Page 1 of 2
CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Thu Jun 09, 2011 10:07 pm
by Numdydar
In 12/42 two CSs (Mizuho and Nisshin) can convert to CVLs. I happened to have one in Tokyo and the other in Singapore on that date. The one in Tokyo started conversion but the one in Singapore did not. Plenty of supplies in Singapore (30K+)
After a bit I sent the one from Singapore to Hiro as I could not figure out why it would not convert in Singapore as according to the upgrade requirements the Yard was big enough and as far as I knew 30K of supplies should be sufficent. So I get to Hiro (which has an even bigger yard than Singapore and even more supplies), and still no conversion. Leave it there for a bit as everyone knows that doing the same thing over and over again expecting a different result is the trait of a wise person [:D].
Finally come to my senses and get the damn thing to Tokyo where it starts the conversion the next turn with no problem. So here are my questions.
a) is there anywhere you are told that these two conversions HAVE to be done in Tokyo and no where else? All other conversions for other ship classes have worked fine in all sorts of different ports outside of Japan.
or
b) If the conversions can happen at other locations, what are the requirements needed as everything I could find told me I was fine in both Sinapore and Hiro?
Any help with this would be appriciated.
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Thu Jun 09, 2011 10:15 pm
by Don Bowen
There is a special condition for ships the CONVERT to carriers or battleships. The Conversion can be done in the Home Port (i.e. Tokyo) and a few other very large ports. Don't recall the exact limitation but Tokyo is best.
I believe this was an anti-cheat rule based on experience with WITP.
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Thu Jun 09, 2011 10:49 pm
by Numdydar
While good to know now lol, how would a new player be able to find this info out BEFORE they need to do a conversion?
Also I HAVE been able to convert CAs and below in non-home ports like Hong Kong, Singapore Shanghi, etc with no issues which is why this one took me by surprice. It was just by luck I had one of the two in Toyko. Otherwise, both would have been sailing around trying randomly [&:] to find a port that would allow them to convert.
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 12:15 am
by Shark7
ORIGINAL: Numdydar
While good to know now lol, how would a new player be able to find this info out BEFORE they need to do a conversion?
Also I HAVE been able to convert CAs and below in non-home ports like Hong Kong, Singapore Shanghi, etc with no issues which is why this one took me by surprice. It was just by luck I had one of the two in Toyko. Otherwise, both would have been sailing around trying randomly [&:] to find a port that would allow them to convert.
On most ships all you need is a repair shipyard of the appropriate size. However, some of the capital ships have special rules as Don pointed out. That's why your smaller ships can convert anywhere with a RSY (IE Singapore, Hong Kong, Shanghai, etc).
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 12:48 am
by Numdydar
Sure I get that, but as this is not in the manual (at least I couldn't find it) and other than posting the question here, is there anywhere else this information is to be found? Or is this just something that everyone has to find out on their own (which would really s*** btw)?
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 1:02 am
by John 3rd
Heck...I've had Chitose and Chiyoda sitting in Kobe for a month with no action. Guess I need to move them to Tokyo...
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 1:05 am
by Numdydar
I feel much better now that I am not alone [;)]
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 1:16 am
by John 3rd
I THOUGHT the Port and repair yard were plenty big enough! Crapppy. Will move them next turn!
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 1:27 am
by Shark7
ORIGINAL: John 3rd
Heck...I've had Chitose and Chiyoda sitting in Kobe for a month with no action. Guess I need to move them to Tokyo...
Just wagering a guess, but Tokyo, Osaka, or Kure seems like they would be good candidates for the conversions to take place. Yokosuka might work as well. These 4 places historically had large shipyards available (remember, Yamato and Musashi were fitted out in Kure).
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 2:18 am
by PaxMondo
The only place I know the CS will convert is Tokyo. There may be others, but I haven't found them yet.
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 1:50 pm
by John 3rd
We shall find out. I just moved my CS to Tokyo.
