Page 1 of 1
Capture of an atoll by the Japanese.
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 7:29 pm
by cirrius06
Hi everyone.
I am having trouble capturing atolls in the Pacific, where Japanese forces significantly outnumber the Marine defenders. Even with a 2-to-1 or 3-to-1 numerical advantage—and despite naval bombardment—my forces have been nearly wiped out during the initial landing phase on both Palmyra and Johnston.
The scenario takes place in late 1942.
My question is: do you think intensive aerial bombardment should be added before the landing ?
Re: Capture of an atoll by the Japanese.
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 8:33 pm
by Jim D Burns
I'm Pat's opponent, he has had a very difficult time of it trying to invade first Palmyra (not Johnston) and now Christmas Island. In both cases he has naval bombarded my units on the turn he lands, but he has not launched air attacks.
To give a little more context, here is a cut and paste of the last attempted invasion turn:
Night Naval bombardment of Christmas Island at 174,141
Japanese Ships
CA Mikuma
CA Nachi
CA Myoko
CA Tone
CL Agano
DD Wakatake
DD Namikaze
DD Tachikaze
DD Minekaze
DD Mochizuki
DD Hatsuharu
DD Samidare
DD Yudachi
DD Harusame
DD Murasame
DMS W-21
DMS W-9
Allied ground losses:
197 casualties reported
Squads: 0 destroyed, 1 disabled
Non Combat: 4 destroyed, 24 disabled
Engineers: 1 destroyed, 0 disabled
Guns lost 9 (2 destroyed, 7 disabled)
Vehicles lost 4 (2 destroyed, 2 disabled)
Resources hits 1
Light Industry hits 1
Airbase hits 47
Airbase supply hits 9
Runway hits 88
Port hits 17
Port fuel hits 7
Port supply hits 2
E7K2 Alf acting as spotter for CA Mikuma
CA Mikuma firing at Christmas Island
CA Nachi firing at Christmas Island
CA Myoko firing at Christmas Island
CA Tone firing at Christmas Island
CL Agano firing at Christmas Island
DD Wakatake firing at Christmas Island
DD Namikaze firing at Christmas Island
DD Tachikaze firing at Christmas Island
DD Minekaze firing at Christmas Island
DD Mochizuki firing at Christmas Island
DD Hatsuharu firing at Christmas Island
DD Samidare firing at Christmas Island
DD Yudachi firing at Christmas Island
DD Harusame firing at Christmas Island
DD Murasame firing at Christmas Island
DMS W-21 firing at Christmas Island
DMS W-9 firing at Christmas Island
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pre-Invasion action off Christmas Island (174,141)
Defensive Guns engage approaching landing force
61 Coastal gun shots fired in defense.
Japanese Ships
DD Fubuki
SC Ch 12
SC Ch 4
LSD Akitsu Maru
DD Yuzuki
Allied ground losses:
27 casualties reported
Squads: 0 destroyed, 1 disabled
Non Combat: 0 destroyed, 2 disabled
Engineers: 0 destroyed, 1 disabled
Guns lost 1 (1 destroyed, 0 disabled)
DD Fubuki firing at 102nd Combat Engineer Regiment
SC Ch 12 fired at enemy troops
SC Ch 4 fired at enemy troops
DD Fubuki fired at enemy troops
Defensive Guns fire at approaching troops in landing craft at 5,000 yards
Defensive Guns fire at approaching troops in landing craft at 1,000 yards
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Amphibious Assault at Christmas Island (174,141)
TF 80 troops unloading over beach at Christmas Island, 174,141
Japanese ground losses:
143 casualties reported
Squads: 0 destroyed, 22 disabled
Non Combat: 0 destroyed, 11 disabled
Engineers: 0 destroyed, 0 disabled
Guns lost 4 (0 destroyed, 4 disabled)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Invasion Support action off Christmas Island (174,141)
