Page 1 of 2

Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 2:43 pm
by Jim D Burns
I would like to see bombardments (air, land and sea) toned down in its ability to kill elements outright. Currently an air, artillery or naval formation of perhaps 5 bombardment elements can practically wipe out a 30-40 element land unit in one 10 phase attack. That is far too powerful for bombardment attacks. Bombardments need to disrupt readiness more but kill less I think. Bombardments should augment your attack or defense, not be your attack or defense.

Perhaps put a cap on the number of elements that bombardment type attacks can destroy. Say 1 element max per 5 elements bombarding can be destroyed.

Jim

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 2:57 pm
by Banquet
ORIGINAL: Jim D Burns

I would like to see bombardments (air, land and sea) toned down in its ability to kill elements outright. Currently an air, artillery or naval formation of perhaps 5 bombardment elements can practically wipe out a 30-40 element land unit in one 10 phase attack. That is far too powerful for bombardment attacks. Bombardments need to disrupt readiness more but kill less I think. Bombardments should augment your attack or defense, not be your attack or defense.

Perhaps put a cap on the number of elements that bombardment type attacks can destroy. Say 1 element max per 5 elements bombarding can be destroyed.

Jim

I tend to agree. Could the damage be more proportionate to entrenchment level? It's probably not too bad for units caught moving in the open, but when a unit is well entrenched in defensive terrain I think the damage is too high.

How about reducing the damage somewhat but adding in a loss of actionpoints? That would simulate a unit being pinned down by constant air attack.

As a side note.. as aircraft are very powerful in the game, could the AI be adjusted to build more of it?



RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 2:58 pm
by seille
The air/artillery attacks are not too powerful. You should not forget the costs of the planes in your calculations.
A plane represents 20 infantry, so it´s very ok they do a lot of damage in the open terrain when the target is not entrenched
or protected by flak/fighters.
Look at the same attack when the target is entrenched or maybe in heavy forrest and you´ll note it will cause smaller losses.

The whole system was balanced over a long time. You have no idea what would happen when you reduce air or artillery power
as much as you want. Breaking thru enemy fortified lines would be impossible. The attacker would have unbelievable bloody losses
when he can´t prepare the attacks well enough by planes/artillery.
Or want to reduce entrenchemnt, too ?

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 3:14 pm
by Awac835
I too are sometimes suprised by how deadly arty and airstrikes are. But then again i dont really mind it becouse it do seems that entrenchment and enviorment play a big role.
 
If you have lots of infantry with little entrenchment and on a plain open hex. Fighter planes will really hurt them same goes for dive bombers against tanks in the open. Try the same in heavy forrest and you will see they dont really hurt them that much.
 
And i agree that the price of planes should be factored in, They are reletive expensive comming in with a price of 2000 production points

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 4:27 pm
by pad152
Every unit has it's match, if your being bombarded by ship build subs!, if you being attacked by bombers, build AA and fighters. One of the keys to victory in AT is to keep changing your production to build what you need, in one turn you can build subs, in the next turn build fighters, etc.

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 4:56 pm
by Banquet
ORIGINAL: pad152

Every unit has it's match, if your being bombarded by ship build subs!, if you being attacked by bombers, build AA and fighters. One of the keys to victory in AT is to keep changing your production to build what you need, in one turn you can build subs, in the next turn build fighters, etc.


That is a good point. Playing against the AI I have encountered the occasional fighter unit and when I do my divebombers are vastly less effective. Having the AI build more fighters would certainly help.

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 5:08 pm
by seille
Against AI+ i often met very big fighter units (overall i destroyed about 150 in a russia 1941 game), but the AI
doesn´t use it´s planes always that good. And another point is that the AI let the planes often on not or bad guarded places
to close behind the front, so a good player will focuss at and overroll them. A thing a smart PBEM opponent never will do.
I think 2/3 of the AI planes i destroyed on the ground. Meeting all of them in the air.....oha !

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 6:19 pm
by Jim D Burns
I guess it’s just a matter of personal preference. Some people prefer the simpler rock, paper, scissors style of game. I would prefer a more historically correct style of game. Which means bombardments would not destroy the defenders, instead it would prepare the way for attacking ground forces to be the ones that actually destroy the defenders.

What we have now is the rock paper scissors (RPS) kind of game, what I was asking for was a change towards the historical style. With the RPS style of play, pure air or sea power can obliterate all ground forces in an area even if no friendly ground forces are around for miles. That NEVER happened in WWII.

Heck even the first gulf war and its massively successful and punishing air campaign needed hundreds of thousands of friendly ground troops to go in and actually eliminate the defending forces… In this game, there wouldn’t be an Iraqi ground unit left in the entire country because bombardment attacks kill too many forces instead of just disrupting them which is what bombardment attacks actually do.

