Page 1 of 1

I think I'm going to give AT an 8/8

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 5:41 pm
by JaguarUSF
Can't........resist......awesomeness.

The flexibility of the game is winning me over: size of battles, time period. It's a lot like TOAW but less annoying because I don't have hundreds of units to worry about if I don't want to. The HQ and production model is great. Well, I don't want to spoil much about my review, so we'll see if my opinion changes between now and the 12th (when it goes up).

On a semi-related topic, would it be possible to make random maps using other scenarios? I know the master file controls the units and that can be changed, but the master file for the downloaded scenarios seem to be imbedded in the .pt2 file. If I could do a random map using the World War I or not-Lord-of-the-Rings units, that would solidify the 8/8 methinks. Mmmmm...future patch?

RE: I think I'm going to give AT an 8/8

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 5:47 pm
by Banquet
I would certainly give AT a pretty high score if I were reviewing it. The wargamer review was good, but didn't seem overly enthusiastic. I guess it's horses for courses. I can see where a real grognard would find faults in AT but the fun factor and brilliant design just completely outweigh any potential realism issues for me.

RE: I think I'm going to give AT an 8/8

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 5:47 pm
by Awac835
You can specify which master file to use for random games. Only thing is that the scenario designers have imbedded there master file into there scenario. Atleast thats how i think it works. Ive only briefly read the manual on the editor so i dont know all that much about it. But i think you could take the tolken scenario and extract the master file for it and use it in random games maybe?

RE: I think I'm going to give AT an 8/8

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 7:33 pm
by ravinhood
See Banquet that's the difference in a professional review an a fanboi review. ;)~[:D]

RE: I think I'm going to give AT an 8/8

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 7:35 pm
by Banquet
ORIGINAL: ravinhood

See Banquet that's the difference in a professional review an a fanboi review. ;)~[:D]

Fanboi? Moi?

[:D]

RE: I think I'm going to give AT an 8/8

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 7:49 pm
by freeboy
read the Wargamer review again, it was very enthusiastic imo
reavenhood, dude what are you waiting for?[&:]

RE: I think I'm going to give AT an 8/8

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 8:19 pm
by Banquet
ORIGINAL: freeboy

read the Wargamer review again, it was very enthusiastic imo
reavenhood, dude what are you waiting for?[&:]

It was a positive review and I didn't mean to imply otherwise. However, for example, the closing remark;

'gamers who are interested in a versatile, turn-based wargame of medium complexity, may wish to consider adding Advanced Tactics: World War II to their collection.'

Is a bit more subdued that I'd have written. However, as ravinhood points out, I'm no reviewer, and probably for good reason :)