Beethoven (Soviet) vs HLYA (Axis): '41 Campaign
Posted: Sat Jul 09, 2022 9:22 pm
This is an AAR for a 1941 campaign between me and HLYA.
I will post a small amount of content in real time here on the forum (probably mostly showing Axis turn 1), but other than that I will generally be posting the Soviet perspective here on the forum with a delay of some TBD # of turns. This is so that I can post un-censored screenshots showing my units, their strengths, etc. If I posted un-censored screenshots like that in real time, I have little doubt that HLYA could pick apart my defense like Michaelangelo chiseling away at his masterpiece, David.
So, I will also be posting real time screenshots on discord in a separate AAR, here: https://discord.gg/FDeFYnNZDG
HLYA won't be able to see that, but verified/known players can receive a discord role to be able to see it. Alternatively, if you wait, more or less the same basic content will show up here on this forum AAR.
HLYA will also be doing his own AAR on discord, here:
AAR channel: https://discord.gg/QTfZFAmnqS
AAR Comments channel: https://discord.gg/rjZJwyx4pz
I will be reading HLYA's AAR, at least initially. However, if/when we get to the point where Soviets are on the offensive (winter, presumably), then I will likely stop reading it, at least temporarily, since it is primarily the player on the offensive who can gain a benefit from reading an opponent's AAR. We'll figure it out.
To see HLYA's AAR, you will need to be a verified/known player to avoid alts similarly to my discord AAR. However, I may end up posting some screenshots etc from HLYA's discord AAR on the forum, with his permission until HLYA decides to start posting his AAR on the Matrix Forums.
We are playing "no early end," but I will keep track of the VPs/checks for "sudden death" so that we know if any sudden death victories would be triggered, and will report on that in the AAR. For my part, I will do my best to avoid any situation which would trigger an Axis "sudden death" victory, the difference is just that if it is triggered, the game won't be automatically ended without us also deciding it should end at that point.
Settings:
AI Air Assist off
Theater boxes unlocked
House Rules:
1) No temp motorization
2) No paradrops
3) No naval invasions
Additional House Rules added on turn 5:
4) No airfield bombing.
5) No conducting deliberately failed attacks just as a means to getting planes to join a battle.
6) Until turn 10, if you want to do ground attack, the settings must be approved by the other player.
7) Until turn 10, we are going to continue allowing ourselves to freely change air doctrine settings and also to set non-default settings for air missions. This will allow a bit more time to test things out with the air war and see what counter-measures we can come up with in response to what the other player does. However, on turn 10 we are planning to switch to some stricter rules regarding air doctrine and mission settings, which will more or less mean we both have to stick to default settings (specifics pending).
Soviet self-imposed rules:
1) I won't take advantage of exploits that are not WAD but which Joel has confirmed can't be feasibly fixed at the moment like e.g. spamming small air missions, exceeding guards limits or other build limits by exploiting airborne/whatever, merging non-isolated but doomed units to rescue the equipment, or anything like that which might come up.
2) Regarding any new/unanticipated things that come up from new patches or unanticipated events in the game, I won't do anything to gain any advantage from anything that is unbalanced/bugged/broken. This also goes for anything that HLYA considers unbalanced/bugged/broken, even if I myself am not fully persuaded that it is game-breaking. If something comes up that is unbalanced/bugged/broken, Soviets are in my opinion strong enough to give up any possible advantage gained by the unbalanced/bugged/broken thing so that the game can go on. For example, if something comes up that is bugged or wrong regarding the air war, I can just not use the VVS until it is fixed, and am perfectly happy to allow the Luftwaffe free reign (I don't think I really need the VVS, anyway). Similarly, if something comes up that is bugged or wrong regarding Panzers being weakened too much by a new patch, I can sacrifice some Soviet units to compensate for it (I don't think I really need every last Soviet unit, anyway). ... etc, etc, etc...
I will post a small amount of content in real time here on the forum (probably mostly showing Axis turn 1), but other than that I will generally be posting the Soviet perspective here on the forum with a delay of some TBD # of turns. This is so that I can post un-censored screenshots showing my units, their strengths, etc. If I posted un-censored screenshots like that in real time, I have little doubt that HLYA could pick apart my defense like Michaelangelo chiseling away at his masterpiece, David.
So, I will also be posting real time screenshots on discord in a separate AAR, here: https://discord.gg/FDeFYnNZDG
HLYA won't be able to see that, but verified/known players can receive a discord role to be able to see it. Alternatively, if you wait, more or less the same basic content will show up here on this forum AAR.
HLYA will also be doing his own AAR on discord, here:
AAR channel: https://discord.gg/QTfZFAmnqS
AAR Comments channel: https://discord.gg/rjZJwyx4pz
I will be reading HLYA's AAR, at least initially. However, if/when we get to the point where Soviets are on the offensive (winter, presumably), then I will likely stop reading it, at least temporarily, since it is primarily the player on the offensive who can gain a benefit from reading an opponent's AAR. We'll figure it out.
To see HLYA's AAR, you will need to be a verified/known player to avoid alts similarly to my discord AAR. However, I may end up posting some screenshots etc from HLYA's discord AAR on the forum, with his permission until HLYA decides to start posting his AAR on the Matrix Forums.
We are playing "no early end," but I will keep track of the VPs/checks for "sudden death" so that we know if any sudden death victories would be triggered, and will report on that in the AAR. For my part, I will do my best to avoid any situation which would trigger an Axis "sudden death" victory, the difference is just that if it is triggered, the game won't be automatically ended without us also deciding it should end at that point.
Settings:
AI Air Assist off
Theater boxes unlocked
House Rules:
1) No temp motorization
2) No paradrops
3) No naval invasions
Additional House Rules added on turn 5:
4) No airfield bombing.
5) No conducting deliberately failed attacks just as a means to getting planes to join a battle.
6) Until turn 10, if you want to do ground attack, the settings must be approved by the other player.
7) Until turn 10, we are going to continue allowing ourselves to freely change air doctrine settings and also to set non-default settings for air missions. This will allow a bit more time to test things out with the air war and see what counter-measures we can come up with in response to what the other player does. However, on turn 10 we are planning to switch to some stricter rules regarding air doctrine and mission settings, which will more or less mean we both have to stick to default settings (specifics pending).
Soviet self-imposed rules:
1) I won't take advantage of exploits that are not WAD but which Joel has confirmed can't be feasibly fixed at the moment like e.g. spamming small air missions, exceeding guards limits or other build limits by exploiting airborne/whatever, merging non-isolated but doomed units to rescue the equipment, or anything like that which might come up.
2) Regarding any new/unanticipated things that come up from new patches or unanticipated events in the game, I won't do anything to gain any advantage from anything that is unbalanced/bugged/broken. This also goes for anything that HLYA considers unbalanced/bugged/broken, even if I myself am not fully persuaded that it is game-breaking. If something comes up that is unbalanced/bugged/broken, Soviets are in my opinion strong enough to give up any possible advantage gained by the unbalanced/bugged/broken thing so that the game can go on. For example, if something comes up that is bugged or wrong regarding the air war, I can just not use the VVS until it is fixed, and am perfectly happy to allow the Luftwaffe free reign (I don't think I really need the VVS, anyway). Similarly, if something comes up that is bugged or wrong regarding Panzers being weakened too much by a new patch, I can sacrifice some Soviet units to compensate for it (I don't think I really need every last Soviet unit, anyway). ... etc, etc, etc...

















