Yamamoto's War: BtS Lite Kitakami-J v Revthought-A - No Revthought
Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 7:12 pm
Ok... after a rather long hiatus due to health reasons, I have come back to my favorite game ever (and the cheapest per hour too). I am as rusty as an old nail left in the middle of a wet field for a few years, so any and all comments are welcome. We are using the latest BtS version available, and there will be no Yamato or Musashi, which makes for a different, but interesting, start. Also, we will be doing 2-day turns, which makes games quite different (like having to order land units to combat mode when they have only traveled 30 miles, because otherwise next turn they will cross the river into enemy occupied terrain in travel mode.
Turn one has already been run. Results were... unexpected. One thing the Japanese player must realize about BtS is that quantity comes at a price, and that price is quality. The starting experience of the Japanese air arm has been lowered enough so that I did not expect to sink even one battleship in Pearl Harbor. So much so, that I was even tempted to leave the old battlewagons alone and send all three divisions of Kido Butai against Manila. In the end, I decided against it, but I did do something different due to the 2-day turns. I set all carrier attack planes to naval attack primary with port attack secondary. Especially in the Philippines I believe it is a wise course of action. Something else I did was to remain near Pearl for a second day of attacks. Unwise, I know, but I wanted to try something different.
Well the results were, as I wrote above, unexpected. First, my opponent was very conservative with his surface forces, and I found no carrier TFs (expected), and no cruiser TFs (unexpected). I did not even find Force Z! Still, what air attacks could not do, sub attacks kind of made up for. These are the combat results, by region:
Pearl Harbor:
- One midget sub sneaks in and scores a hit on BB Tennessee.
- BB Nevada hit by 2 torpedoes.
- BB Tennessee hit by an additional 5 torpedoes.
- BB Idaho hit by 1 torpedo, magazine explodes, and is reported as sunk.
- BB Arizona hit by 2 torpedoes.
- BB New Mexico hit by 4 torpedoes.
- BB California hit by 2 torpedoes.
- BB Oklahoma hit by 3 torpedoes.
- CA San Francisco hit by 2 torpedoes.
- CA Minneapolis hit by 2 torpedoes.
- CL Helena hit by 1 torpedo.
- CL St Louis hit by 1 torpedo.
- DD Ward hit by a total of 9 bombs and is sunk.
- 6 aircraft reported destroyed.
- Other minor units hit.
Interestingly, I see no report of Pearl Harbor being attacked on day 2 of the turn. I am not sure if I should be upset... or relieved!
Pacific
Little action here:
- BC Ranger hit by 1 torpedo. Reported sunk, but I don't believe it.
- Makin taken.
- 1st Sasebo Assault Div landed on Guam. Will assault next turn.
Philippines
Since the USN cruisers (2 CAs, 2 CLs, 1 CLV, plus escorts) did not seek battle, the Japanese naval air concentrated on Manila:
- SS S-38 hit by 2 bombs and reported sunk.
- SS Sargo hit by 2 bombs.
- SS Sturgeon hit by 1 bomb.
- SS Spearfish hit by 1 bomb.
- SS Sculpin hit by 1 bomb.
- SS Saury hit by 1 bomb.
- SS S-41 hit by 1 bomb.
- SS Seal hit by 1 bomb.
- SS Seadragon hit by 1 bomb.
- SS Spearfish hit by 1 bomb.
- SS Stingray hit by 1 bomb.
- DD Scout hit by 1 bomb and 1 torpedo, and reported sunk.
- DD Thanet hit by 1 bomb.
- A few transports hit but not sunk.
- Batan Island taken.
- Vigan taken, 65th Bde, 2x Tk Rgts, and elements of 48th Div landed.
- 18th Div on its way to southern Luzon.
Dutch East Indies
- Ternate taken by air assault by 1st Para Assault Div.
Malaya
- CL Durban hit by 1 torpedo near Muntok.
- Most of 5th Div landed in Singora. Rest will unload on turn 2... hopefully!
- 18th Div, engineers and artillery landed in Kota Bharu. Will assault on turn 2.
- 4th & 21st Div landed in Kuantan. Will assault on turn 2.
- Imperial Guards Div will start moving by rail next turn.
- Victoria Point taken by air assault by 1st raiding Rgt. Defenders eliminated.
Burma
- 55th Div will start moving by rail next turn.
- 2x Tk Rgts & 1 Arty unit waiting for 55th Div in Bangkok.
China
- Hong Kong forces arrived. Bombardment will start next turn.
- Pengpu assaulted and taken.
- Ichang evacuated.