Defensive Guns engage approaching landing force
35 Coastal gun shots fired in defense.
Japanese Ships
DD Fubuki
DD Minegumo
SC Ch 12
SC Ch 4
LSD Akitsu Maru
Allied ground losses:
50 casualties reported
Squads: 0 destroyed, 2 disabled
Non Combat: 0 destroyed, 6 disabled
Engineers: 0 destroyed, 0 disabled
DD Minegumo firing at 1st/102nd Infantry Battalion
SC Ch 12 fired at enemy troops
SC Ch 4 fired at enemy troops
DD Fubuki fired at enemy troops
Defensive Guns fire at approaching troops in landing craft at 1,000 yards
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Invasion Support action off Christmas Island (174,141)
Defensive Guns engage approaching landing force
28 Coastal gun shots fired in defense.
Japanese Ships
SC Ch 12
SC Ch 4
LSD Akitsu Maru
DD Minegumo
DD Fubuki
Allied ground losses:
14 casualties reported
Squads: 0 destroyed, 1 disabled
Non Combat: 0 destroyed, 1 disabled
Engineers: 0 destroyed, 0 disabled
SC Ch 12 fired at enemy troops
SC Ch 4 fired at enemy troops
Defensive Guns fire at approaching troops in landing craft at 1,000 yards
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ground combat at Christmas Island (174,141)
Japanese Shock attack
Attacking force 2716 troops, 24 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 98
Defending force 4243 troops, 59 guns, 31 vehicles, Assault Value = 144
Japanese adjusted assault: 12
Allied adjusted defense: 156
Japanese assault odds: 1 to 13 (fort level 4)
Combat modifiers
Defender: forts(+), disruption(-), experience(-)
Attacker: shock(+), disruption(-)
Japanese ground losses:
1744 casualties reported
Squads: 88 destroyed, 24 disabled
Non Combat: 0 destroyed, 38 disabled
Engineers: 0 destroyed, 0 disabled
Guns lost 11 (9 destroyed, 2 disabled)
Assaulting units:
41st Naval Guard Unit
44th Naval Guard Unit
Defending units:
102nd Combat Engineer Regiment
Fanning Island Det.
1st/102nd Infantry Battalion
3rd/102nd Infantry Battalion
1/198th Coast AA Battalion
E Det USN Port Svc
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ground combat at Christmas Island (174,141)
Allied Bombardment attack
Attacking force 2083 troops, 28 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 144
Defending force 1342 troops, 14 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 10
Assaulting units:
1st/102nd Infantry Battalion
102nd Combat Engineer Regiment
Fanning Island Det.
3rd/102nd Infantry Battalion
1/198th Coast AA Battalion
E Det USN Port Svc
Defending units:
44th Naval Guard Unit
41st Naval Guard Unit
For whatever reason, his naval bombardments are not damaging the combat units. All three non-combat units got tore apart with disruption over 80%. But the three infantry units had no disruption with two at 0 and one at 3. So it appears naval bombardments do not hit land combat units. The exact same thing happened in three or more attempted landing he tried at Palmyra.
I assume his units that land are heavily disrupted due to the malus indicated on the results above and my defending units defensive fire disrupts whatever squads managed to land intact before his units get to shoot and that forces his units into retreat, which for Japan means Banzai, so his units get almost wiped out to a man. But this is just an assumption on my part, I'm not sure. The only advice I managed to give him was to use his carriers to ground attack for a turn or two before he lands, but there is no guarantee the ground strikes will hit the combat units, so I told him to post here for more advice.
I know the number of troops landed at this invasion is low, but he greatly outnumbered a single Raider battalion at Palmyra in three or more attempts and had similarly devastating results every time.
Re: Capture of an atoll by the Japanese.
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 9:06 pm
by dcpollay
Just looking at the Shock attack, it's plain to me that on Christmas Island at least, you are not attacking with 2:1 or 3:1 odds. It's more like the attackers are outnumbered by 2:1, in troops, guns, and vehicles (which would include any armor). That's before you account for the level 4 forts that provide additional defense bonuses. Based on that, the assault was most certainly doomed to fail.
Did you have more troops than that? If so, perhaps they did not all unload during the invasion turn?
Were the attackers fully prepped for the invasion? Less than 100% preparation tends to have severe consequences during atoll invasions.
