Page 1 of 1

Question about officers/leaders

Posted: Sat Apr 16, 2016 12:09 am
by MrLongleg
I can't find any documentation about leaders/officers in new dawn random games.

I have have couple questions:

- is a HQ with leader always better than one without, no matter the stats of the leader
- if there is more staff than the leader can handle, what is the penalty? Is it better to get rid of the leader in that case?
- are leaders in higher level HQ's useful at all? How far are they spreading their bonuses?

And is there any good link to more explanation?

Thanks for any help.

RE: Question about officers/leaders

Posted: Sat Apr 16, 2016 3:51 pm
by ernieschwitz
ORIGINAL: Haudrauf1962

I can't find any documentation about leaders/officers in new dawn random games.

I have have couple questions:

- is a HQ with leader always better than one without, no matter the stats of the leader
- if there is more staff than the leader can handle, what is the penalty? Is it better to get rid of the leader in that case?
- are leaders in higher level HQ's useful at all? How far are they spreading their bonuses?

And is there any good link to more explanation?

Thanks for any help.

You can make leaders worse than having no leader, but there really is no point, since you can just remove the leader from the HQ in question, no questions asked, no penalty, and the HQ would be better. The leaders in GD 1938 are always better than not having a leader.

The bonuses a Leader conveys stop when the max. staff level is reached. That is the remainder staff does not get bonuses, while those that he can command do.

Unsure if bonuses from leaders in higher level HQs spread to troops under lower level HQs, I think they don't.... that being said I might be wrong.

RE: Question about officers/leaders

Posted: Sat Apr 16, 2016 5:51 pm
by Tac2i
An HQ with/without leader excerts it bonuses out to max of 7 hexes.

RE: Question about officers/leaders

Posted: Sat Apr 16, 2016 6:01 pm
by bobarossa
If you are talking random games, I've never seen a leader with negative bonuses, so I would say a leader is always a benefit. My guess is that when you exceed the staff level of the leader, the leader's bonus gets reduced proportionately. Probably something like (max staff/actual staff) x bonus% (only if actual is greater than max). I imagine the leader's bonus would be cut in half if he had twice the recommended max staff.

RE: Question about officers/leaders

Posted: Sat Apr 16, 2016 9:33 pm
by ernieschwitz
The effect of a leader is like this.

Let us make it easy on ourselvses and use some simple numbers...

Let us say that the effect of the HQs staff in question is to double the effectiveness of the troops, that is a bonus of 100%. There are 20 staff, and our general or officer if you will has a combat bonus of 25%, and is capable of commanding 10 staff.

His bonus would then be calculated as follows. 10 / 20 *100% * 25% = 12,5%. So the affected soldiers would get a bonus of 12,5% resulting in an overall bonus of 112,5%.

That's it. No drop-off, no reduced effectiveness of overstaffing. I have this from the fingers of Vic, in either mail form or skype conversation... i forget which.

RE: Question about officers/leaders

Posted: Sun Apr 17, 2016 4:22 pm
by MrLongleg
Thanks a lot. So as it looks right now it would not make sense to have leaders at higher HQ

RE: Question about officers/leaders

Posted: Thu Jan 05, 2017 5:17 pm
by balto
Sorry for the necro on this thread. Can I re-ask this:

In a random game, if you are going to create a new HQ, wouldn't you ALWAYS want one with a leader?

Thanks,

RE: Question about officers/leaders

Posted: Thu Jan 05, 2017 5:20 pm
by ernieschwitz
HQs with Leaders cost more PPs.

RE: Question about officers/leaders

Posted: Thu Jan 05, 2017 5:28 pm
by balto
Other than the PP cost, would it ALWAYS be advantageous to create one with a leader?

THank you for all your responses Ernie.

RE: Question about officers/leaders

Posted: Thu Jan 05, 2017 5:37 pm
by ernieschwitz
Well depends really. There are some fringe benefits of making HQs without leaders. For instance your main HQ (or top HQ) and those beneath it, that are not frontline, would probably not need leaders, as leaders would confer very limited advantages.

RE: Question about officers/leaders

Posted: Thu Jan 05, 2017 6:05 pm
by bobarossa
You can always add (or move) leaders later. It comes down to "can you afford the extra PP's for a leader?" It also can depend on whether the front is active or not. You definitely want a local HQ controlling your units as soon as possible to avoid paying the 50% readiness hit when reassigning them when they are under attack.


RE: Question about officers/leaders

Posted: Sat Jan 14, 2017 1:56 am
by Philo32b
It would be nice if the modifiers for leaders were hidden, at least for a while. (Distant Worlds does this, for example.) And then a hefty cost in PP if you want to get rid of a bad leader (and there should be bad leaders). Reading Rick Atkinson's masterful An Army at Dawn impressed upon me how bad leaders could be and how hard to identify and remove them.

Ideal setup: you never get hard stats on what the modifiers are, so you just have to come up with your intuitive grasp on whether the leader is good or bad. Even better, if you got messages from that leader's rivals and subordinates that reported on their competence (whether truly or falsely, you might not know), that would be awesome!

RE: Question about officers/leaders

Posted: Sat Jan 14, 2017 9:48 pm
by bobarossa
Just read Army at Dawn a few months ago, great book. I like the idea of leader's stat's being hidden but I don't really want to evaluate them myself; never had any interest in management of personnel! Forge of Freedom had hidden leader stats that slowly got revealed as they took part in battles. This is my favorite method of handling leaders.