Page 1 of 1

Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Fri Oct 02, 2009 7:27 pm
by witpqs
I've noticed that Amphib HQ's do not load fully on AGC's. There are several support squads left over, and they remain the parent while the loaded portion is a fragment. Additional commands to load the remainder are greeted with a message like "can load only one LCU per ship!" or some such.

Is this a known issue already repaired for patch 2?

RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Fri Oct 02, 2009 11:36 pm
by Halsey
I've noticed it too...

The AGC's can handle 2500 capacity, and the HQ's are 2700.

Don't know if it's being fixed.

Post this in the naval thread for Don.[;)]

RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2009 2:18 am
by P.Hausser
Just use 2 AGC's...



RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2009 8:57 am
by Halsey
True, but only the one with the parent unit will give you the HQ shift in amph assaults.

RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2009 10:19 am
by Sardaukar
Somewhat easy fix....increase AGC capacity. Might even make it into Patch 02. [8D]

RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2009 1:47 pm
by witpqs
ORIGINAL: Halsey

The AGC's can handle 2500 capacity, and the HQ's are 2700.

IIRC, in WITP the capacity was also less but there must have been some special code because the whole unit fit anyway.

ORIGINAL: Sardaukar

Somewhat easy fix....increase AGC capacity. Might even make it into Patch 02. [8D]

With this thread I'm hoping to find out if this issue is already fixed for patch 2 or if they need save games

RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2009 1:56 pm
by Gary D
As important as these HQ units are I do not think I would like to load them all on to one ship. For now using two ships to load, then sending the parent off to work while I split the loaded TF and unload the non parent fragment back into the original base seems ok from my POV.

RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2009 2:00 pm
by witpqs
ORIGINAL: Gary D

As important as these HQ units are I do not think I would like to load them all on to one ship. For now using two ships to load, then sending the parent off to work while I split the loaded TF and unload the non parent fragment back into the original base seems ok from my POV.

As a work-around loading on two ships is fine, but putting part of the unit safely ashore while the other part provides the benefits would be gamely in a PBM.

RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2009 4:20 pm
by Halsey
ORIGINAL: Gary D

As important as these HQ units are I do not think I would like to load them all on to one ship. For now using two ships to load, then sending the parent off to work while I split the loaded TF and unload the non parent fragment back into the original base seems ok from my POV.


True...

This could save a fragment for rebuild if the parent goes down with the ship.

RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2009 12:57 pm
by witpqs
ORIGINAL: witpqs

I've noticed that Amphib HQ's do not load fully on AGC's. There are several support squads left over, and they remain the parent while the loaded portion is a fragment. Additional commands to load the remainder are greeted with a message like "can load only one LCU per ship!" or some such.

Is this a known issue already repaired for patch 2?

Bump for devs...

RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2009 1:33 pm
by Sardaukar
Might be beneficial to mention this in Naval Issues sticky, devs tend to view that regularly. Well, did it for you. [8D]

RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2009 1:41 pm
by witpqs
ORIGINAL: Sardaukar

Might be beneficial to mention this in Naval Issues sticky, devs tend to view that regularly. Well, did it for you. [8D]

I know you're right, I was just trying to keep that cleaner for them until I confirmed if it's an outstanding issue. I didn't want to make more clutter for something that was solved but I just missed in some other thread.

Thanks.

RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2009 1:43 pm
by Sardaukar
ORIGINAL: witpqs

ORIGINAL: Sardaukar

Might be beneficial to mention this in Naval Issues sticky, devs tend to view that regularly. Well, did it for you. [8D]

I know you're right, I was just trying to keep that cleaner for them until I confirmed if it's an outstanding issue. I didn't want to make more clutter for something that was solved but I just missed in some other thread.

Thanks.

I think it's an issue, probably minor one, but still an issue. It might get pushed to Patch 03, though. [8D]

RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2009 3:34 pm
by JWE
ORIGINAL: witpqs
ORIGINAL: Sardaukar
Might be beneficial to mention this in Naval Issues sticky, devs tend to view that regularly. Well, did it for you. [8D]
I know you're right, I was just trying to keep that cleaner for them until I confirmed if it's an outstanding issue. I didn't want to make more clutter for something that was solved but I just missed in some other thread.

