Page 1 of 1
Sample Lineups
Posted: Wed Nov 12, 2008 1:06 pm
by Old Coach
I have uploaded a spreadsheet file listed as Sample Lineup to FBMAX. It includes 2 lineups with player ratings. The teams are 1948 New York Giants and 1940 Tennessee Volunteers. Both lineups are on the same spreadsheet. Download and unzip. Maybe this will help or at least you might find them interesting to look at.
Old Coach
RE: Sample Lineups
Posted: Thu Nov 13, 2008 11:18 pm
by Old Coach
There's a lot of hits on this thread, but no responses. Has anyone downloaded the sample lineups and if so are they helpful? I'll be happy to answer questions about how I arrived at my ratings. This ratings "system" that I use for MaxFB is the same one I used with FBPRO98. Seems to work well. I also actually used it to assign ratings when I dabbled with Madden 2002 & 2005 and also with NCAA 2004. Worked OK there too.
Old Coach
RE: Sample Lineups
Posted: Fri Nov 14, 2008 2:06 am
by bobcat200
Have been enjoying everything you've been posting on the site. I would be interested in the sytem you use to create your teams.
Bobcat 200
RE: Sample Lineups
Posted: Fri Nov 14, 2008 4:14 am
by DreamTeams
I'd like to know, as well. Also if you do anything to your constants file?
RE: Sample Lineups
Posted: Fri Nov 14, 2008 6:14 am
by DONMVP
it dose look good
RE: Sample Lineups
Posted: Sat Nov 15, 2008 1:13 pm
by Old Coach
Sorry it took me so long to respond. ON FBMAX in the "Tips, Charts, Diagrams, Etc" section you can find my Player Ratings Chart. That file's been there since March of 2006. As to the constants file in the game, the only modification I make is with placekick accuracy. For Pro leagues like my CFL or 1948 NFL, I leave it at 30. For 1964 College I increase it to 31 to reflect less accuracy and in really old school college leagues like 1940 College or 1933 SEC (under construction) I set the value to 32. If you look at the sample lineup sheet, you'll see that the placekicker has an KACC rating in the mid 60 to low 70 range. I have a separate ineup slot for my kickoff man. His numbers are KSTR in the 90's and KACC also in the 90"s to get a long, staright kickoff.
Old Coach
RE: Sample Lineups
Posted: Tue Dec 02, 2008 8:07 pm
by regenerator
Two Questions, Coach -
1) Don't you get a lot of missed field goals with these settings? I understand you're playing a more old-fashioned style of football with those teams, but I wouldn't expect, based on what I've seen, to see hardly any field goals made outside of 30-yards. From what I've observed, MaxFB kickers have a hard time hitting 40-yarders even with Kicking Strength in the 90's. They always fall short.
2) I've looked at your "Speed and Strength" doc many times, which you say is your basis for ratings. However, a quick glance seems to indicate that the rosters don't match up much with the Ratings Guide. You have OL weighing 216 pounds with 90 str - according to the ratings guide, max str with that weight is 77. Also, I see several offensive linemen with Speed of 80, supposed to be reserved for "Freaks". Not trying to be critical, honestly, just wondering if maybe I missed something, or am looking at the wrong document.
I'm just trying to find the best systems to optimize this game!
RE: Sample Lineups
Posted: Tue Dec 02, 2008 9:40 pm
by Old Coach
In reference to the strength table and player weights, I have gotten away from that relationship.
MaxFB uses a formula that includes player weight to determine if a tackle is made or broken or who wins the fight between a blocker and a defender. According to David, other games don't work out these situations with weight as a factor. A way to look at it is that MaxFB works with player momentum and force which is a function of player weight. A 160lb WR can be very strong but he still can't out muscle a 260lb DL because he doesn't have the mass. The little WR with an STR of 85 may have similar muscular strength to the 260lb lineman with an STR of 85, but his ability to actually move a large object (big lineman) would be much less due to lack of mass. The 160lb WR with STR or 85 might be able to break the tackle of a 180lb DB with an STR of 75. The chart is a guide but I'm more inclined to use the Old Coach "Fudge Factor" assigning ratings.
An All-Conference level 6'2", 185lb WR might have these ratings: SPD 86, STR, 85, AGI 80, INT 85, END 85, BLK 90, Cat 80, Hnd 60.
The average 6'2" 185 WR might have ratings: SPD 84, STR, 78, AGI 78, INT 80, END 80, BLK 85, Cat 78, Hnd 55.
The bottom tier 6'2", 185 WR might have ratings of: SPD 82, STR, 73, AGI 75, INT 75, END 75, BLK 75, Cat 70, Hnd 50.
These ratings have a level of subjectivity to them but they do fall within definite perameters. Have I helped or have I muddied the waters further?
That table worked much better with Madden and NCAA Football games then it does with MaxFB. Actually, I developed the table with the EA Sports games in mind and continued using it with MaxFB until I changed my philosophy about assigning STR ratings.
Old Coach
RE: Sample Lineups
Posted: Tue Dec 02, 2008 9:51 pm
by Old Coach
As to the placekicker ratings, yes, my field goal PCT is low with my 1940 NCAA league. I actually don't attempt that many FG's because they simply didn't kick many back then. I get a higher than normal number of failed PAT's, but that is what I was looking for to reflect the state of placekicking in that era. In my 1964 College league, the placekick accuracy is set to 31 in the constant file. My PK's KS and KA ratings are a bit higher to reflect a greater proficiency. In Pro level leagues, the constant is set to the stock rating of 30 and the PK ratings are set higher to reflect Pro ability. Another factor to consider with Pro level leagues is the placement of the goal post on either the goal line or end line. I play a Canadian rules league and 1948 NFL in which the goal post is set on the goal line. You may need to tweak the PK constant value and your PK's KS and KA ratings until you get the accuracy and distance you want.
Old Coach
RE: Sample Lineups
Posted: Tue Dec 02, 2008 10:08 pm
by Old Coach
Bobcat 200 wrote: I would be interested in the sytem you use to create your teams.
Actually, I'd be interested to know what system I use too. In my previous posts to answer Regenerator's questions, I tried to explain my "system", but now
I'm confused as to what I do. I guess the thing is, whatever "system" you use to give you the results you want, use it. What I have finally figured out is that a rigid system doesn't work that well. There has to be some fudge factor, subjectivity, whatever you want to call it to get desired results. As long as you set perameters for high and low values in each of the ratings catagories and then assign those ratings according to some scale to create the good, bad and ugly players in your league, you should get good results.
Old Coach