Page 1 of 1
"Helper" notices
Posted: Mon Nov 30, 2015 12:25 pm
by 76mm
I was testing the PBEM++ system with a fellow player, and we decided to look at how players are informed of use of "helpers" by their opponents.
On page 57 of the manual it says that if a player uses a helper it will be noted in the Difficulty section of his Daily Game Log and that of his opponent.
I don't seem to have such a section in my daily log, and can't find any mention of the fact that my opponent used a helper anywhere. Can anyone point to where players are notified of this?
Two other issues with "helpers":
--the top of page 56 in the manual states that "Helpers aren't cheats. There are times when...you need to yell out for assistance." Actually, helpers look very much like cheats--simply saying that they are "yelling out for assistance" rather than "cheats" doesn't constitute much of a difference as far as I can tell; and
--it sure seems like players should be able to turn these off for PBEM++ play--whether you classify them as cheats or not, I'm not sure if I want opponents to be able to "yell out for assistance" during a game. Why can't we turn these off?
RE: "Helper" notices
Posted: Mon Nov 30, 2015 12:35 pm
by zakblood
is this what you mean?

RE: "Helper" notices
Posted: Mon Nov 30, 2015 12:38 pm
by zakblood
the test im on atm
if not then i have no idea either tbh[:(]
regarding this,
--it sure seems like players should be able to turn these off for PBEM++ play--whether you classify them as cheats or not, I'm not sure if I want opponents to be able to "yell out for assistance" during a game. Why can't we turn these off?
that's a question for the developers, so will leave it and let them answer, don't play PBEM++ myself, only test so does seem to be with most games you need house rules maybe? or a gentleman's agreement before hand?
RE: "Helper" notices
Posted: Mon Nov 30, 2015 12:40 pm
by 76mm
Thanks, yes, there it is, thank you.
But why can't we turn these off for PBEM++ play? I guess it doesn't matter much if I am notified of their use since I can't do anything about it; even if players agree to a house rule not to use them, chances of me checking that particular log every turn are not very high.
Also, from your screen shot, it looks like these "helpers" can be used many times each turn. I guess this is someone yelling out really really loud for help?
RE: "Helper" notices
Posted: Mon Nov 30, 2015 12:44 pm
by zakblood
sorry i edited mine, as i read the other bit afterwards, then edited again for spelling[:(]
RE: "Helper" notices
Posted: Mon Nov 30, 2015 12:45 pm
by 76mm
No worries, thanks for the help!
RE: "Helper" notices
Posted: Mon Nov 30, 2015 12:45 pm
by zakblood
ORIGINAL: 76mm
Thanks, yes, there it is, thank you.
But why can't we turn these off for PBEM++ play? I guess it doesn't matter much if I am notified of their use since I can't do anything about it; even if players agree to a house rule not to use them, chances of me checking that particular log every turn are not very high.
Also, from your screen shot, it looks like these "helpers" can be used many times each turn. I guess this is someone yelling out really really loud for help?
yes you can shout as many time as you like, but each time to do, the other side also get the same amount of help, so tbh it in the end makes it just as hard if not harder, but can pull you out of some tight spots used, so i guess with VP's etc, it could mean you win the battle and loose the campaign etc? not sure but i can see it's a point match as well...
RE: "Helper" notices
Posted: Mon Nov 30, 2015 1:05 pm
by 76mm
ORIGINAL: zakblood
yes you can shout as many time as you like, but each time to do, the other side also get the same amount of help, so tbh it in the end makes it just as hard if not harder...
When you say that the other side gets the same amount of help, I guess you mean it raises the difficulty rating? While the manual says that using these lowers your difficulty rating and raises your opponents, that might not always be an effective deterrent, as there will always be circumstances when a few more trucks, trains, or whatever will make a huge difference, and in fact the trucks/trains would not always be available...
RE: "Helper" notices
Posted: Mon Nov 30, 2015 1:20 pm
by zakblood
raises the difficulty rating?
yes
While the manual says that using these lowers your difficulty rating and raises your opponents
think it's the other way round, or alters the VP's at the end anyway[;)]
developers will give a better more correct answer, there better with the words than maybe i am so can explain it more fully[;)]
RE: "Helper" notices
Posted: Mon Nov 30, 2015 3:25 pm
by rickier65
ORIGINAL: 76mm
Thanks, yes, there it is, thank you.
But why can't we turn these off for PBEM++ play? I guess it doesn't matter much if I am notified of their use since I can't do anything about it; even if players agree to a house rule not to use them, chances of me checking that particular log every turn are not very high.
Also, from your screen shot, it looks like these "helpers" can be used many times each turn. I guess this is someone yelling out really really loud for help?
It does seem like this should be turned off for PBEM or H2H.
Thanks
Rick