Jim

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 6:35 pm
by seille
Rock Paper Scissors is the concept the game was balanced. So if you change the artillery/planes you have to change
many other settings, too.
As you said that´s personal preference.
You could change the masterfile settings here yourself and play with a modified masterfile with reduced losses by
air attack/artillery bombardment.
I would like to let these settings as they are now.
I think it won´t need much time until completely new designed masterfiles will come with changed settings and more units.

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 8:32 pm
by Ande
I think someone said that no country has ever been forced to surrender due to airpower alone and I think that someone was Saddam Hussein, I'm not sure though. Anyway, having massive piles of artillery and aircraft helps alot, but it is also  very expensive and they are nothing worth if an enemy manage to attack you on the ground

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 9:09 pm
by Xenomath
At least artillery does much more readiness damage than killing damage, so I think this is kind of realistic.

Looking at the combat system, a concepts come to my mind that could further help in this way and would not change the balance, I hope.
While the way artillery works against a formation with many targets seems fine to me, a small formation (or the remains of a large formation) should not be as vulnerable.
Looking at the artilleries "favTries" value of 1, reflecting it's inaccuracy, I had the following idea:
Why not add dummy targets each combat round for every n stack points below 100. So to kill of the last units in a formation, you need accurate weapons.

Only problem is that bombers have a quite high favTries value, so I fear we would still need some major changes to make it work for planes, too. (I do wonder why the level bombers are so accurate... picking single targets in a level bombing run?)

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 11:20 pm
by Awac835
I can agree that level bombers seem a bit over powered when it comes to killing power against units. But then again i guess if a B-24 came flying by dropping a full payload over a line of defence it would wreck havoc on the ground. But did that ever happen? i mean carpet bombings with planes over defences in preperation for attacks.

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 11:41 pm
by Peterk1
Definitely but they were notoriously inaccurate and would often hit friendlies as often as the enemy. And usually missed the juicy targets altogether.

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 1:31 am
by SMK-at-work
Monte Cassino was carpet bombed...not a German in hte place until it was reduced to rubble that made great cover....

Level bombing was never a tactical solution in WW2 - that's why dive bombers came along - to give some chance of actually landing 1 bomb somewhere within a football-field of the target!!

Dive bombers were, of course, superseded by fighterbombers in the West, and by those and ground attack in the East, but in all cases actual battlefield support was usually hitting things at least a few miles behind the front lines.

I'd be happy if bombers wrecked readiness and supply and made it a walkover for the troops on the ground withoiut killing so much.  That's give a better "feel" IMO.

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 10:44 am
by seille
Yes, the bombers are deadly especially with high XP against troops in the open.
BUT: Why you guy´s don´t do attacks against troops covered by flak ?
You´ll see a much lower effect. You´ll start to lose planes in that attacks and sometimes killing only 1 truck or
something like this.
 
It´s not the fault of the game engine when you´re not able to protect your troops against enemy bombers.
Produce fighters, produce flak and the enemy will have a hard time attacking you.
Reducing the bombers power will make them useless compaired to their price and beeing that vulnerable
against AA fire and fighters. Bombers that reduce only a bit of readiness i would not buy. They have to knock
out tanks/artillery and trucks and also some infantry.

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 11:08 am
by Banquet
Can the AI be altered to build some/more flak?




RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 11:30 am
by seille
At least the AI should use more !!
So far the AI uses planes (even not perfect since often they don´t intercept), but i can´t remember i saw any flak
placed by the AI.

I think the AI should be clever enough to produce and place some flak when the enemy attacks turn by turn with
planes. A weak point of the AI even it uses overall a not bad unit mix.

Imho there is still a lot of room for improvements for the AI. I hope Vic can do something here.
When plane attacks are harder against the AI the whole fight against AI will go into a new dimension [:)]

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 11:35 am
by Banquet
Agreed :)

I did come across AI fighters in my game yesterday. I lost 6 of my 20 divebombers so when they are around, they work well. I was scared to attack that hex again! [:D] I don't see them often against the AI though.

I haven't come across flak yet but from the way it's described in the manual it sounds like it would help even things out. I like the fact it has a range of 1. If a few units had flak it might make all the difference.

Not sure how the AI is programmed to build, but if a few flak units could be included in it's build order that would be a step in the right direction :)

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 2:13 pm
by Vic
ORIGINAL: Banquet

Can the AI be altered to build some/more flak?

it is not building any flak at all at the moment. i'll look into the option.

RE: Less lethal bombardments

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:13 pm
by Erik Rutins
Jim,

A couple of things to note are that in this game you can actually edit this stuff, so if you have an idea of how you want units to function, create a new master file and make some changes. It's really pretty easy from what I've seen.

Second, keep in mind the timescale. Depending on the scenario, a "bombardment" may actually be two to four weeks of sustained air or artillery attack.

Regards,

- Erik