Hey NOOB! This AAR is for you.
Posted: Wed Jun 24, 2009 11:46 pm
Consider the plight of the unknowing innocent who purchases this game, takes it home, fires it up, plugs through the tutorial, and then begins a campaign. Suddenly, without warning, he finds himself at the base of a tall and forbidding learning cliff. After much effort he manages to reach the top and then is introduced to the learning mountain, and behind that, an endless series of learning peaks stretching out to the horizon. The prudent buyer would then shut down the game, box it up nicely, send it off as a present to his worst enemy, and settle for Jackstraws.
Some of the more persistent NOOBs will find themselves at this forum where their questions will be promptly and politely answered. In addition, they will be advised to check out the "Must Read" thread, and to read some of the AARs. The must reads are very helpful and kudos to those who helped to prepare them. The AARs, on the other hand, aren't much use to the NOOB. Here are some reasons why:
1 - Most of the time AAR players and the NOOB are playing entirely different games. The AAR guys might be playing the muscovite version of the humsford mod as ammended by Tagisaki, while the NOOB is playing stock 15.
2 - The AAR will describe what has happened, but for security reasons, won't go into detail about future operations, the planning and preparation for these operations, and the reasons why they are to be carried out. The sort of stuff that would be most helpful to NOOBs
3 - Some players are (what's the word for super skilled?) They are so good that the NOOB can't comprehend it. Something like:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Super player A - "Aha! signet has just reported finding a Prince Albert tobacco tin floating off island A. Since everyone knows that 2nd officer Smith, the assistant laundry officer of BB Repulsive, prefers this tobacco, it is elementary, my dear Kubatchi, that an enemy force consisting of CV Whatitsname, Repulsive, 7 destroyers, and the Duke of Wartshire's own 32nd Messtin Repair Battalion will arrive off island B at 0817 tomorrow. Prepare force D to intercept."
Super Player B - "Aha! They've fallen for the old "floating Prince Albert tobacco tin" trick. We can expect enemy force D to arrive at island B at or around 0817 tomorrow. Prepare force F to intercept"
Super Player A - "Aha! etc etc
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
It seems to me that what is needed is an AAR aimed at the NOOB. Ideally, this AAR would be composed by someone who knows the game, and is capable of creating a clearly written and helpful walkthrough type AAR. That would be the ideal. Unfortunately, I don't see any hands raised. I've only had the game for about six months, so it'll be another few years before I can be expected to know how to play this game, and my writing skills are questionable, but I do like to bloviate, so I'm going to give it a shot. With a little luck and, hopefully, some help from the old salts I might end up with a semi-legible stumblethrough.
I've consulted with the AI and we've agreed on HR
1 - Units within a command must be assigned to that command. Exceptions are US units staging in CONUS, Hawaii, and OZ/NZ
2 - US Ground troops and fighter aircraft not to evacuate PI
3 - No evacuation of Dutch units from DEI.
4 - Whatever else comes to mind.
5 - In China I am going to adopt a policy of benign neglect and hope the Japanese do likewise
and away we go
[center]Prelude Pearl Harbor[/center]
It's the first weekend since payday and everyone who can has gone on liberty. Some servicemen choose to visit museums, art galleries, and other cultural attractions. Some hang out at the beach. Others admire the quaint architecture of some of the buildings lining downtown Hotel Street and spend their time (and money) there.
There has been some speculation about the possibility of war with Japan, but most believe, that if war does come, the Japanese will strike the Philippines first. Nevertheless, precautions have been taken to prevent sabotage by Japanese aliens. Additional sentinels have been stationed at vital points such as bridges, airfields, and other military installations. Particular care has been taken to secure aircraft by parking them close together making it easier for the sentinels to keep a watchful eye upon them.
[center]Prelude Philippines[/center]
Analysis of Japanese capabilities as of 1 July 1940
"The enemy will send an expedition of about 100,000 men to capture Manila and its harbor defenses in order to occupy the Philippines, sever the American line of communications, and deny the United States a naval base in the Far East. It is expected that this operation will be undertaken with the greatest secrecy and that it will precede or coincide with a declaration of war. The garrison therefore can expect little or no warning. The attack will probably come during the dry season, shortly after the rice crop is harvested, in December or January. The enemy is assumed to have extensive knowledge of the terrain and of American strength and dispositions, and will probably be assisted by the 30,000 Japanese in the Islands."
Gen. Marshall to Gen MacArthur 9 Sep 1941
"I have directed that United States Army Forces in the Philippines be placed in highest priority for equipment including authorized defensive reserves for fifty thousand men."
The Philippine department is acutely aware that war could break out at any moment and are working feverishly to prepare the Islands' defense. The Chief of Staff, General Marshall, has given the Department the highest priority and thousands of reinforcements, mountains of supplies, and hundreds of aircraft are on the way.
