Page 1 of 1

I want my money back

Posted: Wed Sep 03, 2003 1:35 am
by Real and Simulated Wars
from the following war games I bought before:

Blitzkrieg (a tiny cute war where tanks don't see more than 20 meters ahead)
WWII Batlefield Command (a full 3D game with line of sights of 30 meters in which a inf squad can demolish a 3-story building with grenads!)

What was I thinking?
Developers are dumbing down good ideas just to sell, it is awful.

P/S: Got AA:RDOA. Excellent war game. With this, Cpts Proctor's Brigade Combat Team and Korsun Pocket I feel like I am in heaven.

Posted: Wed Sep 03, 2003 1:53 am
by Kevinugly
I have the original 'Sudden Strike' with it's '..... Forever' expansion pack. I bought it some time ago and enjoyed playing it for a while but wouldn't consider going back to it now. It's very playable and looks great but is not particularly realistic in terms of its gameplay. However, without 'Sudden Strike' I doubt whether CDV would have wanted to publish AA:RDOA and Combat Mission in the UK and Europe and from there whether JustPlay would have taken on the Matrix games. World War 2 games are very popular at the moment and as long as there is an 'Airborne Assault' published for every 'Blitzkrieg' I'll be happy. :)

Posted: Wed Sep 03, 2003 3:09 am
by Fred98
What is “Brigade Combat Team”?

Posted: Wed Sep 03, 2003 3:14 am
by Real and Simulated Wars
Sorry! I meant Armored Task Force. You will find it interesting:

www.prosimco.com

Continous time, tactical wargame set in the present day.

Enjoy!

Posted: Wed Sep 03, 2003 5:43 am
by Sarge
Chelco wrote:from the following war games I bought before:

Blitzkrieg (a tiny cute war where tanks don't see more than 20 meters ahead)
WWII Batlefield Command (a full 3D game with line of sights of 30 meters in which a inf squad can demolish a 3-story building with grenads!)

What was I thinking?
Developers are dumbing down good ideas just to sell, it is awful.

P/S: Got AA:RDOA. Excellent war game. With this, Cpts Proctor's Brigade Combat Team and Korsun Pocket I feel like I am in heaven.
Give EYSA a look, its 3d squad combat. It has been revamped from GIC and it looking real nice. I know first hand some of the work that has gone it to the game and it is no-were near the old GIC. I like to think its as close as a wargame has come to ASL one of my all time favorites of the old school table tops. RTS in 3D

Posted: Wed Sep 03, 2003 4:56 pm
by Real and Simulated Wars
Yes sarge, I'm in there too. Actually, I bought GIC out of my waiting anxiety. I had 3 battles that were awesome. Looking forward for EYSA, hope the middle Sep release figure is accurate.

Posted: Thu Sep 04, 2003 10:52 pm
by Hertston
Kevinugly wrote: However, without 'Sudden Strike' I doubt whether CDV would have wanted to publish AA:RDOA and Combat Mission in the UK and Europe and from there whether JustPlay would have taken on the Matrix games. World War 2 games are very popular at the moment and as long as there is an 'Airborne Assault' published for every 'Blitzkrieg' I'll be happy. :)
Just as long as bloody cdv never get their claws on any Matrix games (long live Justplay). I've had quite enough of Wafflegrenadiers, thank you.

It's a little unfair to compare games like Blitzkrieg, Sudden Strike etc with "real" wargames like KP, ATF and Combat Mission. Different genres for different markets - Sudden Strike has far more in common with Starcraft than it does with AA:RDoA.

Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2003 5:35 am
by Kevinugly
Hertston wrote: It's a little unfair to compare games like Blitzkrieg, Sudden Strike etc with "real" wargames like KP, ATF and Combat Mission. Different genres for different markets - Sudden Strike has far more in common with Starcraft than it does with AA:RDoA.
Not taking exception ;) , but it is the same subject matter. I would hope that somebody, somewhere might play Sudden Strike, find their interest piqued, and progress from there to more 'serious' wargames. Games like KP, AA:RDoA, and even Combat Mission can be more than a bit daunting to the novice gamer and 'serious wargaming' is a genre that can always do with some 'new blood' if you'll excuse the expression.

Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2003 6:52 am
by brent_2
Joe 98 wrote:What is “Brigade Combat Team”?

this was the precursor to Armored Task Force, very good game, although I had some issues with the interface

ATF is supposed to be better

Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2003 6:46 pm
by riverbravo
Chelco wrote:from the following war games I bought before:

Blitzkrieg (a tiny cute war where tanks don't see more than 20 meters ahead)
WWII Batlefield Command (a full 3D game with line of sights of 30 meters in which a inf squad can demolish a 3-story building with grenads!)

What was I thinking?
Developers are dumbing down good ideas just to sell, it is awful.

P/S: Got AA:RDOA. Excellent war game. With this, Cpts Proctor's Brigade Combat Team and Korsun Pocket I feel like I am in heaven.

Man,you gotta be careful buying wargames.Sadly the hobby is infected with bunk titles as well as companies who dont know what year ww2 started much less a wargame.

Stick with Matrix products and the games you see the regs on the forum frothing about and usualy you are in business.

I myself dont consider Sudden Strike or Blitzkrieg to be a wargame.They are horde games were you throw youre horde mindlessly into the enemies horde and hope you got more fire-power.

Chances are the devs are not dumbing down their ideas,they never had a good idea.

Posted: Tue Sep 23, 2003 8:16 pm
by Crimguy
Hey Chelco:

Are you the Chelco from the old icrontic.com site? I don't remember if he spelled his screenie as chelco or celco.

Just curious.

Posted: Tue Sep 23, 2003 8:37 pm
by Real and Simulated Wars
Crimguy wrote:Hey Chelco:

Are you the Chelco from the old icrontic.com site? I don't remember if he spelled his screenie as chelco or celco.

Just curious.
No, sorry. I have never logged in there.

Posted: Wed Sep 24, 2003 9:23 pm
by hank
In the last couple of years the only game I returned for my money was Panzer Elite Gold. Just wouldn't work on my computer ... not saying it couldn't but I was unsuccessful. ...and I returned Sudden Strike because it ran like a snail on my dual Pentium III with a Gig or ram and cutting edge graphics card ... I just couldn't figure out how to get it running better. :confused:

At the time I was big into SteelBeasts and am anxiously awaiting its next Release. Its great because you can play it as a simulator (as gunner or commander) or play it tactically from the map views. Plus there is multiplayer thru IP and a large following of good guys to play against.

All the games I've bought recently I've enjoyed: PzCamaigns Kursk, Sicily, Fulda Gap and Middle East; SSG/Matrix Korsum Pocket (I'm really enjoying right now ... and can't wait for more).

I've down loaded the Armored Task Force Demo (which is a great demo) ... I enjoyed it but didn't buy it. I downloaded TacOps demo and it was a little too slow for my liking. I'm also interested in Decisive Action but I run Win2000 and all the literature I've seen says its only for Win95/98.

Right now I'm looking forward to buying AA: Highway to the Reich. Does anyone know when it will be out on the shelves or available at the online stores ?

hank

Posted: Mon Sep 29, 2003 6:49 pm
by xambrium
Chelco wrote:from the following war games I bought before:
WWII Batlefield Command (a full 3D game with line of sights of 30 meters in which a inf squad can demolish a 3-story building with grenads!)
Did you mean WW2:Frontline Attack, or the BidmapBrothers WW2 Game?
Battlefield Command is from MaddoxGames and the Release is in 1/2Q 2004.

Posted: Wed Oct 01, 2003 6:12 pm
by HitMan52
hank wrote: Right now I'm looking forward to buying AA: Highway to the Reich. Does anyone know when it will be out on the shelves or available at the online stores ?

hank
Last time I checked EBgames had it posted for October 13th shipping though I wouldn't bet on it :( Based on what the update thread is reporting I would expect HttR to be available by the last week in October at best or at worst, early November.