Page 1 of 1

Modular editing /masterfiles

Posted: Thu Nov 15, 2007 12:36 pm
by PDiFolco
I've tried to work on a couple mods :
- Adding a couple new SFtypes - SP Arty, Assault Guns..
- Using a graphics mod (Rick69 sent me a version of its mod)
In each case I just wanted to change some and add some things, but use most of the standard masterfile untouched
And each time I've had problems doing something reliable, because either you directly change the masterfile - then you have a "concurrent" version of the standard game's one, that won't be updated when Vic makes patches- or you have to make a scenario, but then nothing is reusable...

What I think would be a good solution would be to be able to load modular parts of a masterfile : currently you can switch on/off the loading of Peoples, but that's all.
If the same option was possible for SFTypes, Land, etc... then it would be relatively easy to maintain mods that change only one or couple game objects categories (ie terrain, loctypes,...).
A second requirement would be that masterfile loading be only "up to" what is in : if for example the masterfile has SFTypes 1 to 99, and I make a SFType100, it should be kept.
Third, as already requested, things in a pt2 file should be tagged as copied from masterfile or locally modified, with scenario changes not overriden when reloading a masterfile.
The tag should be editable to put the item back to "standard" if needed.

Another way to go may be to allow import/export of XML (or whatever format) files that will also clearly help when trying to change for example att/def modifiers tables.
At least a big dump of a pt2 file would be useful to check things without opening umpteenth windows.

I hope this makes sense and would eventually be possible in an upcoming patch ... [;)]

RE: Modular editing /masterfiles

Posted: Thu Nov 15, 2007 5:52 pm
by rickier65
From what I've seen in the masterfile, and in the editor, there is a lot A LOT of interelated elements. While I'm sure Vic could sort through it all and make it modular, the potential for problems would seem to be pretty large (risk vs return).

If things develop as they appear to doing with the gaming commnuity, it looks like there will be a lot of community support for this game. We've already had some tutorials from Vic, as well as from TWeber, and some documentation aids from GJK. The game is only couple of weeks old -- so I'm hoping this means we'll see a lot more along the lines of design guides, etc. and not just from the developer.

I really like the idea of getting a xml dump that would be very nice for studying design techniques. Of course it might also be used for those wanting to get a competitive edge. Now I'm rambling.

The editor itself is a lot more complex that I first though. I'm still trying to get my head around it, simply by poking at different parts. I've just about decided to make a structural diagram to see if that helps.

I'm all for making the change you suggest PD, but I'd recommend doing it only after lots of testing (and then some more testing).

Rick

RE: Modular editing /masterfiles

Posted: Fri Nov 16, 2007 9:43 am
by NickGen
Hey pdiFolco....
My pseudo is not rick69 but nick69 ... lol[/align]

RE: Modular editing /masterfiles

Posted: Fri Nov 16, 2007 10:24 am
by PDiFolco
Oops apologies Nick69 [&o] !