Page 1 of 1

Is repair quicker when docked or disbanded

Posted: Wed Jul 10, 2002 4:12 pm
by v.Manstein
I frequently visit this forum but I didn`t catch this:
Is it quicker to repair the ships when the TF is docked, or disband them as soon as they arrive at port. I know, port size matters but I am talking about a TF in one specific port.
What are your experiences?:)

Posted: Wed Jul 10, 2002 4:15 pm
by Spooky
Repair is quicker when the damaged ship is anchored rather than docked - so you need to disband the damaged ship TF.

Spooky

Posted: Wed Jul 10, 2002 4:19 pm
by v.Manstein
Thanks, Spooky.

Posted: Wed Jul 10, 2002 8:06 pm
by corbulo
I have wondered that as well. thanks for the answer. I have also noticed that system damage drops about 1 point for every 2 days at Rabaul. I believe it is Port(8).

Posted: Wed Jul 10, 2002 8:14 pm
by Spooky
Originally posted by corbulo
I have wondered that as well. thanks for the answer. I have also noticed that system damage drops about 1 point for every 2 days at Rabaul. I believe it is Port(8).
In fact, the smaller the ship, the quicker the repair :)

A DD or APD with a 40 System damage can easily be repaired in Rabaul or Truk while to repair a CV or BB with the same level of damage in these ports will take a very long time ...

Spooky

Posted: Wed Jul 10, 2002 8:34 pm
by v.Manstein
The thing is that I have a CV with 17 system damage sitting disbanded in my port in Cairns. It took 2 weeks to knock off about 3 sys damage and I was just wondering, what would have been more efficient.

That's pretty good, in my experience

Posted: Wed Jul 10, 2002 8:58 pm
by Armorer
Greetings,

2 weeks to knock off 3 sys damage is an excellent rate of repair, from what I've seen. In one of my previous games, I put Hornet in L'ville on 1 December with 15 points of sys damage. By 1 March, she was down to 12 points. Repairing capital ships in-theater, even if only slightly damaged, has been excruciatingly slow, in my experience.

By the way, L'ville was a fully developed, size 9 port, with 300k+ supplies, for the duration of the time mentioned, and Hornet sat and did nothing the entire time. Just in case anyone was curious.

Regards,
Randy

Sprockets

Posted: Wed Jul 10, 2002 9:24 pm
by mogami
Hi, During the DEC- March time period there was an acute shortage of Sprockets in Pacific area depots.

Also in short supply were:
Grid Squares
Gun Target Line
Frequency Grease.
Sweat pumps
Main Deduction Gears
reversable Zenor Diodes
left handed monkey wrench

Re: Sprockets

Posted: Wed Jul 10, 2002 10:33 pm
by Admiral DadMan
Originally posted by Mogami
Hi, During the DEC- March time period there was an acute shortage of Sprockets in Pacific area depots.

Also in short supply were:
Grid Squares
Gun Target Line
Frequency Grease.
Sweat pumps
Main Deduction Gears
reversable Zenor Diodes
left handed monkey wrench
and a left handed spanner...

What, no chewing gum and tin foil?

Re: Sprockets

Posted: Wed Jul 10, 2002 11:12 pm
by dgaad
Originally posted by Mogami
Hi, During the DEC- March time period there was an acute shortage of Sprockets in Pacific area depots.

Also in short supply were:
Grid Squares
Gun Target Line
Frequency Grease.
Sweat pumps
Main Deduction Gears
reversable Zenor Diodes
left handed monkey wrench
Dieter would be very upset. "You have become boring . . . " "Would you like to touch my monkey?"

Re: Sprockets

Posted: Wed Jul 10, 2002 11:30 pm
by tanjman
Originally posted by Mogami
Hi, During the DEC- March time period there was an acute shortage of Sprockets in Pacific area depots.

Also in short supply were:
Grid Squares
Gun Target Line
Frequency Grease.
Sweat pumps
Main Deduction Gears
reversable Zenor Diodes
left handed monkey wrench
:D Mogami, you forgot

Relative Bearing Grease
Fallopian Tubing
Bosun Punches
Transit Lines
and last but not least
WOMEN!

Experience with size 2 ports

Posted: Thu Jul 11, 2002 3:53 am
by wpurdom
My experience is that ships with over 70 flotation damage docked in a size 2 port will tend to get worse. What is others' experience? Anchored in a size 3 port they always get better.
Does the rating of the naval commander of the task force affect the repairs of the ship? If so, what is the critical rating? I replayed a damage situation once with Wilkinson in command after having the ship commander did with it and it seemed to make a difference but that may have been random variation.
Do people playing PBEM games think it is kosher to go into the editor to sheck out co's full ratings?