Page 1 of 1

Important: Friendly mines can change from "defensive" to "offensive" !

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2003 12:20 pm
by Apollo11
Hi all,

Perhaps you didn't know but friendly laid mines can change from "defensive" to
"offensive" - therefore beware !


Explanation:

If you lay mines in your base (i.e. you are laying "defensive" minefield) and
enemy then takes over your base your mines will now become "offensive".

I think this is done because, when you base falls, the data of how your
initial mines were laid is lost. Nice touch.

Interesting isn't it...


Leo "Apollo11"

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2003 12:22 pm
by U2
Yeah it's been that way for some time now, just noticed it? Anyway it can be quite a nasty surprise if you fail to remember it:)

Re: Important: Friendly mines can change from "defensive" to "offensive" !

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2003 8:07 pm
by JohnK
Originally posted by Apollo11
I think this is done because, when you base falls, the data of how your
initial mines were laid is lost. Nice touch.


I'd say the chances this was done deliberately is about 0%; it simply didn't occur to the designers that it would be a problem.

And the idea that, say, if the US laid a defensive minefield at Luganville, the ONLY copy of the map of the minefield in the entire US Navy was at Luganville, and the map would be lost if the Japanese captured Luganville, is beyond silly.

Re: Re: Important: Friendly mines can change from "defensive" to "offensive" !

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2003 8:44 pm
by panda124c
Originally posted by JohnK
I'd say the chances this was done deliberately is about 0%; it simply didn't occur to the designers that it would be a problem.

And the idea that, say, if the US laid a defensive minefield at Luganville, the ONLY copy of the map of the minefield in the entire US Navy was at Luganville, and the map would be lost if the Japanese captured Luganville, is beyond silly.


More likley is, new paths would be cut through the old mine field and old paths would be mined over. Much more economical than sweeping the old mine field and then planting all new mines.

Posted: Wed Apr 16, 2003 4:55 am
by Drex
i found out the hard way. The South Dakota is now on her way back to Pearl after a bombardment run on my old base Nevea.