- Tons of units moving to fulfill all garrisons, but maximizing front-line strength.
Losses:
Naval losses have been light so far. I can't complain in this respect.
- TK Kanze Maru sunk by submarine near Soc Trang.
- xAK Korei Maru sunk by submarine near Batan Island.
- xAK Teihoku Maru heavily damaged near Soc Trang.
- xAK Keihuku Maru heavily damaged near Takao.
- xAK Arimasan Maru heavily damaged near Takao.
- AD Gyoko Maru heavily damaged by a B-17 in Babeldaob.
- SS I-169 lightly damaged by DCs near Pago Pago.
- xAP Ural Maru lightly damaged near Kuantan.
Air losses, on the other hand, were unexpectedly heavy, probably because of the lower experience levels (I do escort my bombers). This rate of attrition cannot continue, or I will run out of planes very, very quickly.
- 28 B5N2
- 20 A6M2
- 17 G4M2
- 6 Ki-27b
- 8 D3A1
- 3 Ki-48-Ib
- 19 P-40E
- 18 P-40B
- 15 Vildebeest III
- 13 Buffalo I
- 5 PBY-5
- 5 F4F-3
- 5 P-36A
- 4 Blemheim IV
- 3 Do-24K-1
(I did not list other, minor losses)
All told, 650 TFs were active last turn. Some have arrived to their destinations, but there are literally hundreds moving everywhere right now.
I am not sure what to think of the turn. On the one hand I think my interior lines are somewhat secure. On the other, I did not sink as many enemy ships as I would have liked (if Tennessee goes down, I will call Pearl Harbor a Pyrrhic victory, though). PoW, Renown, and the USN cruisers in the Philippines / DEI area worry me. Yet, I damaged a lot of subs in Manila, and they will have to go through the gauntlet (Naval air against the port, and ASW assets waiting for them outside the bay) to get out of there. We will see if that works.
These are a few of the strategic decisions made before turn 1:
BB Repair Yards
Hiroshima & Nagasaki: 122 SY to repair 41cm rifles (4 ships).
Yokohama & Kobe: 102/100 SY to repair 40cm rifles (3 ships).
Shanghai & Tokyo: 63/62 SY to repair 36cm rifles (10 ships).
Later on:
Hong Kong & Singapore: 63 SY to repair 36cm rifles.
I am toying with the idea of stopping construction of a few SSs to accelerate some CVs and CVLs. I am not sure about this, though. Any thoughts on the matter would be welcome.
Aircraft research has been set, with a few plane types getting the main focus, and a few getting none. We will see what comes of this.
Thoughts?
Turn one has already been run. Results were... unexpected. One thing the Japanese player must realize about BtS is that quantity comes at a price, and that price is quality. The starting experience of the Japanese air arm has been lowered enough so that I did not expect to sink even one battleship in Pearl Harbor. So much so, that I was even tempted to leave the old battlewagons alone and send all three divisions of Kido Butai against Manila. In the end, I decided against it, but I did do something different due to the 2-day turns. I set all carrier attack planes to naval attack primary with port attack secondary. Especially in the Philippines I believe it is a wise course of action. Something else I did was to remain near Pearl for a second day of attacks. Unwise, I know, but I wanted to try something different.
Well the results were, as I wrote above, unexpected. First, my opponent was very conservative with his surface forces, and I found no carrier TFs (expected), and no cruiser TFs (unexpected). I did not even find Force Z! Still, what air attacks could not do, sub attacks kind of made up for. These are the combat results, by region:
Pearl Harbor:
- One midget sub sneaks in and scores a hit on BB Tennessee.
- BB Nevada hit by 2 torpedoes.
- BB Tennessee hit by an additional 5 torpedoes.
- BB Idaho hit by 1 torpedo, magazine explodes, and is reported as sunk.
- BB Arizona hit by 2 torpedoes.
- BB New Mexico hit by 4 torpedoes.
- BB California hit by 2 torpedoes.
- BB Oklahoma hit by 3 torpedoes.
- CA San Francisco hit by 2 torpedoes.
- CA Minneapolis hit by 2 torpedoes.
- CL Helena hit by 1 torpedo.
- CL St Louis hit by 1 torpedo.
- DD Ward hit by a total of 9 bombs and is sunk.
- 6 aircraft reported destroyed.
- Other minor units hit.
Interestingly, I see no report of Pearl Harbor being attacked on day 2 of the turn. I am not sure if I should be upset... or relieved!
Pacific
Little action here:
- BC Ranger hit by 1 torpedo. Reported sunk, but I don't believe it.