My two cents worth....
Re: Capture of an atoll by the Japanese.
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 9:58 pm
by cirrius06
The Japanese forces were unable to complete their landing during the first turn.
They had an average readiness level of 80%.
In fact, according to the reports provided by my opponent, the Japanese forces were not numerous enough to have any hope of victory.
Thank you for your help.
Re: Capture of an atoll by the Japanese.
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 10:01 pm
by Jim D Burns
Yeah, this combat was not a good example of the issue he is dealing with. He invaded Palmyra at least 3 perhaps 4 times. For 3 of those attacks all I had was a single raider battalion and he landed 3 SNLF type units and one regiment. All his attacks were wiped out almost to a man (I assume due to Banzai) with little to no allied losses. His frustration built up over those failed attacks and is what caused him to post today, this attack was a bad example to show, but digging through 400+ turns of combat reports to find an example of one of those landings was not something I wanted to do lol.
The only consistent thing in all the landings is his naval bombardments do nothing to disrupt my land combat troops. They are always at or close to 0 disruption, while everything else is trashed. That's why I said perhaps air bombardments might help, but there is no guarantee the planes will target and hit the land combat units.
Re: Capture of an atoll by the Japanese.
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 2:02 am
by rockmedic109
It looks like the cruisers were in a bombardment task force. Would they have targeted the combat troops if they were in the amphibious task force? This would explain the level of casualties that I recently suffered against the AI.
It looks like too few troops landing to me. Atolls are blood baths. Did all the troops land before the shock attack?
Re: Capture of an atoll by the Japanese.
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 6:48 am
by BBfanboy
First, a very good Detection Level is required for bombarding TFs to hit troop targets. That means starting Recon flights days ahead of the landings.
Troops are dug in while support units have to do their work above ground and leave their equipment like vehicles there.
Second, it is always a good idea to have a few cruisers or BBs embedded with the Amphib TF. They suppress the coastal batteries and some of the enemy fire at troops crossing the beach.
Third, TFs unload in the order of fighting troops, then light equipment like mortars and MGs, then heavy equipment like artillery and vehicles, and lastly supply. If you do not land supply before the troops fight, they will be handicapped by as much as 75% of their AV. Always load some ships amphibiously with supply only, then merge them with the troop TFs.
On atolls with their restricted maximum number of troops, it is better to land tanks and machine gun units to get higher firepower for the same number of troops. Artillery is good too, to bust enemy forts and tie up enemy arty in a duel.
At least one Corps or Army level HQ should be landed to coordinate the troops. It shows up as less disruption.
Do not use separate TFs for each unit being landed - defensive guns get to fire at each TF. If you combine them before landing they can't fire as often.
Re: Capture of an atoll by the Japanese.
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:59 am
by Chris21wen
What BBFanboy said also.
First Christmas Is is an Atoll all-be-it a large one so it falls under those rules for invasion.
Second your sending 120 AV average infantry to invade an atoll with between 80-100 AV with fortifications. You probably need a division and then more.
I'm assuming from the ship count your invasion TV is fast transport, not amphibious as you only has one ship capable of loading troops in an amphibious invasion and there are two units. There never gong to unload fast enough.
Third you have no HQs and no combat engineers for the forts, no artillery.
When's the date by the way.
Re: Capture of an atoll by the Japanese.
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 5:18 pm
by Jim D Burns
Thanks guys, been away from the game for so long none of this even occurred to me. It's amazing how much stuff you forget over time.
The battle above occurred in very early Jan 43. My opponent has invaded and taken all the bases south of Pearl and also Midway and Johnston. So this is a continuation of his strategy driving deep into the central pacific. He just ran into real difficulties trying to take Palmyra and when he finally gave up and bypassed it, his try at Christmas popped his patience bubble. All his attempts at Palmyra had plenty of troops, but digging through the combat reports to find them was too much for my lazy old self.
I should mention Pat is French so he has to translate everything we type and sometimes stuff gets lost/misunderstood in translation. Anyway thanks for the input.