Thanks.
No worries, the implementation is indeed different from WiTP, so can understand how it might be a concern. This was discussed, believe it or not, and it gets even more quirky when you throw in those USCG PGs that got converted to AGCs and have doo-doo for 'capacity'. Here's the answer I posted for Sardaukar in the issues thread.

-- I see where people suggest using 2 or more AGCs to solve this. I don’t think there is anything wrong with that approach. The idea behind the AGC is to host a HQ unit that provides command and control (combat modifiers) to invasion units. The operational part of a Corps HQ ain’t really all that big.

In the game, an HQ LCU provides lots of other functions and is fairly large in terms of device/squad content, most of which have little bearing on the C&C functions. So why not split it up? And why shouldn’t any HQ fragment eventually rebuild? Even if Howlin Mad got whacked, it wouldn’t make his Corps HQ disappear – somebody would step up, maybe Navy TF and/or MC divisional staff would wear two hats for a while, but them slots gonna be filled.

Unless there is something else going on, I see no issue with landing a fragment, getting the parent whacked, and then promoting the fragment to parent. So, in my poor, stupid sense of things, I would probably resist increasing the “capacity” of an AGC, or reducing the “load cost” of an HQ LCU, so long as there is the option to load the HQ on multiple AGCs.

I really hope this helps.

RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2009 4:04 pm
by witpqs
It does help. I guess that it's now coming down to developer intent. By that I mean that we've got here a game (simulation for those of us who are interested in the historical capabilities aspect of it) that, of course, can only seek to approximate real life situations. To keep the flavor of things and get the best out of the simulation I try to go with the program on technicalities instead of gaming the system. Trying out various strategies, etc. is fair game - because that's the whole point! But I want to paint within the lines on technicalities.

So... it sounds like yous guys (developers, et al) are still hashing out the intent on how to handle AGC's. I'm basing that on what you just wrote about the matter still being discussed and maybe somewhat up in the air (my choice of words). Will you give us more guidance on intent by the time patch 2 comes out? (Or, have I misunderstood?!)

RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2009 4:39 pm
by JWE
ORIGINAL: witpqs
So... it sounds like yous guys (developers, et al) are still hashing out the intent on how to handle AGC's. I'm basing that on what you just wrote about the matter still being discussed and maybe somewhat up in the air (my choice of words). Will you give us more guidance on intent by the time patch 2 comes out? (Or, have I misunderstood?!)
No, we're not still hashing. We had a major bagel nosh back when we included the USCG Treasury conversions to AGCs, long, long ago, understanding their 'capacity' didn't cut it, so what the hey. We worked the alternatives, and found them reasonable and conceptually valid, and came up with the noted justifications, so didn't think there was an insoluable problem.

It's not up in the air, it has a conceptual basis. And please don't blame 'developers, et al', I must admit it's my winkie on the table for this one, so I am your Huckelberry. I think it works, although it works in a different fashion than you are used to in WiTP, but think it works within the conceptual framework of what we are trying to accomplish.

Will always listen to 'issues', but hope ya'll can get to the concept. Will do my best to explain "why" it is as it is. Ciao. John

RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2009 4:48 pm
by witpqs
OK, cool. Wasn't 'blaming' devs or anybody, just deferring to whoever is the root of the design intent for the matter at hand.

To summarize: In WITP, there was a (stated) intent of exactly one amphib HQ per AGC. In AE no such intention. Load an amphib HQ up on 2 AGC's if that's what it takes.

[8D]

RE: Loading Amphib HQ on AGC

Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2009 5:01 pm
by JWE
ORIGINAL: witpqs
Load an amphib HQ up on 2 AGC's if that's what it takes.
[8D]
(on 2 AGC's, "or more", if that's what it takes) On the nosey! [;)]

Not to say issues with this won't be considered, but don't really see any "issues" just yet. J