same cities as those that built the heavier tanks, but not always (eg Factory 38 at Kirov produced T60's, T70's and Su-76's until 1943 with no heavier plant nearby).

similarly heavy artillery was only produced at a small nubmer of plants.


RE: Can you restrict what a city produces?

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 8:49 pm
by freeboy
not sure about that, BUT you are saying that they where not done historically, but are you also statingthe COULD not be done? I do not agree

RE: Can you restrict what a city produces?

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 9:36 pm
by SMK-at-work
suer you can build a tank plant anywhere....if you're willing to put in the resources.  But in AT you dont' have to do that...you can just allocate some production to tanks and voila - next turn you get tanks.  THAT is not "historic", so for simplicities sake I'd like to restrict tank production to those cities that had it.

RE: Can you restrict what a city produces?

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 9:38 pm
by freeboy
that makes sense, and you could , if possible add a DELAY when changeing types, say inf to planes or art  or .. etc
I do not think the engine supports that..could be done with house rules as factories can be idled

RE: Can you restrict what a city produces?

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 9:50 pm
by seille
@SMK
 
Be careful with any changes in the russia 1941 scenario.
That scenario has some events that calculate with production values.
I don´t want to go in detail.
So when you add cities or change their production capacity you´ll definitely screw these events.
I know what i´m talking about cause i worked on that part of the events.
 
Pls make sure you can follow the events 100% especially what happens when german capture a russian city.
To be honest i would let it as it is. When the german will advance you´ll be happy when you are flexible in production....

RE: Can you restrict what a city produces?

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 9:58 pm
by therockyfroggy
Knew you'd buy the game....it's so tough to hold off on these damn new games.

Hey, I'm back from a 10 day trip and will get that GOA turn off tonight...am up for any AT PBEM also.....a lot quicker..no more vacations till next summer!

RE: Can you restrict what a city produces?

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 9:59 pm
by SMK-at-work
It's not a matter of being happy with flexibility - that might make it easier to win, but it is not a flexibility the Sov's had in 1941, and I would like to play a game that has all the problems they had (and gives the Axis all the problems THEY had too...)

RE: Can you restrict what a city produces?

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 10:06 pm
by seille
Ok SMK, i just wanted to warn you about the events used here.
Be careful with [;)]

RE: Can you restrict what a city produces?

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 10:10 pm
by SMK-at-work
Yeah well anything I do do will be on a copy of the scenario....not the original!! [8D]

RE: Can you restrict what a city produces?

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 10:19 pm
by tweber
You can change what a location type is allow to produced.  So, all cities will produce the same thing.  However, you could make a location called 'city that produces medium tanks' and then not allow medium tanks elsewhere.
 
Also, you can also set what a particular regime can produce.  So you could invent a type called the katyusha and only allow the Soviets to produce.