The induction of the Philippine Army reserve divisions was begun on 1 September 1941, and is expected to be completed by the middle of December. Training these units have begun, but many difficulties have been encountered due to equipment and personal shortages. Consider the 31st PA Division:
Personal
One regiment, the 31st Infantry was mobilized on September 1 and is in camp.
A second regiment, the 32nd Infantry was inducted on 1 Nov but did not join the Div until 6 December.
The third regiment, the 33rd Infantry began arriving in camp on 25 November.
The medical battalion, motor transport, service and division headquarters companies were mobilized between 18 and 30 November. Signal company was organized on 1 December.
The 31st Field Artillery Regiment has not yet been mobilized
Equipment
Every man has a rifle, a .30 caliber Enfield. The stock is often too long for the Philippine soldier and the extractors, for which there are no replacements, often break.
Each infantry company has 1 BAR.
Each machine gun company has 8 .30 caliber water-cooled guns
Each infantry regiment has two .50 caliber machine guns and six 3 inch mortars.
Artillery for the division consists of 8 75mm guns which were delivered to the division on the evening of 7 December, without sights or fire control equipment.
Total Divisional Transport
Sedan x 1
Command car x 2
Bantam car x 1
1 1/2 Ton Truck x 9
Despite all these problems, it is believed that the Philippine Army can be made fully operational by April 1942.
[center]Prelude Malaya-Singapore[/center]
Commander of 2nd Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders to General Brooke-Popham
"I do hope, sir, we are not getting too strong in Malaya because if so the Japanese may never attempt a landing"
On 29 November the War Office in London passed on to Air Chief-Marshal Brooke-Popham at Singapore the contents of a message they had just received from the RAF's delegation in Washington.
"Joint planning staff have been informed verbally this afternoon by War Plans Division War Department that US Army Commanders in Far East have been informed that Japanese negotiations have reached stage where their final breakdown or offensive action by Japan against Thailand, Netherlands East Indies or Philippines may be expected at any time. USA commanders have been instructed to await offensive move by Japanese and carefully avoid overt action on their own part."
British commanders have taken this message seriously and, on 1 December, mobilized the Volunteer Forces in Malaya. Daily RAF reconnaissance sorties are being flown deep into the Gulf of Siam and the South China Sea.
In general, British commanders are somewhat optimistic despite the shortfalls of air and sea power. The Japanese Army is, after all, an unknown quantity, and certainly hasn't distinguished itself in China. Its logistical support is suspect and the British feel that a stout defence in Malaya can keep the Japanese at bay until reinforcements arrive.
[center]Prelude Dutch East Indies[/center]
There are 40,000 Dutch troops stationed in the DEI. This force is backed up by about 100,000 colonial troops. They have occupied the DEI for 350 years, consider it their second homeland, and will fight to the finish to preserve it.
Wonder what's going to happen tomorrow?
Some of the more persistent NOOBs will find themselves at this forum where their questions will be promptly and politely answered. In addition, they will be advised to check out the "Must Read" thread, and to read some of the AARs. The must reads are very helpful and kudos to those who helped to prepare them. The AARs, on the other hand, aren't much use to the NOOB. Here are some reasons why:
1 - Most of the time AAR players and the NOOB are playing entirely different games. The AAR guys might be playing the muscovite version of the humsford mod as ammended by Tagisaki, while the NOOB is playing stock 15.
2 - The AAR will describe what has happened, but for security reasons, won't go into detail about future operations, the planning and preparation for these operations, and the reasons why they are to be carried out. The sort of stuff that would be most helpful to NOOBs
3 - Some players are (what's the word for super skilled?) They are so good that the NOOB can't comprehend it. Something like:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Super player A - "Aha! signet has just reported finding a Prince Albert tobacco tin floating off island A. Since everyone knows that 2nd officer Smith, the assistant laundry officer of BB Repulsive, prefers this tobacco, it is elementary, my dear Kubatchi, that an enemy force consisting of CV Whatitsname, Repulsive, 7 destroyers, and the Duke of Wartshire's own 32nd Messtin Repair Battalion will arrive off island B at 0817 tomorrow. Prepare force D to intercept."
Super Player B - "Aha! They've fallen for the old "floating Prince Albert tobacco tin" trick. We can expect enemy force D to arrive at island B at or around 0817 tomorrow. Prepare force F to intercept"
Super Player A - "Aha! etc etc
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
It seems to me that what is needed is an AAR aimed at the NOOB. Ideally, this AAR would be composed by someone who knows the game, and is capable of creating a clearly written and helpful walkthrough type AAR. That would be the ideal. Unfortunately, I don't see any hands raised. I've only had the game for about six months, so it'll be another few years before I can be expected to know how to play this game, and my writing skills are questionable, but I do like to bloviate, so I'm going to give it a shot. With a little luck and, hopefully, some help from the old salts I might end up with a semi-legible stumblethrough.
I've consulted with the AI and we've agreed on HR
1 - Units within a command must be assigned to that command. Exceptions are US units staging in CONUS, Hawaii, and OZ/NZ
2 - US Ground troops and fighter aircraft not to evacuate PI
3 - No evacuation of Dutch units from DEI.