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 2:23 pm
by Chickenboy
ORIGINAL: Numdydar
In 12/42 two CSs (Mizuho and Nisshin) can convert to CVLs. I happened to have one in Tokyo and the other in Singapore on that date. The one in Tokyo started conversion but the one in Singapore did not. Plenty of supplies in Singapore (30K+)
After a bit I sent the one from Singapore to Hiro as I could not figure out why it would not convert in Singapore as according to the upgrade requirements the Yard was big enough and as far as I knew 30K of supplies should be sufficent. So I get to Hiro (which has an even bigger yard than Singapore and even more supplies), and still no conversion. Leave it there for a bit as everyone knows that doing the same thing over and over again expecting a different result is the trait of a wise person [:D].
Finally come to my senses and get the damn thing to Tokyo where it starts the conversion the next turn with no problem. So here are my questions.
a) is there anywhere you are told that these two conversions HAVE to be done in Tokyo and no where else? All other conversions for other ship classes have worked fine in all sorts of different ports outside of Japan.
or
b) If the conversions can happen at other locations, what are the requirements needed as everything I could find told me I was fine in both Sinapore and Hiro?
Any help with this would be appriciated.
Hi Numdyar,
I believe consensus on this is that
Mizuho and
Nisshin can be converted elsewhere in the Empire (with suitable port size, supply, naval support, etc.), but
Chitose and
Chiyoda seem to be hard coded to have to be done at Tokyo.
When in doubt, Tokyo will do it, but you may be able to get some of the others done elsewhere to spread the love (and the work!) around.
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 2:35 pm
by hunchback77
This is what I found in my notes guys. Conversions for the Chitose and Chiyoda are November. The Mizuho and Nishin are December. You need to have a minimum shipyard size of 50. And for the Chiyoda and Chitose you need to be in Tokyo.
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 4:21 pm
by herwin
ORIGINAL: hunchback77
This is what I found in my notes guys. Conversions for the Chitose and Chiyoda are November. The Mizuho and Nishin are December. You need to have a minimum shipyard size of 50. And for the Chiyoda and Chitose you need to be in Tokyo.
Instead of Yokosuka (Chiyoda) and Sasebo (Chitose)???
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 4:26 pm
by Chickenboy
ORIGINAL: herwin
ORIGINAL: hunchback77
This is what I found in my notes guys. Conversions for the Chitose and Chiyoda are November. The Mizuho and Nishin are December. You need to have a minimum shipyard size of 50. And for the Chiyoda and Chitose you need to be in Tokyo.
Instead of Yokosuka (Chiyoda) and Sasebo (Chitose)???
Herwin,
I tried to upgrade these two CS in Hiroshima, Kobe and Osaka-in that order. No joy. Only when moved to Tokyo did they 'take'. In my game, Hiroshima has the largest repair yard and the most naval support (and size 10 port). No reason it shouldn't have 'taken' there, unless it was hard coded for Tokyo. Others have reported something similar.
Without betraying too much OPSEC, I was able to upgrade the other two aforementioned CS elsewhere, not necessarily on the home islands either.
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 6:11 pm
by JWE
ORIGINAL: Chickenboy
I tried to upgrade these two CS in Hiroshima, Kobe and Osaka-in that order. No joy. Only when moved to Tokyo did they 'take'. In my game, Hiroshima has the largest repair yard and the most naval support (and size 10 port). No reason it shouldn't have 'taken' there, unless it was hard coded for Tokyo. Others have reported something similar.
Without betraying too much OPSEC, I was able to upgrade the other two aforementioned CS elsewhere, not necessarily on the home islands either.
Ok, minucious gallus domesticus, here ya be. You are gonna have to be the keeper of this, since it's been posted a gazillion times, but nobody bothers to look, and I'm getting tired, and so tag, you're it.
"UPGRADES" from one class to another ( i.e, CS to CVE) need to be done at Tokyo. It's a code thing. Don't give a rat's patoot what the whiners say, it's a code thing, and that's it. "CONVERSIONS" are a bit different; all that's required is time and a BIG shipyard. Maybe we could have done it different, but what the hey ...
