A few general ATG gameplay questions
Posted: Wed Jun 03, 2020 11:04 am
I have been playing this fine game for a couple of years now. While most of my queries have been answered by perusing the rules or by simple trial and error by playing I would like to have some queries about the gameplay to be finally explained with no margin for doubt.
Firstly overstacking. I know there is a penalty for this in both attack and defense but I'm still slightly confused about one point. If I have a hex containing 200 rifle and I want to attack an adjacent hex. Simply attacking from the hex would be a big overstack, but what happens if I split my 200 rifles into two units containing 100 rifle each? I can then attack the adjacent hex with only 100 rifle. However despite the fact that I am attacking with 100 rifle I am attacking from a hex that contains 200 units. So would I still get an overstack penalty despite my splitting up of the units?
How exactly is "damage" modeled in this game? If I bomb a hex and my bomber gets reduced to 1 hit point it can still manage to fly back to base. Is this damage "repaired" again fully the next turn at no cost? Or does it require supply to bring it back to full repair? Does the "readiness" value reflect a damage state? I understand the concept of "readiness" as combat effectiveness but I'm still confused as to it's relation to hit points and damage.
Is there any point in causing structural damage to a city that is below it's "auto repair" value? If I bomb or bombard a city and cause 300 structural damage is this basically a waste of time, as it will be fully repaired next turn.
Is there actually any point in having rear area HQs staffed at all? I assumed for a long time that staff would be needed not just to give combat/ morale bonuses but also to transfer supplies. But as an experiment I disbanded all staff in Supreme HQ, and found that it had no effect on actual supply transfer at all. Since then I have only had staff in HQs close to fighting.
Do urban hexes or ports actually give ships an protection? I have read VR Designs War College and it said that urban hexes give subs protection. Yet the stats on screen don't say that ships or subs have any entrenchment bonuses when in a urban hex.
And finally what is the best way to give bombers fighter escort? Should you directly put fighters into a bomber division, or create a separate fighter division and send both the bomber and fighter divisions to a bombing raid? Or is there any difference?
Firstly overstacking. I know there is a penalty for this in both attack and defense but I'm still slightly confused about one point. If I have a hex containing 200 rifle and I want to attack an adjacent hex. Simply attacking from the hex would be a big overstack, but what happens if I split my 200 rifles into two units containing 100 rifle each? I can then attack the adjacent hex with only 100 rifle. However despite the fact that I am attacking with 100 rifle I am attacking from a hex that contains 200 units. So would I still get an overstack penalty despite my splitting up of the units?
How exactly is "damage" modeled in this game? If I bomb a hex and my bomber gets reduced to 1 hit point it can still manage to fly back to base. Is this damage "repaired" again fully the next turn at no cost? Or does it require supply to bring it back to full repair? Does the "readiness" value reflect a damage state? I understand the concept of "readiness" as combat effectiveness but I'm still confused as to it's relation to hit points and damage.
Is there any point in causing structural damage to a city that is below it's "auto repair" value? If I bomb or bombard a city and cause 300 structural damage is this basically a waste of time, as it will be fully repaired next turn.
Is there actually any point in having rear area HQs staffed at all? I assumed for a long time that staff would be needed not just to give combat/ morale bonuses but also to transfer supplies. But as an experiment I disbanded all staff in Supreme HQ, and found that it had no effect on actual supply transfer at all. Since then I have only had staff in HQs close to fighting.
Do urban hexes or ports actually give ships an protection? I have read VR Designs War College and it said that urban hexes give subs protection. Yet the stats on screen don't say that ships or subs have any entrenchment bonuses when in a urban hex.
And finally what is the best way to give bombers fighter escort? Should you directly put fighters into a bomber division, or create a separate fighter division and send both the bomber and fighter divisions to a bombing raid? Or is there any difference?