Page 1 of 1

Naval Warfare

Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2026 5:05 pm
by macgregor
Let me just take a moment to thank, whoever developed the naval warfare (Ralph?). This is precisely what I was going crazy about in the dev thread. Some people don't care about larger, more inclusive scenarios. I remember Golden Delicious was quite open about it. Thankfully it didn't have to affect land warfare one bit.

Naval warfare may seem tricky at first. But it does work.

I still think this game is about as realistic as it gets for turn-based. From here, most improvements would be superficial. Sure, could there be more air missions, unit formations, and of course graphic resolution and I dare say, animation.

I'm not interested in adding complexity. If it's something the leader would pass to a subordinate, or organize itself by default, throwing it on the player's lap I see as unnecessary. Pdox did this with Hoi3 and Hoi4. Easy to digest intelligence limited by fog of war, that allows one to make informed decisions asap is what I want.

It would be nice if there was a way for more than 2 players to play this game, so that teammates could move simultaneously. Perhaps an online file that could be updated from several sources with some indicator that they've all moved.

Re: Naval Warfare

Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2026 6:13 pm
by Curtis Lemay
macgregor wrote: Sat Nov 14, 2026 5:05 pm Let me just take a moment to thank, whoever developed the naval warfare (Ralph?). This is precisely what I was going crazy about in the dev thread. Some people don't care about larger, more inclusive scenarios. I remember Golden Delicious was quite open about it. Thankfully it didn't have to affect land warfare one bit.

Naval warfare may seem tricky at first. But it does work.

I still think this game is about as realistic as it gets for turn-based. From here, most improvements would be superficial. Sure, could there be more air missions, unit formations, and of course graphic resolution and I dare say, animation.

I'm not interested in adding complexity. If it's something the leader would pass to a subordinate, or organize itself by default, throwing it on the player's lap I see as unnecessary. Pdox did this with Hoi3 and Hoi4. Easy to digest intelligence limited by fog of war, that allows one to make informed decisions asap is what I want.

It would be nice if there was a way for more than 2 players to play this game, so that teammates could move simultaneously. Perhaps an online file that could be updated from several sources with some indicator that they've all moved.
Lots of stuff we don't have yet and are needed to get Naval Warfare right:

1. Ship-board torpedoes.
2. Submarines (Patrol Zones & Snorkeling ability)
3. ASW (Sonar ability)
4. Physical Sea-lift equipment (both for lifting units and logistics). (Throw in air-lift equipment too).
5. Naval Reaction.
6. Naval Disengagement.
7. Terrain enhancements to Port facilities (Port Ship Harbor Capacity; Port Cargo Transfer Capacity; Ship Repair Capacity (drydock); Ship Production Capacity, etc.).
8. Engineering Construction/Damage Repair abilities (Port/Airfield/Fortification/road/railroad construction/repair etc.)
9. Mines (land and sea). Including mine layers/sweepers.
10. More detailed ship features (Secondary/tertiary armaments; armor and armament configurations => impacting facing) Also, ship upgrade options. Camouflage (dazzle patterns)/Stealth architecture & coatings.
11. Wooden and ironclad warships. Perhaps including rams, grappling, & boarding.
12. Wind (strength & direction), Oar (fatigue), Steam (Coal, Oil, Nuclear) propulsion.
13. Hoovercraft.
14. Icebreakers. (And Frozen Deep/Shallow Water terrain)
15. Vastly expanded ship classes.

Probably plenty I'm forgetting (or haven't thought of yet). For sure, improvements are coming in the Next Update (whatever comes after the Current Update).

Re: Naval Warfare

Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2026 9:35 pm
by macgregor
That would be phenomenal!

Re: Naval Warfare

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 7:55 pm
by golden delicious
Curtis Lemay wrote: Sat Nov 14, 2026 6:13 pm 5. Naval Reaction.
Without this- the ability for naval units to act autonomously on the opposing player's turn - the whole solution doesn't work. At typical TOAW scale combinations, naval movement rates are so enormous that naval forces can sail serenely past their opponents, just out of range of their guns, and then back to safety as long as they do it all on the same turn.

In the meantime, a goodly number of land/sea scenarios built prior to TOAW IV are broken. More will be broken when Bob bans manually disembarking in coastal hexes without anchorages- can we at least make this a game option?

Re: Naval Warfare

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 11:00 pm
by Curtis Lemay
golden delicious wrote: Wed Nov 18, 2026 7:55 pm
Curtis Lemay wrote: Sat Nov 14, 2026 6:13 pm 5. Naval Reaction.
Without this- the ability for naval units to act autonomously on the opposing player's turn - the whole solution doesn't work. At typical TOAW scale combinations, naval movement rates are so enormous that naval forces can sail serenely past their opponents, just out of range of their guns, and then back to safety as long as they do it all on the same turn.
Gotta be out of range of the air units on Sea Interdiction too. Not just the guns. But, I did list Naval Reaction as necessary.
In the meantime, a goodly number of land/sea scenarios built prior to TOAW IV are broken. More will be broken when Bob bans manually disembarking in coastal hexes without anchorages- can we at least make this a game option?
I suppose. Are you sure there's no terrain kluge available that would keep this invasion kluge working? Anchorage in deep water?