Page 1 of 1

ATG Scenario Capabilities

Posted: Tue Feb 07, 2017 11:50 pm
by rhinobones
Over the years, I’ve had a few other war games and one of the things I enjoyed most was building scenarios for military problems.
Nothing big, just 10 to 30 turns, with built in variables for OOB, objectives and starting positions.

The intention was twofold, 1) make the problem interesting and challenging and 2) make it variable so you never play the same game twice. I really dislike those set piece scenarios where the expert players all have that killer first move. Way too gamey.

I don’t own ATG, but from what I read the system has a capability far beyond the competitors.
Questions for scenario design are:

1. Can the selection of starting active units be randomized, such as having 10 units active out of 50 possible units? For both sides.
2. Make the type of units selected to be active variable, such as making the number of armored, air, infantry or artillery variable. Some type of plus or minus per unit category.
3. Can victory objectives be assigned randomly? The home cities (where all production/support is produced) would be a candidate, but there could also be objectives such as bridges, crossroads, observation posts, and so on.

Would appreciate any input from the ATG players/designers to help me understand the capability of ATG.

Best Regards, RhinoBones

RE: ATG Scenario Capabilities

Posted: Wed Feb 08, 2017 6:11 pm
by Tac2i
Let me just say the ATG editor is very powerful but does have a rather steep learning curve and isn't the easiest thing to use. That said modders much more talented than me have done some amazing things with it. For me personally, the main strength of this game is the random game engine. I, like you, don't much care for historical scenarios/games that kinda put you in a historical straight jacket. After nearly six years I still enjoy this game though I don't play it as much as I use to. To do the things you want to do would definitely require you learn the editor. Some of those things may not be achievable.

If you travel over to http://vrdesigns.net, create an account, you can log in and see all the player made scenarios available for download.

RE: ATG Scenario Capabilities

Posted: Sun Feb 12, 2017 5:36 pm
by warnevada
ATG, despite its name, is more strategic/operational than tactical. As such, each side has production facilities consisting of cities or factories which produce units. For your points 1 and 2, you can generate a scenario and then build different units each time you play. So you play on the same map but with potentially very different forces each time.

Victory hexes are cities and as far as I know can't be assigned to things like resources or geographic points such as bridges. I suppose you could fake it by putting a city adjacent to the bridge and giving it victory points.

ATG is a very good game. My friends and I have been playing it for three years and still enjoy it. We have now gotten to the point of designing our own scenarios rather than just playing the randomly generated ones. The game is best when playing against other players rather than against the AI.

RE: ATG Scenario Capabilities

Posted: Sun Feb 12, 2017 6:36 pm
by Bombur
The scenario editor is extremely powerful and you can build essentially any strategic scenario from ancient times to the early cold war, for newer scenarios the engine starts to showw some limitations. For operational scenarios you need some extra work with the editor. However, it must be noticed that, while the event editor is years light beyong that of TOAW, it isn´t intuitive.

RE: ATG Scenario Capabilities

Posted: Sun Feb 12, 2017 8:29 pm
by Twotribes
In the editor you can in fact assign victory points to any hex, the advantage to only assigning them to cities or such is they are visible on the map.

RE: ATG Scenario Capabilities

Posted: Mon Feb 13, 2017 5:22 am
by Vic
Hi there Rhino,

Honestely you might be more interested in the Decisive Campaigns Community Project. Its a free game if you own any of the Decisive Campaigns series games. For more information go here: http://www.vrdesigns.net/?page_id=1331

Its editors allow you to do exactly all 3 things you asked for.

Best wishes,
Vic