ORIGINAL: GBS
Need some info before I buy.
How complex is this game?
Fairly...not so much as TOAW, more so than SC2 or CEAW
Is this another TOAW? (I liked TOAW.)
sort of but not quite [:)]
If not how does it differ?
It has some features that are a lot better than TOAW - it handles the strategic side of things that TOAW has to be fudged for, it allows units to be transferred between HQ's, new units and HQ's to be built, etc.
But the tactical aspects such as the combat model is more abstracted.
How much play time to complete a tipical scenario?
Depends on the scenario.....
What about command and control and logistics?
it has an interesting supply system - you produce supplies at some of your manufacturing plants/cities - each such plant/city feeds its units to a set HQ. HQ's and units subordinate to that HQ then "demand" supplies from it, and get what it can deliver.
I haven't gotten to all the intricacies yet, but it's a much better system than most, because supplies actually get used up - unlike most systems 9incl TOAW, SC2, CEAW) where you get a supply value for a hex and any number of units in that hex get exactly the same - which is always the max supply that the hex can deliver.
Ditto for new troops - they get produced, then funnelled straight to a set HQ. But from there you have to allocate them manually to new or existing units. there's a transport limit, and the further your production is from your HQ the fewer troops actually make it - the rest get caught in a backlog and keep trying (at least that's how I think it works....)
Command and control is fairly simple - combat units are allocated (subordinate) to HQ's - HQ's have staff points, and het more combat units they control the more staff they need. there's a staff rating for HQ's which is the % of required staff - this can be over 100% if you have more than required, and the staff rating affects combat performance of all subordinate units - including bonuses if over 100%.
Units can be x-fered betwen HQ's, but lose quite a lot of effectiveness when they do so.
So for the Sov's in 1941, for example, you have several cities feeding supplies and replacements into STAVKA HQ. All other HQ's are subordinate to STAVKA, so they draw their supplies from it. in my game vs teh AI I had STAVKA build some reserve armies around Moscow, while also feeding troops to Smolensk, Kiev and Kharkov. Those HQ's built new units to do the fighting.
Leningrad production went straight to the Leningrad HQ, which built up reserves around that city and crushed the Finns (I think the Finns need fortifications!!). similarly Kharkov production went straight to Kharkov, Kiev to Kiev and a couple of other cities sent it straight to nearby HQ's to avoid transport bottlenecks.
all in all it seems a pretty good system.