Page 1 of 1
SOLVED 3.2.0 FR PART attacking with cooperating PARA?
Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2021 10:41 am
by Angeldust2
It is Land Combat Declaration Phase. In the previous Paradrop phase, the Allies have succesfully paradropped a CV PARA near to Channel Coast and a US PARA in Provence. Both are next to FR PART. Only the 2-1 PART is offered for combat declaration. Can the 0-1 PART attack as well in conjunction with the CW PARA, with 0 combat value but in order to be taken as a loss?
RE: FR PART attacking with cooperating PARA?
Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2021 10:46 am
by Angeldust2
Although at least the 2-1 FR PART is offered for land combat declaration, it will not join the attack of the US PARA against the notional. Program displays message, the PART cannot attack into the hex in question, because some of the units attacking cannot cooperate. But FR is shown under relations as cooperating with both US and CW.
.gam is attached.
RE: FR PART attacking with cooperating PARA?
Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2021 10:49 am
by Orm
No, the 0 strength partisan may not attack, nor may it attack with the PARA. For two reasons that I can think of.
1) A land unit can only attack if it has 1 or more combat factors.
2) The partisan does not co-operate with either the US nor the CW PARA and may not be included in an attack with them. Partisans only co-operate with other units from their own country.
RE: FR PART attacking with cooperating PARA?
Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2021 10:50 am
by Orm
ORIGINAL: Angeldust2
Although at least the 2-1 FR PART is offered for land combat declaration, it will not join the attack of the US PARA against the notional. Program displays message, the PART cannot attck into the hex in question, because some of the units attacking cannot cooperate. But FR is shown under relations as cooperating with both US and CW.
.gam is attached.
Works as it should. Partisans co-operation differ from how the controlling nation co-operates.
RE: FR PART attacking with cooperating PARA?
Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2021 11:30 am
by Angeldust2
Understand. Thanks, Orm.
RE: FR PART attacking with cooperating PARA?
Posted: Thu Feb 04, 2021 4:43 pm
by Joseignacio
ORIGINAL: Orm
No, the 0 strength partisan may not attack, nor may it attack with the PARA. For two reasons that I can think of.
1) A land unit can only attack if it has 1 or more combat factors.
2) The partisan does not co-operate with either the US nor the CW PARA and may not be included in an attack with them. Partisans only co-operate with other units from their own country.
I agree with the second point but I doubt the first one, I believe they could attack with a regular unit and take a loss, I think I saw it somewhere.
Unfortunately, I made searches in RAW7, RAC, and Clarifications and cannot find it. Somebody else can comment? out of curiosity.
RE: FR PART attacking with cooperating PARA?
Posted: Thu Feb 04, 2021 5:41 pm
by Courtenay
11.16. LAND COMBAT
ELIGIBLE LAND UNITS
You can only attack a hex with organized land units that are adjacent to the hex (or invading or paradropping into it).
A land unit can only attack if it has 1 or more combat factors.
RE: FR PART attacking with cooperating PARA?
Posted: Fri Feb 05, 2021 2:39 pm
by Centuur
The same text can be found in RAW...