Page 1 of 1

Wish: Loading plane units on cargo ships

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 10:57 am
by seille
I think it would be good and realistic when a player would be able to load plane units on cargoships.
That planes are not usable while transfer of course.
Lend Lease convoy´s sent a lot of planes to Russia, so i think that should be possible by the AT engine.

RE: Wish: Loading plane units on cargo ships

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 6:28 pm
by freeboy
I am sure there is a field that shows planes and load on off in the  designer. 

RE: Wish: Loading plane units on cargo ships

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 6:34 pm
by Vic
Hi seille,
 
Putting airplanes on naval units can only be done on aircraft arriers.
 
If you want to get them from one airfield to a faraway airfield or port overseas you have to use transfers.
 

RE: Wish: Loading plane units on cargo ships

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 6:40 pm
by seille
Thanks Vic, but i know that of course.
Transport on Carriers is not what i had in mind. I have in mind a transport on a cargoship
from Manchester to lets say Alexandria. Same kind of transport like a armor unit.
But there is probably something like a hardcoded difference that doesn´t allow to transport it in that way.
 
How about two "different transport" types for planes ?
 
1. With "active" planes on CV´s
2. With "inactive" (no AP or something like this) on cargoships
 
You´ll agree that moving planes on cargoships was used in ww2.
Maybe you can find a way to allow that.

RE: Wish: Loading plane units on cargo ships

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 6:44 pm
by seille
Just to explain.
I just had to evacuate Manchester in my 1939 game.
And i had limited room for transports and had to set priorities.
 
Highest would have had my fighter group (7 fighter III with 71XP), but i had only
1 CV for transporting them. The cargoships (2) i would have used if possible even i had to save a lot
of other material like my very valuable Flak III with over 50XP.
 
That´s why i ask. When i add the planes to a ground unit would a transport on cargoships then possible
with the actual settings or would the unit the start to be a "air unit" ?

RE: Wish: Loading plane units on cargo ships

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 10:25 pm
by Gresbeck
ORIGINAL: seille

I think it would be good and realistic when a player would be able to load plane units on cargoships.
That planes are not usable while transfer of course.
Lend Lease convoy´s sent a lot of planes to Russia, so i think that should be possible by the AT engine.

I thought the system works realistically as it is. Loading planes on cargoes needs a big logistical effort and many assets: in game terms it needs a transfer operation through HQ.

RE: Wish: Loading plane units on cargo ships

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 11:02 pm
by SMK-at-work
Planes are pretty much expendabble - in the circumstances as described evacuating the crews and support and then re-equipping them would have been a realistic proposal "in real life".
 
Planes were often shipped - eg lend lease aircraft to Murmansk were crated.  It's no great problem for many planes of this era to take the wings off and crate them up...more particularly fighters that are small and fairly simple of course, but even B-26 Marauders were crated for shipment to the Sth Pacific - essentially anything that couldn't be fitted with enough tanks to fly long distances over water had to be crated up and shipped.
 
In many cases howe4ver the a/c were shipped as deck cargo withotu crating - eg see teh photo of P47's at http://home.att.net/~historyzone/Seversky-Republic5.html

RE: Wish: Loading plane units on cargo ships

Posted: Mon Nov 05, 2007 2:54 pm
by seille
Thanks SMK, exactly what i wanted to say.
Such transfers are realistic and were often used during WW2.
Especially for the lend lease help to Murmansk.
 
I can remember very good on a list what was destroyed by the germans when they attacked
PQ17. Lot´s of planes went down with the cargo ships.
I cannot built the VERY expensive CV´s just to TRANSPORT planes.

RE: Wish: Loading plane units on cargo ships

Posted: Mon Nov 05, 2007 3:14 pm
by Vic
@seille,
 
the engine can not make difference between aircraft as cargo and as active aircraft on carrier. in practice it would mean you could keep filling an aircraft carrier from ships stored on cargo planes. unless i change the engine radically, but i dont think this is important enough. :)
 
so the easy way around is just to use strategic or normal transfer to get those aircraft to murmansk.
 
kind regards,
vic
 

RE: Wish: Loading plane units on cargo ships

Posted: Mon Nov 05, 2007 3:24 pm
by seille
Yes Vic, as i already wrote i expected already a rule in the way to realize that wish.
In my case it´s that i wish to evacuate England and want to move my units (including planes)
down to the MED. And this is impossible with normal transfers or movement. For strategic transfers over that distance
i would need tons of cargo ships. So there is no way :(
 
Maybe you can code something like a "container" for the air units which allows a transport on cargo ships ?
A container that removes the attribute "air unit" for the time of the transfer ?
There must be a easy solution without making a new game or do drastic changes.
You´re the specialist here. I bet you would find a easy way to code this if you want [;)]