4 - Whatever else comes to mind.
5 - In China I am going to adopt a policy of benign neglect and hope the Japanese do likewise
and away we go
[center]Prelude Pearl Harbor[/center]
It's the first weekend since payday and everyone who can has gone on liberty. Some servicemen choose to visit museums, art galleries, and other cultural attractions. Some hang out at the beach. Others admire the quaint architecture of some of the buildings lining downtown Hotel Street and spend their time (and money) there.
There has been some speculation about the possibility of war with Japan, but most believe, that if war does come, the Japanese will strike the Philippines first. Nevertheless, precautions have been taken to prevent sabotage by Japanese aliens. Additional sentinels have been stationed at vital points such as bridges, airfields, and other military installations. Particular care has been taken to secure aircraft by parking them close together making it easier for the sentinels to keep a watchful eye upon them.
[center]Prelude Philippines[/center]
Analysis of Japanese capabilities as of 1 July 1940
"The enemy will send an expedition of about 100,000 men to capture Manila and its harbor defenses in order to occupy the Philippines, sever the American line of communications, and deny the United States a naval base in the Far East. It is expected that this operation will be undertaken with the greatest secrecy and that it will precede or coincide with a declaration of war. The garrison therefore can expect little or no warning. The attack will probably come during the dry season, shortly after the rice crop is harvested, in December or January. The enemy is assumed to have extensive knowledge of the terrain and of American strength and dispositions, and will probably be assisted by the 30,000 Japanese in the Islands."
Gen. Marshall to Gen MacArthur 9 Sep 1941
"I have directed that United States Army Forces in the Philippines be placed in highest priority for equipment including authorized defensive reserves for fifty thousand men."
The Philippine department is acutely aware that war could break out at any moment and are working feverishly to prepare the Islands' defense. The Chief of Staff, General Marshall, has given the Department the highest priority and thousands of reinforcements, mountains of supplies, and hundreds of aircraft are on the way.
The induction of the Philippine Army reserve divisions was begun on 1 September 1941, and is expected to be completed by the middle of December. Training these units have begun, but many difficulties have been encountered due to equipment and personal shortages. Consider the 31st PA Division:
Personal
One regiment, the 31st Infantry was mobilized on September 1 and is in camp.
A second regiment, the 32nd Infantry was inducted on 1 Nov but did not join the Div until 6 December.
The third regiment, the 33rd Infantry began arriving in camp on 25 November.
The medical battalion, motor transport, service and division headquarters companies were mobilized between 18 and 30 November. Signal company was organized on 1 December.
The 31st Field Artillery Regiment has not yet been mobilized
Equipment
Every man has a rifle, a .30 caliber Enfield. The stock is often too long for the Philippine soldier and the extractors, for which there are no replacements, often break.
Each infantry company has 1 BAR.
Each machine gun company has 8 .30 caliber water-cooled guns
Each infantry regiment has two .50 caliber machine guns and six 3 inch mortars.
Artillery for the division consists of 8 75mm guns which were delivered to the division on the evening of 7 December, without sights or fire control equipment.
Total Divisional Transport
Sedan x 1
Command car x 2
Bantam car x 1
1 1/2 Ton Truck x 9
Despite all these problems, it is believed that the Philippine Army can be made fully operational by April 1942.
[center]Prelude Malaya-Singapore[/center]
Commander of 2nd Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders to General Brooke-Popham
"I do hope, sir, we are not getting too strong in Malaya because if so the Japanese may never attempt a landing"
On 29 November the War Office in London passed on to Air Chief-Marshal Brooke-Popham at Singapore the contents of a message they had just received from the RAF's delegation in Washington.
"Joint planning staff have been informed verbally this afternoon by War Plans Division War Department that US Army Commanders in Far East have been informed that Japanese negotiations have reached stage where their final breakdown or offensive action by Japan against Thailand, Netherlands East Indies or Philippines may be expected at any time. USA commanders have been instructed to await offensive move by Japanese and carefully avoid overt action on their own part."
British commanders have taken this message seriously and, on 1 December, mobilized the Volunteer Forces in Malaya. Daily RAF reconnaissance sorties are being flown deep into the Gulf of Siam and the South China Sea.
In general, British commanders are somewhat optimistic despite the shortfalls of air and sea power. The Japanese Army is, after all, an unknown quantity, and certainly hasn't distinguished itself in China. Its logistical support is suspect and the British feel that a stout defence in Malaya can keep the Japanese at bay until reinforcements arrive.
[center]Prelude Dutch East Indies[/center]
There are 40,000 Dutch troops stationed in the DEI. This force is backed up by about 100,000 colonial troops. They have occupied the DEI for 350 years, consider it their second homeland, and will fight to the finish to preserve it.
Wonder what's going to happen tomorrow?
[/center]
[/center]
[/center]
[/center]
[/center]
[/center]
[/center]
[/center]
[/center]
[/center]
[/center]

[/center]
