Page 1 of 2

.

Posted: Sat Jul 25, 2015 12:48 pm
by chemkid
.

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Sat Jul 25, 2015 1:19 pm
by wodin
He dropped in to Guns of August asking about the want for work to continue on it which was enthusiastically received..only to disappear again until the release of Fortress Europa.

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Sat Jul 25, 2015 1:34 pm
by chemkid
.

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Sat Jul 25, 2015 2:36 pm
by Agathosdaimon
Franks games are fantastic! always very unique and elegant in game mechanics

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Sun Jul 26, 2015 4:02 pm
by Alan Sharif
Have to agree with the comments above.

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Mon Jul 27, 2015 6:26 am
by berto

For COTD:

[*]Updating the UI.
[*]One or more map zoom-out modes.
[*]Map scrolling by mousing to the map's edges, not via sidebars.

Throw in chemkid's superlative Fresh Map. All of these together would greatly enhance COTD's appeal.

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Thu Dec 10, 2015 6:43 am
by Recognition
Mr Frank Hunter the Napoleonic armies are waiting to be mustered[:)]

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Thu Dec 10, 2015 7:17 am
by chemkid
.

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Thu Dec 10, 2015 9:58 am
by altipueri
I recently got Frank Hunter's Campaigns On The Danube (COTD) and I am enjoying it (even more than Wars Of Napoleon, which I also bought.)

Those of you who remember Command Ops - Battle of The Bulge - where you give high level orders, then there's order delay, then things start to move - well COTD is a bit like that for Napoleon - but the orders take hours to travel by courier.

By coincidence I happened to read a paragraph in Jomini's book about Napoleon playing with colored pins on his maps that got me thinking about which games are nearer reality for commanders before telephone, radio and satellite.

In fact I'll quote from Chapter 6 of Jomini's "The Art Of War":

"The emperor was his own chief staff officer. Provided with a pair of dividers opened to a distance by the scale of from seventeen to twenty miles (which made from twenty-two to twenty-five miles, taking into account the windings of the roads,) bending over and at sometimes stretched at full length upon his map, where the positions of his corps and the supposed positions of the enemy were marked by pins of different colors, he was able to give orders for extensive movements with a certainty and precision which were astonishing."

In COTD turns are a day, you give orders to your corps - and a few hours later they start to move - a bit like Jomini said, but in my case not with as much precision as Napoleon.


There's a good AAR by Rasputitsa to look at, and the game only costs ten quid/dollars/euros at the moment and has just had a patch.


This style of game could be used for many wargame periods


RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Thu Dec 10, 2015 10:05 am
by altipueri
Ha, I've now found a quote from an old post I made on commanders getting information - Churchill was visiting Montgomery:

From Winston Churchill's "The Second World War". Chapter XXIV "Crossing the Rhine"

At 8 p.m. we repaired to the map wagon, and I now had an excellent opportunity of seeing Montgomery's methods of conducting a battle on this gigantic scale. For nearly two hours a succession of young officers, of about the rank of major, presented themselves. Each had come back from a different sector of the front. They were the direct personal representatives of the Commander-in-Chief, and could go anywhere and see anything and ask any questions they liked of any commander. As in turn they made their reports and were searchingly questioned by their chief the whole story of the day's battle was unfolded. This gave Monty a complete account of what had happened by highly competent men whom he knew well and whose eyes he trusted. It afforded an invaluable cross-check to the reports from all the various headquarters and from the commanders, all of which had already been sifted and weighed by General de Guingard, his Chief of Staff, and were known to Montgomery. By this process he was able to form a more vivid, direct and sometimes more accurate picture. The officers ran great risks, and of the seven or eight to whom I listened on this and succeeding nights two were killed in the next few weeks. I thought the system admirable, and indeed the only way in which a modern Commander-in-Chief could see as well as read what was going on in every part of the front. This process having finished, Montgomery gave a series of directions to de Guingand, which were turned into immediate action by the Staff machine. And so to bed.

* * * * *

The next day, March 25, we went to meet Eisenhower. On our way I told Montgomery how his system resembled that of Marlborough and the conduct of battles in the eighteenth century, where the Commander-in-Chief acted through his lieutenant-generals. Then the Commander-in-Chief sat on his horse and directed by word of mouth a battle on a five or six mile front, which ended in a day and settled the fortunes of great nations, sometimes for years or generations to come. In order to make his will effective he had four or five lieutenant-generals posted at different points on the front, who knew his whole mind and were concerned with the execution of his plan. These officers commanded no troops and were intended to be off-shoots and expressions of the Supreme Commander. In modern times the general must sit in his office conducting a battle ranging over ten times the front and lasting often for a week or ten days. In these changed conditions Montgomery's method of personal eye-witnesses, who were naturally treated with the utmost consideration by the front-line commanders of every grade, was an interesting though partial revival of old days.

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2015 1:13 am
by 76mm
I just bought COTD as well and am very impressed, it is certainly the best $12 I ever spent on a game (it is currently on sale).

It is only a shame that there is not, and apparently will not be, an editor for it or other campaigns.

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2015 8:11 am
by demyansk
How about piercing game, is th as t good?

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2015 9:56 am
by Recognition
Also you can get Frank Hunters excellent "Fort Sumter to Appomattox - The American Civil War" as a free download here....

http://www.thurb.com/games/acw/intro.htm

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2015 10:11 am
by Karri
It was one of the games that got me hooked in US civil war games and history.

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2015 10:22 am
by Recognition
ORIGINAL: Karri

It was one of the games that got me hooked in US civil war games and history.

Great!! and its still working well on my Win XP and Win 8.1 systems.

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 12:22 pm
by chemkid
.

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 8:25 pm
by Fred98
I got piercing fortress Europe and found it impossible! The basic actions that are simple in all games were impossible!

After a few months I deleted it.

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 9:46 pm
by Yogi the Great
I think Piercing Fortress Europa is a great game and well worth the purchase. Interesting system when you can't be sure as in real life that your units can and/or will move where you want.

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2016 1:58 am
by Agathosdaimon
i found PFE to be fairly easy, the mechanics are different to say games like TOAW but it works well. His Campaigns on the Danube game though is really where his unique approach comes into its own - a game that is as much as about fog of war and the critical nature of getting accurate and timely information back from what your corps and cavalry scouts are encountering as well as all the other necessities of maintaining supply lines, field hospitals, retreat points, etc. Similary to Wars of Napoleon but with the issue of information delays, stragglers, and also the means of linking the campaign game up with using miniatures to fight the battles and with a hex based map rather than tiles. It is great and even the very first incarnation of it which was La Grande Armee 1806 and which is hard to find, though i was kindly gifted the CD, can still work perfectly fine on Windows 7

His grand civil war game also is still regarded as one of the best too i have heard. Maybe he could even do a Campaigns on the Potomac?

RE: Frank Hunter Games need MORE LOVE!!

Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2016 9:31 am
by Zap
But you don't hear much from Frank Himself. He needs more exposure( get out there Frank and do some interviews) or maybe he is winding down his career and is not that interested promoting himself or his games?

This would be a good interview for Jason(Wodin) for his Needful Things for a Wargamer Blog.