- Makin taken.
- 1st Sasebo Assault Div landed on Guam. Will assault next turn.
Philippines
Since the USN cruisers (2 CAs, 2 CLs, 1 CLV, plus escorts) did not seek battle, the Japanese naval air concentrated on Manila:
- SS S-38 hit by 2 bombs and reported sunk.
- SS Sargo hit by 2 bombs.
- SS Sturgeon hit by 1 bomb.
- SS Spearfish hit by 1 bomb.
- SS Sculpin hit by 1 bomb.
- SS Saury hit by 1 bomb.
- SS S-41 hit by 1 bomb.
- SS Seal hit by 1 bomb.
- SS Seadragon hit by 1 bomb.
- SS Spearfish hit by 1 bomb.
- SS Stingray hit by 1 bomb.
- DD Scout hit by 1 bomb and 1 torpedo, and reported sunk.
- DD Thanet hit by 1 bomb.
- A few transports hit but not sunk.
- Batan Island taken.
- Vigan taken, 65th Bde, 2x Tk Rgts, and elements of 48th Div landed.
- 18th Div on its way to southern Luzon.
Dutch East Indies
- Ternate taken by air assault by 1st Para Assault Div.
Malaya
- CL Durban hit by 1 torpedo near Muntok.
- Most of 5th Div landed in Singora. Rest will unload on turn 2... hopefully!
- 18th Div, engineers and artillery landed in Kota Bharu. Will assault on turn 2.
- 4th & 21st Div landed in Kuantan. Will assault on turn 2.
- Imperial Guards Div will start moving by rail next turn.
- Victoria Point taken by air assault by 1st raiding Rgt. Defenders eliminated.
Burma
- 55th Div will start moving by rail next turn.
- 2x Tk Rgts & 1 Arty unit waiting for 55th Div in Bangkok.
China
- Hong Kong forces arrived. Bombardment will start next turn.
- Pengpu assaulted and taken.
- Ichang evacuated.
- Tons of units moving to fulfill all garrisons, but maximizing front-line strength.
Losses:
Naval losses have been light so far. I can't complain in this respect.
- TK Kanze Maru sunk by submarine near Soc Trang.
- xAK Korei Maru sunk by submarine near Batan Island.
- xAK Teihoku Maru heavily damaged near Soc Trang.
- xAK Keihuku Maru heavily damaged near Takao.
- xAK Arimasan Maru heavily damaged near Takao.
- AD Gyoko Maru heavily damaged by a B-17 in Babeldaob.
- SS I-169 lightly damaged by DCs near Pago Pago.
- xAP Ural Maru lightly damaged near Kuantan.
Air losses, on the other hand, were unexpectedly heavy, probably because of the lower experience levels (I do escort my bombers). This rate of attrition cannot continue, or I will run out of planes very, very quickly.
- 28 B5N2
- 20 A6M2
- 17 G4M2
- 6 Ki-27b
- 8 D3A1
- 3 Ki-48-Ib
- 19 P-40E
- 18 P-40B
- 15 Vildebeest III
- 13 Buffalo I
- 5 PBY-5
- 5 F4F-3
- 5 P-36A
- 4 Blemheim IV
- 3 Do-24K-1
(I did not list other, minor losses)
All told, 650 TFs were active last turn. Some have arrived to their destinations, but there are literally hundreds moving everywhere right now.
I am not sure what to think of the turn. On the one hand I think my interior lines are somewhat secure. On the other, I did not sink as many enemy ships as I would have liked (if Tennessee goes down, I will call Pearl Harbor a Pyrrhic victory, though). PoW, Renown, and the USN cruisers in the Philippines / DEI area worry me. Yet, I damaged a lot of subs in Manila, and they will have to go through the gauntlet (Naval air against the port, and ASW assets waiting for them outside the bay) to get out of there. We will see if that works.
These are a few of the strategic decisions made before turn 1:
BB Repair Yards
Hiroshima & Nagasaki: 122 SY to repair 41cm rifles (4 ships).
Yokohama & Kobe: 102/100 SY to repair 40cm rifles (3 ships).
Shanghai & Tokyo: 63/62 SY to repair 36cm rifles (10 ships).
Later on:
Hong Kong & Singapore: 63 SY to repair 36cm rifles.
I am toying with the idea of stopping construction of a few SSs to accelerate some CVs and CVLs. I am not sure about this, though. Any thoughts on the matter would be welcome.
Aircraft research has been set, with a few plane types getting the main focus, and a few getting none. We will see what comes of this.
Thoughts?