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 6:27 pm
by Schanilec
ORIGINAL: JWE
ORIGINAL: Chickenboy
I tried to upgrade these two CS in Hiroshima, Kobe and Osaka-in that order. No joy. Only when moved to Tokyo did they 'take'. In my game, Hiroshima has the largest repair yard and the most naval support (and size 10 port). No reason it shouldn't have 'taken' there, unless it was hard coded for Tokyo. Others have reported something similar.
Without betraying too much OPSEC, I was able to upgrade the other two aforementioned CS elsewhere, not necessarily on the home islands either.
Ok, minucious gallus domesticus, here ya be. You are gonna have to be the keeper of this, since it's been posted a gazillion times, but nobody bothers to look, and I'm getting tired, and so tag, you're it.
"UPGRADES" from one class to another ( i.e, CS to CVE) need to be done at Tokyo. It's a code thing. Don't give a rat's patoot what the whiners say, it's a code thing, and that's it. "CONVERSIONS" are a bit different; all that's required is time and a BIG shipyard. Maybe we could have done it different, but what the hey ...
I like the cut of your jib.
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 7:20 pm
by herwin
ORIGINAL: JWE
ORIGINAL: Chickenboy
I tried to upgrade these two CS in Hiroshima, Kobe and Osaka-in that order. No joy. Only when moved to Tokyo did they 'take'. In my game, Hiroshima has the largest repair yard and the most naval support (and size 10 port). No reason it shouldn't have 'taken' there, unless it was hard coded for Tokyo. Others have reported something similar.
Without betraying too much OPSEC, I was able to upgrade the other two aforementioned CS elsewhere, not necessarily on the home islands either.
Ok, minucious gallus domesticus, here ya be. You are gonna have to be the keeper of this, since it's been posted a gazillion times, but nobody bothers to look, and I'm getting tired, and so tag, you're it.
"UPGRADES" from one class to another ( i.e, CS to CVE) need to be done at Tokyo. It's a code thing. Don't give a rat's patoot what the whiners say, it's a code thing, and that's it. "CONVERSIONS" are a bit different; all that's required is time and a BIG shipyard. Maybe we could have done it different, but what the hey ...
Or as we used to say, WAD (working as designed).
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 11:41 pm
by Numdydar
ORIGINAL: JWE
ORIGINAL: Chickenboy
I tried to upgrade these two CS in Hiroshima, Kobe and Osaka-in that order. No joy. Only when moved to Tokyo did they 'take'. In my game, Hiroshima has the largest repair yard and the most naval support (and size 10 port). No reason it shouldn't have 'taken' there, unless it was hard coded for Tokyo. Others have reported something similar.
Without betraying too much OPSEC, I was able to upgrade the other two aforementioned CS elsewhere, not necessarily on the home islands either.
Ok, minucious gallus domesticus, here ya be. You are gonna have to be the keeper of this, since it's been posted a gazillion times, but nobody bothers to look, and I'm getting tired, and so tag, you're it.
"UPGRADES" from one class to another ( i.e, CS to CVE) need to be done at Tokyo. It's a code thing. Don't give a rat's patoot what the whiners say, it's a code thing, and that's it. "CONVERSIONS" are a bit different; all that's required is time and a BIG shipyard. Maybe we could have done it different, but what the hey ...
I thank you for that information. Just to make sure I have this straight see the following:
The CS Chitose to CVL is an Upgrade. It uses the standard Upgrade <date available> Yes/No and what class it will upgrade to format on the ship screen. This can ONLY be done in Tokyo.
The CS Mizuho to CVL is a Conversion which can be done anywhere that has the right sized port/repair yard/supplies available. It is clearly marked as Conversion on the ship screen which makes it different than one marked as an Upgrade only.
Please correct me if the above is incorrect. Thanks again for the help.
RE: CS to CVL conversion
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2011 9:21 am
by JWE
That is correct. Technically, the Tokyo requirement is only for Upgrades from any class to a CV type class.