Page 1 of 1
Naval movement question
Posted: Sun Nov 17, 2013 1:18 pm
by smittyohio90
So, I'm reading the rules, and getting used to the UI, and ran into something I can't reconcile b/w the rules and the UI behavior.
Under 11.4.1. DEFINITION OF NAVAL MOVE:
You make 1 “naval move” with SUB units every time you:
Move a group of organized SUB units from one port, to any number of destinations (ports or sea-box sections, even in different sea areas)
Example: It would count as 1 naval move if you moved 3 SUBs from Brest to the Central Atlantic and put 2 into the 3 section and 1 into the 2 section.
I picked a "combined" action for Germany (1 naval move), and thought, based on the above rule and example, that I could pick up 2 subs from Kiel and move them into the North Sea. However, I am unable to do so... the cursor is an "X", and the MF tells me "Exceeds naval move limits". If I choose only 1 sub, it works. What am I missing?
RE: Naval movement question
Posted: Sun Nov 17, 2013 1:27 pm
by Rekm41
Do both subs have the same range? Maybe one cannot reach there.
RE: Naval movement question
Posted: Sun Nov 17, 2013 1:29 pm
by Centuur
Couple of questions:
Did you move any ship before you try to move the subs?
Is it the first impulse of the game (since Germany is neutral in the first impulse, he can only move 1 SUB as a naval move)?
If both answers are "no", than it looks like a bug to me...
RE: Naval movement question
Posted: Sun Nov 17, 2013 1:29 pm
by Centuur
ORIGINAL: rekm41
Do both subs have the same range? Maybe one cannot reach there.
North Sea is only 1 range from Kiel. All sub's have larger ranges...
RE: Naval movement question
Posted: Sun Nov 17, 2013 1:40 pm
by Shannon V. OKeets
ORIGINAL: smittyohio2
So, I'm reading the rules, and getting used to the UI, and ran into something I can't reconcile b/w the rules and the UI behavior.
Under 11.4.1. DEFINITION OF NAVAL MOVE:
You make 1 “naval move” with SUB units every time you:
Move a group of organized SUB units from one port, to any number of destinations (ports or sea-box sections, even in different sea areas)
Example: It would count as 1 naval move if you moved 3 SUBs from Brest to the Central Atlantic and put 2 into the 3 section and 1 into the 2 section.
I picked a "combined" action for Germany (1 naval move), and thought, based on the above rule and example, that I could pick up 2 subs from Kiel and move them into the North Sea. However, I am unable to do so... the cursor is an "X", and the MF tells me "Exceeds naval move limits". If I choose only 1 sub, it works. What am I missing?
If this is the first impulse of the first turn of Global War, then Germany is technically 'neutral' and can only move 1 naval unit.
RE: Naval movement question
Posted: Sun Nov 17, 2013 1:51 pm
by smittyohio90
ORIGINAL: Shannon V. OKeets
ORIGINAL: smittyohio2
So, I'm reading the rules, and getting used to the UI, and ran into something I can't reconcile b/w the rules and the UI behavior.
Under 11.4.1. DEFINITION OF NAVAL MOVE:
You make 1 “naval move” with SUB units every time you:
Move a group of organized SUB units from one port, to any number of destinations (ports or sea-box sections, even in different sea areas)
Example: It would count as 1 naval move if you moved 3 SUBs from Brest to the Central Atlantic and put 2 into the 3 section and 1 into the 2 section.
I picked a "combined" action for Germany (1 naval move), and thought, based on the above rule and example, that I could pick up 2 subs from Kiel and move them into the North Sea. However, I am unable to do so... the cursor is an "X", and the MF tells me "Exceeds naval move limits". If I choose only 1 sub, it works. What am I missing?
If this is the first impulse of the first turn of Global War, then Germany is technically 'neutral' and can only move 1 naval unit.
Thanks all for the quick responses! Steve hit the nail on the head... It was the first turn of the Globar War scenario. I was just about to reply to my original post that it didn't seem to affect any other country, but I guess I don't need to now
RE: Naval movement question
Posted: Sun Nov 17, 2013 5:01 pm
by bo
ORIGINAL: smittyohio2
ORIGINAL: Shannon V. OKeets
ORIGINAL: smittyohio2
So, I'm reading the rules, and getting used to the UI, and ran into something I can't reconcile b/w the rules and the UI behavior.
Under 11.4.1. DEFINITION OF NAVAL MOVE:
You make 1 “naval move” with SUB units every time you:
Move a group of organized SUB units from one port, to any number of destinations (ports or sea-box sections, even in different sea areas)
Example: It would count as 1 naval move if you moved 3 SUBs from Brest to the Central Atlantic and put 2 into the 3 section and 1 into the 2 section.
I picked a "combined" action for Germany (1 naval move), and thought, based on the above rule and example, that I could pick up 2 subs from Kiel and move them into the North Sea. However, I am unable to do so... the cursor is an "X", and the MF tells me "Exceeds naval move limits". If I choose only 1 sub, it works. What am I missing?
If this is the first impulse of the first turn of Global War, then Germany is technically 'neutral' and can only move 1 naval unit.
Thanks all for the quick responses! Steve hit the nail on the head... It was the first turn of the Globar War scenario. I was just about to reply to my original post that it didn't seem to affect any other country, but I guess I don't need to now
\
Hey smitty I think Centuur helped you first, his feelings get hurt if you do not recognize his efforts [:D] People from the Neds are very very touchy. [:(]
Bo
RE: Naval movement question
Posted: Sun Nov 17, 2013 5:05 pm
by AxelNL
ORIGINAL: bo
ORIGINAL: smittyohio2
ORIGINAL: Shannon V. OKeets
If this is the first impulse of the first turn of Global War, then Germany is technically 'neutral' and can only move 1 naval unit.
Thanks all for the quick responses! Steve hit the nail on the head... It was the first turn of the Globar War scenario. I was just about to reply to my original post that it didn't seem to affect any other country, but I guess I don't need to now
\
Hey smitty I think Centuur helped you first, his feelings get hurt if you do not recognize his efforts [:D] People from the Neds are very very touchy. [:(]
Bo
What do you mean by that last comment!!!![:@]
[;)]
RE: Naval movement question
Posted: Sun Nov 17, 2013 5:07 pm
by Orm
ORIGINAL: AxelNL
ORIGINAL: bo
ORIGINAL: smittyohio2
Thanks all for the quick responses! Steve hit the nail on the head... It was the first turn of the Globar War scenario. I was just about to reply to my original post that it didn't seem to affect any other country, but I guess I don't need to now
\
Hey smitty I think Centuur helped you first, his feelings get hurt if you do not recognize his efforts [:D] People from the Neds are very very touchy. [:(]
Bo
What do you mean by that last comment!!!![:@]
[;)]
It means that we like people from Netherlands so much that we make jokes about it. [:)]
RE: Naval movement question
Posted: Mon Nov 18, 2013 4:56 pm
by Centuur
Thank God that I'm part Austrian than... [:'(]
RE: Naval movement question
Posted: Mon Nov 18, 2013 4:59 pm
by Zorachus99
I watched the naval movement video and figured it out. Not intuitive, so watch the video
