Page 1 of 1

Some questions and observations concerning combat and AI

Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2007 2:57 pm
by Xenomath
I played some scenarios, browsed through the manual and have some questions now:

1. What is the supply consume modifier? (p.54)
2. What is the Rebel Combat modifier? (p.55)
3. What exactly is the penalty for attacking over a river?
4. Initiative scores: Hight score goes first, right?
5. When comparing the stats of rifle and SMG, I wondered about SMG targeting armors first while rifles target them last. Bug or feature?
6. At least in the desert scenario the AI(++) seldom moved his planes to the front.
Playing with both sides, both times they had most of their planes unused in the main HQ far behind the front.
7. I have the feeling AI only attacks with one unit at a time instead of simultaneously using the bonus for attacking from several directions, but maybe I just observed it once or twice when the AI thought it would win with the first attack and had to attack second time...
8. What exactly are the effects of ZOC? Only which adjacent hexes convert to my territory?
It seems to me like I need a minimum ZOC score to conquer adjacent territory even when there is no enemy unit present. Is that right?
9. do scouts have to be in a unit without other subformations to use their increased hide skill?
10. Why is there no music during the game? Is this common with these kinds of games? I have thematically fitting music from other games I play in the background, so it's ok, but music in the game would have been nice.
11. Will there be additional ladder maps? The two coming with the game are nice, but I could imagine that they can grow old after some time

Enough for now, more questions will certainly arise later :)
Btw. nice game! I especially like it that you have to watch your supply lines and other logistical effects, an aspect I'm often missing in other games. Also the combat system is nicely done. It's probabilistic without overemphasizing luck and complex enough so you have to use intuition and can't do all the numbers to calculate your odds.


RE: Some questions and observations concerning combat and AI

Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2007 4:31 pm
by Vic
hi xenomath,
 
lot of questions so i keep it short.
 
1. if unit did not consume enough supply it will not perform well in combat
 
2. only happens in some events where a unit appears from nowhere upon the occupants of the hex
 
3. thats different per type of subformation. its worse for armour then for infantry
 
4. highest probably goes first.  (is randomized)
 
5. is bug. thank you very much for spotting. will be fixed in 1st patch.
 
6. the AI can still be improved upon. i agree. though this will always remain the case.
 
7. no it does simultaneous attacks.
 
8. yes only that.
 
9. yes. if they are together with a piece of artillery, the artillery will give them away.
 
10. noted.
 
11. lets see how things go. i very well might add some. but maybe the community will offer some new official ladder maps too ?
 
kind regards,
Vic

RE: Some questions and observations concerning combat and AI

Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2007 6:17 pm
by Awac835
More ladder maps could be cool. If more versions are added to it would also be great. I really like how the plain and forrest/mountain ones play out so differently due to the focus of tanks in the one with open ground and infantry in the forrest and mountain version.

RE: Some questions and observations concerning combat and AI

Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2007 4:11 pm
by Xenomath
Thanks for answering my questions

1. Ok, so there is an extra combat penalty besides low readiness for low supply?
Is the colored status display in the units symbol linked to this?

3. A I see, it's with the other terrain modifiers. I got confused by the modifier also described on p. 55 concerning rivers. What's that about?

5. glad I could help :)

7. Ok, I saw it doing that now.


some more questions:

12. Why should I build up a command hierarchy? The staff bonus and the variation of concentric boni only takes into account the direct HQ of a unit, doesn't it? Ok, it's nice to have a central HQ with lots of trucks where all the production goes so you can distribute from there. But there is no need for staff in such a logistical HQ, is there?

13. In the Naval training scenario the cargo ship did not have enough supply in stock for itself and the
loaded land formation to make it without heavy readiness losses to the other side of the map. How to do that in a better way?

RE: Some questions and observations concerning combat and AI

Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2007 4:27 pm
by Vic
1. yes low supply is extra on top of low readiness.
 
3. its the same. only it says -X% because it varies per suformationtype
 
12. thats true. but sometimes it is handy if supply gets automaticly handed out from a more central distribution point. you can use multiple HQs too to determain how supply flows overseas.
 
13. must be a scenario setup issue, because a cargoship can take like 20x the supply it needs with it. 
 
kind regards,
Vi
 

RE: Some questions and observations concerning combat and AI

Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2007 11:39 pm
by Xenomath
3. I'm referring to this entry:

Defending individual is attacking over river and not broken through (Presence of a bridge halves the penalty)
Attacker Attack Points: -
Defender Attack Points: -
Attacker Hit Points: -
Defender Hit Points: Minus X%


Why does the defender lose hit points?

13. Sure, a cargo ship can hold 200 points of supply, much more than it consumes.
But when 2 cargo ships with a stock of 400 supply carry 100 SMGs consuming a total of 200 supply per turn, the stock is depleted quite fast.